Sunday, February 20, 2011

Ode to the Taco Mexicano

TLAQUEPAQUE, JAL, MX—When we last left off our story, your intrepid wanderers were hungry.  As we’ve already established, the main meal of the day here is at around two or three in the afternoon, so at about eight at night you need a little something to tide you over until breakfast the next morning.  This is where the taco comes in.  This is by no means the only dish served at cena, but it is my favorite.  Tacos are not just eaten at night either; it serves as a late breakfast, afternoon pick me up and late night snack—anytime is the right time for this little meat, cilantro and onion delight.

The key is to find the right place, of course.  Tacarías, or taco stands, can be found on almost every corner, but one must be choosey in picking the spot to chow down at.   There are more upscale places, like Tacos Providencia (that has very good tacos, some say the best in the city), that is housed in an actual building, with some of the trappings of a typical diner and appears to be following the health code.  But what’s the fun in that? You want to keep it real.  You want to hit the street.  You also want to avoid dysentery.  And I’ve got news for you, the locals do also.  If you see a taco stand and no one is at it, other than a lonely little guy with a sad, frustrated look, cleaver in hand, chopping away earnestly at the meat on his little wood chopping block, meat that no one will ever eat, stay away.  The odds are people got sick there and the word has gotten out.  If right on the opposite corner there is a stand with people standing ten deep to get at the carnal goodness awaiting them, step on line.  I’m sure the wait will be worth the wait.

Now there is one caveat to all this.  As is typical with me, I took formal Spanish lessons as I was ending my stay here in 2001 (long story).  The school I went to had flyers for the students alerting them to the dangers of eating food from street venders, especially tacos.  When I protested to my profesora that tacos were practically a food group unto themselves, she replied, “Oh, Tom, you’ve been here for three years. Your system is use to it.  These poor guys will get sick as dogs!” I dispute that a little, because my first week in Guadalajara in 1998 I ate at a taco stand in an abandoned lot from a guy who had his hibachi set up on the tailgate of a 1972 Ford Country Squire station wagon.  No worries, as the Aussies say.  But if you do have a weak constitution, or have never really tested the outer limits of you gastrointestinal system’s tolerances, stick to the diner.

Fr. Eric credits me with showing him the little gem that is El Rancho Blanco.  I’m not sure if that’s apocryphal, but Francisco Oriel, AKA Oso (Bear), who was the deacon in charge of my small group at the time, showed me the place one evening when he took the group out for supper.   Oso was, and I’m assuming still is, the king of the drive thru.  His dream was to be assigned to Piedras Negras, which is just across the border from Eagle Pass, Texas because there was a Wendy’s on the U.S. side.  He knew every burger joint in Guadalajara, as well as taco stand.  In fact he could locate any type of sidewalk venders you could think of: deep fried hotdogs mixed with French fries in paper bowl, churos, elote (corn on the cob smothered in cream and chili powder) tamales, tortas ahogadas (literally “drowned sandwich,” a hero of sorts, made with pork and submerged in a hot sauce that will make you beg for mercy).  Ah, I’m getting hungry just thinking about it.  I do believe Oso favored me a bit, because he usually included me in his clandestine late night trips to satisfy whatever craving he was having (What-A-Burger was his favorite spot). But, as usual, I digress.

Upon returning to Mexico a trip to Rancho Blanco was high on the priority list.  So after a day of hopping buses and running around town, we came back to the residence, cleaned up and made our way down through the Parian.  Rancho Blanco isn’t the hardest place to find, it’s pretty much a straight shot down one of the main street in Tlaquepaque.  But you have to go past the tourist area and into the neighborhood, a place most foreigners never wander.  The street at that point is not very well lit, and you do have to watch your step a bit.  But once you hit the karate school you know that you’re almost there.

Rancho Blanco is a small store front operation with a table and benches on the sidewalk, and a counter and table inside.  The portable grill and work station, about the size of a hotdog cart, is just inside the entrance.  Many times these places are on the sidewalk with a roped off area filled with pick nick tables.  Sometimes there is a counter around the stand itself. 

Anyway, Fr. Eric and I sat down at the outside table, just by the entrance and the waitress stepped up to take our order.  She was trying to suppress a laugh, because, I guess, she couldn’t figure out what we were doing there.  She talked slowly, correctly identifying us as Norteamericanos, but when we shot back our order, knowing the meat and trimmings we wanted without a pause her eyes lit up a bit.  I’m a suadero and chorizo man, myself; don’t forget the cilantro and onions.  And yea, bring he salsa roja, por favor. 

Within a few minutes, they arrive.  A plate of silver dollar pancake size tortillas filled with the meat of your choice.  Suadero is a cut of beef, that in many places can be gristly, but here is always lean. Chorizo is a red sausage, great with eggs.  On the table are placed clay jars of beans, extra onions, small bowls of red and green sauce (yes, hot, both of them) and limes.  I’m strictly a red sauce man, but many put the beans on top and maybe squeeze a little lime over the top, before putting on the salsa.  Ahh, heaven.   The tortillas are doubled up, and if you leave the bottom one they charge you less on subsequent orders.

Remember, you never order just one serving.  The first round is to test things out, trying different meats; bistec, cerebra, lengua, al pastor, whatever.  Then you zero in on what you like for the second and third rounds.  After finishing the first round of six tacos, I waved to the waitress who made the international sign for bringing the check, waving an invisible pen at an invisible pad.  When I told her that I didn’t want the check, but more tacos, she gave that wide eyed look again and said “de verdad?” (Really?)

Well, to make a short story long, we ate and were more than satisfied.  Back in the day I could have done a dozen blindfolded and fifteen, no problem.  But prudence made me stop with ten.  Many times the memories we have are greater than the reality, but I can say the tacos at Rancho  Blanco were as good as I remember them. 

Friday, February 18, 2011

Guadalajara, Day One

Just a bit of background for my faithful readers.  After my first year of theology study in preparation for priestly ordination, spent in Columbus, Ohio, I, along with two of my confrere, were sent to the Instituto Teologico Salesiano in Tlaquepaque, Mexico to study.  I spent three years in Mexico, between ’98 and ’01, and at our height we had eight American students in the community, along with Fr. Eric Wyckoff who was on staff. I came back once, in October 2001, as a “baby” priest to celebrate my ordination with the folks here. Fr. Eric is back on staff, after a stop in Rome to finish is scripture studies.  Now I’m back for a visit after all this time, and sharing my experience with you all.  I hope you enjoy. I'm having trouble uploading pictures right now, and I'll get them posted as soon as I can.

TLAQUEPAQUE, JAL, MX –The first full day of my return to Old Mexico was spent hitting some of the old places I used to go back in the day.  First stop was down town Tlaquepaque, to an area we always called the Parian, even though that’s the name of what purports to be the largest bar in the world.  The Largest Rip Off the Gringo Joint in the Greater Guadalajara Area is more like it.  If you do find yourself in this quaint little corner of the world there are far better places to eat and relax, like El Rio San Pedro or El Patio, located in the few blocks around the center square; places where the food is fantastic, and you won’t be taken advantage of.

Tlaquepaque is the indigenous name for this suburb of Guadalajara, which mean “place above clay land.” San Pedro is it’s “Christian name,” and locals often refer to it by its shorter designation.  They’ll run the two together (San Pedro Tlaquepaque) if they think you might get confused with other places, like San Pedro Vaticano (OK, maybe not with that San Pedro).

So after Padre Eric and myself made the rounds of the shops, we went back to the theologate for midday prayers and comida. This is the main meal of the day, and I must say the food has improved since I was here last.  Breakfast and cena, which is the light evening meal, were always pretty good, but the main meal was often found wanting.  As is the custom for Salesians visiting other Salesian houses, this was the moment I delivered some libations to the director of the community, Fr. Jesús, who in turn poured it forth for all the brethren assembled.

After lunch it was off to the Guadalajara, and trips to the Cathedral and some Catholic book stores.  It was my first time on a Guadalajara bus since 2001, but it was like I never left.  It’s six pesos now (roughly fifty cents) compared to three back in the day.  But with the weak peso the actual increase isn’t nearly that much.

I had forgotten what it was like to be stared at by a bus load of people as if I was, like a foreigner, or something.  Now, I pass for Latino quite often, or at least as long as I keep my mouth shut.  They usually don’t think I’m Mexican, but they’ll ask if I’m from Argentina or Costa Rica or something like that.  When Eric and I are together, or the lot of us piled on the bus back in the 90’s, there is no mistaking that we were from El Norte. So it was yesterday; a lady sitting alone, a couple of little girls, a teenage boy, all gawking at us (men, for some reason, are more subtle about it).  Then we open our mouths, English fills the air and the jig is up.  Sometimes someone will come up to us and try to impress us with their broken English they learned from watching the latest Bruce Willis move (these are usually men, being less subtle).  Since we always assume the next words after “hello, how are you,” and "are you Americans" is going to be, “do you have ten pesos,” we shoot an annoyed  look back or move to another part of the bus.

There are also street musicians that come on the bus and play a few songs on the guitar and pass the hat.  They might stay on for a stop or two, and the drivers let them on for free.  One time there was a man with a beat up boom box singing along to a cassette tape of ranchero music, poorly.  I was going to give him five pesos just to stop.  Other times it’s women or little girl dressed in traditional, but threadbare clothing or men with one arm simply begging.  In Guadalajara they either hop from bus to bus or stake out a spot under the colonnades.  In Quito, Ecuador the children will follow you for blocks, sometimes just to beg, other times to shine your shoes. 

This is not to make light of the situation.  Educational and economic opportunities that we take for granted in the States simply do not exist here.  The issue of immigration policy in the US needs to be debated, and I’m not sure either side has a monopoly on truth and morality (personally I’m for tightening the boarders but against wholesale deportations, for reasons I’ll get into at a later date).  But we shouldn’t wonder why so many people want to cross rivers and deserts to get to into the United States, and nothing gets me madder than branding people criminals who simply want to feed their families. I mean, didn’t anyone out there read Les Misérables. But I digress…      

Once we hit the main places we wanted to see we made a side trip to a large church just off the beaten path, El Templo de Expiatorio.  It’s a neo-gothic structure, plain by local standards, but I think it’s even prettier than the Cathedral because of its simplicity.  To be fair, they’ve done a lot of work on the Cathedral since I was here last, as well as the parish church in San Pedro.  There is scaffolding in the sanctuary of the Cathedral that tells me the face lift isn’t over.

We returned home, washed up, went to prayers with the Salesian community and then headed out again on a mission to find tacos, but not just any tacos.  We sought El Rancho Blanco.  To my Facebook followers I promised an account of this trip, but it will need to wait a bit.  It deserves its own post, so a little patience and it will be here.       

Thursday, February 17, 2011

Landed Safe

TLAQUEPAQUE, JAL, MX-I got in yesterday afternoon, safe and sound.  Fr. Eric picked me up at the airport, which has undergone quite a face lift since the last I was here.  The facade is different but the routine is  the same; go through imigration and then customs.  I wear clerical clothing when I travel (not all priest do), so I take for granted that people know what it means.  I get to the customs station, and one of the lovely ladies working the counter asked what I do for a living.  When I identified myself as a priest she acted surprised, like I was incognito or something.  I felt like saying, "No, I'm really not.  This is a Naru shirt. I'm here for the Relive The 60's Con."  Because of the anti-clerical laws here priests couldn't legally wear clerical clothing publicaly until about ten years ago.  But I mean all the priests on the telanovelas are in Roman collars, so I figured she should have been able to figure it out.

For having been gone ten years, the place hasn't changed that much.  The numbers in the theologate are down, which is one big differance.  This in spite of the combining of the Guadalajara and Mexico City communities.  I always had the sense that some of the social trends hit down here fifteen to twenty years behind us in the States, so that the vocation plunge the Salesians took in the late eighties, early ninties is effecting them now (very unscientific opinion, I admit).  But the spirit among the men seems good, and as the weekend goes on I'll fill you all in on more.  I'm especially looking forward to my visit to my old parish on be writing more before then.  I just heard the bell that means it's breakfast time.  Hasta later.

Monday, February 14, 2011

Reading Revelation Responsibly, Part 2

In the first part of my review of Michael J. Gorman's Reading Revelation Responsibly: Uncivil Worship and Witness, Following the Lamb into the New Creation I praised the book's readability and clarity, but still said that I couldn't recommend it to the general reader. Considering his mostly non-technical style and aim to give an answer to the more popular, but inaccurate, interpretations of the Book of Revelation, I have to think that he was shooting for a broader audience.  I mentioned the price, that is steep for a relatively thin paperback.  The other reason, not entirely unrelated to the first, is that Gorman puts forward some very controversial, if not really new, ideas that might end up distracting a reader new to the topic.  In other words, I don't think that this is the first book on the topic someone should invest their hard earned money in; maybe the third or the fourth.  I would hate to see someone abandon their search for the truth because they were given solid food when they needed milk at that particular moment.

I referred to Gorman's book as solid food, but that doesn't mean that I swallowed all of it.  He is trying to show that Revelation shouldn't be read like a code book; that the divine author is not trying to predict precise events in the future but rather showing people of all ages the pratfalls humanity falls into and the obstacles to true worship and devotion to God that never seem to go out of style.  In the end if we look closely at everything happening today we can understand that it's all just little bits of history repeating, as Shirley Bassey might say.  

So far, so good.  Next he points out that one of these obstacles to true worship of God is "civil religion," where devotion and the giving of qualities that belongs to God alone are transferred to the state.  Seeing your nation as being Divinely mandated somehow, or exceptional would be one such manifestation of this civil religion. Other examples include; to credit one's country with spreading and defending freedom, to justify their military activity by saying it saves others from tyranny, to build loyalty around a collection of "sacred texts" like constitutions or declarations of independence, and even reciting something like the Pledge of Allegiance could be a form of idolatry. He joins this with a critique of empire (with Rome as the template) that points in one direction: The United States of America.  Consistent with his interpretive method, it is not that the United States is the Babylon foretold in scripture, but rather that the U.S. needs to be examined in light of Revelation to see if it hasn't become the latest manifestation of the culture of death that the last book of the Bible describes (it's safe to say that his mind is made up on that point).  More precisely, the faithful disciple needs to examine his or her conscience to see if and how they are participating in this civil religion that Gorman describes.

Basically, to be a faithful disciple one must withdraw from the elements of culture and society that promotes the civil religion, while not withdrawing from society completely.  Saying the Pledge, as was mentioned before and joining the military are out (the later because it is an instrument of imperial oppression).  The mixing of religious and civil symbols, known as syncretism, is also a violation of the commandment to honor God before all else.  This means no national flags in church, not using "God Bless America" as a hymn on the Fourth of July, no praying for veterans on Memorial Day, among other things.  Only the mildest forms of patriotism pass muster according to Gorman.  He is clear that the Christian shouldn't live in isolation, but work to alleviate the sufferings of others and to work against the injustice caused by imperial abuses.


If what Gorman writes represents the default position of the disciple a question that comes to my mind is, what exactly is the role a Christian in public life?  Is running for office or accepting a government appointment a form of "serving the empire?" Most of these positions demand that the office holder take an oath to uphold the Constitution.  Is this a form of idolatry?  If so, is the role of the Christian reduced to marches, protests, voting and, in general, being some type of holy gadfly? Gorman makes clear that Christians are not to live in isolation, but reject those parts of the culture that witness against Gospel values. Even with this important caveat I have a hard time seeing how being a good citizen and a faithful Christian can be reconciled using Gorman's reasoning, short of building a ghetto. 


I really do prefer to keep these posts short, so I will end it here.  This is just one problem I have with Gorman's analysis, and may return to discuss more problems that I have at a later date.  But my objections shouldn't be interpreted as meaning I didn't like the book; I did.  I am in complete agreement with his basic premise on how the Book of Revelation should be read and applied responsibly to our life.  I'm not in complete disagreement with his analysis of empire and its application to contemporary situations.  As Americans we need to have the courage to examine ourselves honestly, and not be afraid to admit when we, as a nation, have lost our way.  I just don't believe that patriotism is a vice, or reciting a Pledge that acknowledges God as a higher power than the state is a form of idolatry.

Friday, February 11, 2011

Reading Revelation Responsibly, Part 1

For at least the last forty years different Evangelical Christian groups have been predicting the glorious return of Jesus that will usher in the end of  the world.  They hold to a particular reading of the Book of Revelation that tries to find point by point correlations between contemporary events and the visions described in the last book of the Bible.  The idea is that if you connect the dots the right way you can successfully predict when the end is coming.  A major doctrine that they hold to is the Rapture; that true believers, those who have "accepted Christ as their personal Savior," will be taken up into the air to meet Jesus.  These blessed ones will avoid a seven year period of tribulation that the poor suckers left behind will suffer before Christ's visible return to earth.  This space doesn't allow for a full explanation of these teachings, but this link to Catholic Update may help. The Catholic Answers website also gives a thorough run down on this teaching.

To put it simply, Catholic teaching, as well as that of most Mainline Protestant churches, is that Christ will indeed return to gather the faithful together, but that the return of the Lord will be in one definitive event.  Why the disagreement?  A big reason is that many of the scriptural justifications given for the Rapture are not actually found in Revelation. The gathering of the saved by Jesus is found in 1 Thessalonians.  Luke 17:34-35 and Matt. 24:40-41both make reference to people being taken and left behind.  Even the figure most associated with the end of the world, outside of Jesus himself, the Anti-Christ, is found in the First and Second Letters of John, not in Revelation.  Whats more the term Rapture itself doesn't even appear in the Bible. These diverse passages have been taken out of context and cobbled together to to formulate a doctrine that is patently non-scriptural and foreign to Christian thought before it appeared in 1830.

All this would be the modern equivalent of arguing over how many angels can dance on the head of a pin, but that the teaching of the Rapture has become so pervasive through the popular writings of Hal Lindsey and in the "Left Behind" series of novels.  They have fostered an attitude that since the "true disciples" will be able to avoid the tribulations of the world, there is no need to worry about things like justice, the ecology and peace.  Let the world go to heck in a hand basket, I'm saved already!  There are also those who have adopted political views based on the idea that it will hasten the Second Coming.  For instance some Evangelicals support the State of Israel because, to their reading of things, Jesus can't come back until all the Jews have returned to the Holy Land.  I heard a Jewish commentator joke that they'll be waiting a long time since she has no intention of ever going to Israel. 

There have been many Catholic and Protestant authors over the last ten years who have written books to refute the claims of Lindsey and the others.  One such book came across my desk recently, with the rather long winded title of Reading Revelation Responsibly: Uncivil Worship and Witness: Following the Lamb Into the New Creation by Michael J. Gorman (he actually laments, jokingly, that the title wasn't longer). Gorman, a Methodist scripture scholar teaching at the Catholic St. Mary's Seminary and University in Baltimore, delivers a short but rich review and analysis of the Book of Revelation.  Rather than simply telling you how the Rapture folks are wrong, he shows you how to read Revelation in it's proper context so you can see for yourself what's in it and what it means.  He draws on contemporary and classical authors, both Protestant and Catholic, to show how the book was read in the past, and what light recent scholarship can shed on this very misunderstood piece of the scriptural canon.

While he writes in an accessible style that avoids a lot of theological jargon (and he explains what technical language he does use), I would hesitate to recommend this for the general reader.  Not the least reason is the price; it lists on Amazon at $25, for a paperback of less than 200 pages (I borrowed it, myself).  There are other, more popular and reasonably priced books like Will Catholics Be Left Behind: A Critique of the Rapture and Today's Prophecy Preachers by Carl E. Olson, that gives a more complete overview of the "Rapture" phenomenon, or Scott Hahn's The Lamb's Supper: The Mass as Heaven on Earth that brings the liturgical connection that Gorman points out into a more focused (and yes, Catholic) perspective. 

But I do not want to leave Dr. Gorman's work behind (excuse the pun).  It is a short book, but a powerful one, that puts foreword many ideas in its brief length.  It is also a challenging read, especially in its critique of empire in general, applying the qualities of empire to the United States, the role of patriotism in the life of the disciple and what a Christian's proper relationship with the economy and material possessions should be.  While I'm not sure I agree with the entirety of his analysis, it can't be easily dismissed, either. I have found my morning meditations the last week or so taken up with the chewing over of the ideas put forward here. Next time I'll continue by exploring some of the more controversial elements of Gorman's book.

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

Fr. Barron comments on "Inception"


Fr. Barron and I didn't exactly see eye to eye on True Grit, but are on the same page with Inception. As usual, he takes it to an entirely different level. Enjoy his insights on the Academy Award nominated movie.

Sunday, February 6, 2011

The King's Speech: Part Two

The Real Princess Elizabeth (future Elizabeth II), Elizabeth, Queen Consort, King George VI and Princess Margaret on VE Day, 1945
As I was watching The King's Speech the one question that kept on coming back to me was, do people get it? While the story focuses on Prince Albert's relationship with his speech therapist, the underlying problem that forces him to seek therapy to begin with is the Abdication Crisis that would drive his brother Edward VIII from the throne.  Edward as King was also Supreme Head of the Church of England, and was forbidden constitutionally from marrying a divorced woman whose spouse (in this case spouses) were still alive.  I was wondering how contemporary audiences would process this.  In the United States we have had a divorced, remarried man whose former spouse was not only still alive but quite in the public eye, as president.  In fact we celebrate his birthday today.  His name was Ronald Reagan (his ex-wife, actress Jane Wyman, had a successful television show during his presidency).  Presently the State of New York has a newly minted governor who is divorced and living in the governor's official residence with a woman not his wife, not even civilly. I could see people shaking their heads and saying, what's the big deal about who he wants to marry, or sleep with for that matter? It's his life isn't it?  What does it have to do with being a public official?

The real Lionel and Myrtle Logue in 1906
Since the producers have King George as the hero this time out the above tack wouldn't have been helpful.  One controversy about the movie is its highly negative portrayal of the Duke and Duchess of Windsor, with some historians saying it went little too far.  The film makers concede to the exaggeration charge, explaining it as a dramatic devise that sets them in clear contrast with our heroes.  While Wallis Simpson's marital status is brought up, more serious objections arise over possible affairs that she may have been having at the time, include one with an official of the Third Reich.  Both are characterized as pleasure seeking and self centered, little concerned with their duties and responsibilities.  This brings me back to the original question, do people get it?  I'm writing not primarily about the social convention and religious principle at work in the abdication of Edward, but in the deeper questions about duty and responsibility.  In our contemporary, therapeutic culture, what is most important is individual self realization.  In this light the greatest responsibility we have is to ourselves and our personal happiness and fulfillment. The Duke and Duchess could just as easily be cast as heroes of nonconformity and revolutionaries who helped break down out dated social norms.  To make King George's dilemma relevant for the modern viewer it was important to find some personal, "human interest" angle.  Simple fidelity to duty just wouldn't suffice.

Wallis Simpson and Edward, Duke of Windsor

The solution found in The King's Speech is to turn the meetings between "Bertie," (the King's nickname) and Lionel Logue into counselling sessions as opposed to elocution lessons, with the therapist trying to dig out the crisis of his client's childhood.  Louge sees the greatness within Bertie, and even surmises that he's seeking his help because he does indeed secretly want to be king in place of his brother.  Why shouldn't he? He's good enough, he's smart enough, and doggone it, people like him!  The theme of duty to country is not absent from the film, but there is this sense that this alone was not going to capture the imagination of today's audience.  They had to come at it with therapeutic themes of self realization, of the little guy overcoming his fears and anxieties (even if he is a fabulously wealthy member of the Royal Family) for people to be touched by it.

What's lost here is that the real George VI, against his own desires, fulfilled his duties while Edward put conditions on service, ultimately walking away at a moment his country needed strong leadership the most.  Both men could be cast as heroes using the "therapeutic method," depending on what aspects of the self actualizing ethic you wanted to accent.  But only one is a hero when selfless duty is made the standard, and I'm afraid it's not the Duke.  As an American I can't identify with the Divine Right of Kings, but as a Catholic Christian I can connect with the notion of God's call that asks that we put personal desires, even legitimate, deeply held ones, aside for the greater good.  This ideal of self sacrificial love goes back to the Master Himself, who gave up his life on the cross for the life of the world.  I don't claim to know the heart of either man, but one, at least on the surface, lived fully the call to service he was born to, if not by a Divine right, then by a Divine call.

That The King's Speech follows the more contemporary, Oprahfied approach does not change my opinion.  It is a well crafted film that I think is Oscar worthy. I wouldn't punish it for being a product of its age. I guess I'm just a hopeless romantic who would like to see a return to the days when duty, self sacrifice and courage were as honored as feeling good about yourself.

Saturday, February 5, 2011

The King's Speech: Part One

The King's Speech 
OOOO
Rated R for some use of strong profanity

When I was a cleric working summer camp out in Newton, New Jersey we had a display case in the main office that housed all the trophies that were going to  be given out for excellence in the various activities we offered.  Small trophies were given out weekly, but the ones that got most of the attention from the campers were the large year end awards.  The most coveted of these trophies was the Camper of the Year Award.  It wasn't uncommon to have a kid stand in front of the case on the first day of camp saying to himself, and sometimes even out loud, "I'm gonna win that sucker this year."  Then he would spend the following five weeks hitting as many activities as he could, volunteering for every skit, making sure he was an altar server when it was his cabin's turn, helping unload delivery trucks, setting up and breaking down activities, shinning shoes, peeling grapes, and generally sucking up to any counselor with a vote.  Sometimes this strategy backfired when the youngster's naked ambition was so obvious; I mean no one likes a brown nose.  But often you had to give it to him simply because, by gum, the little noodge set a goal and persevered, even if his motives were less than noble.

The Kings Speech, which has been nominated for Best Picture, is the cinematic version of that kid in front of the trophy case.  From the opening credits it's practically screaming for that little gold statuette.  You have all the usual suspects assembled to insure success;  A supporting cast that includes veteran British and Australian actors Helena Bonham Carter, Geoffry Rush and even that old Shakespearean stand by Derek Jacobi.  Colin Firth takes the lead, giving a performance the Academy stumbles over itself to award: his character has a disability (speech impediment), is haunted by childhood scars (mean nanny, disaffectionate  father)  in need of overcoming his insecurities caused by the above issues and cruelly exploited by his dashing older brother (The Man keeping him down).  It's an underdog story all the way, that dares you not to be touched. The period costumes and scenery are picture perfect and cinematography flawless.  Throw in that it was made in cooperation with the BBC, and you don't have to wonder that the movie oozes class.  There is no doubt in my mind that from the first moment the idea for this movie was born in the producers' heads they stood in front of that imaginary award case in their minds saying, "I'm gonna win that sucker this year."  And you know what? I say give it to them.

2010, in my humble opinion, was a down year, quality wise, at the movies.  While I have not seen all ten movies nominated this year, the ones I did see left me underwhelmed.  It's true that The King's Speech is not particularly innovative, and in many ways is rather predictable. Nonetheless it is a well crafted and well acted movie.  And it is touching.  I hated myself for being so touched, because I knew they were putting me on, and I didn't care; they did it so well.  My favorite scene is a very small sequence in the film, where Prince Albert, having just assumed the throne after his brother's abdication, goes home as King George VI and meets his daughters.  It's already established that he is an affectionate, loving father.  But when he meets Princesses Elizabeth and Margarete for the first time as king, they stand far off, with the future queen reminding her sister to curtsy before they address him, quite earnestly, as Your Majesty.  I felt heart broken for the man, since he never wanted the crown and its responsibilities, and now it had built a wall between himself and his own children.  Manipulative? Yeah.  But effective and well done.

The only flaw, and it is a minor one, is the actor they chose to play Winston Churchill.  To be honest at first I thought he was trying to do Charles Laughton, and failing miserably.  Out side of that one point, The King's Speech does everything else right.  And why not? It set a goal for itself and certainly tried hard enough to achieve it.  So just give the little noodge his trophy already.

Friday, February 4, 2011

Random Notes, 2/4/11

Egypt
It's hard not to get caught up in the events of the past week.  In many ways it reminds me of the fall of the Berlin Wall, in the sense that things are moving so quickly that it's difficult to keep track of things and understand their meaning.  It's also similar to he events of 1989 in that the unrest in Egypt is a part of a wider movement that began in Tunisia and seems to be picking up in Yemen. Where it will stop no one can guess.  The big difference, of course, is that the fall of the Eastern Block came about through the efforts of a democratic movement resulting in the fall of dictatorships and the rise of free nations.  What will happen in the Middle East is far from certain.  Iran, all those years ago, deposed a dictator but replaced him with a repressive theocracy.  We may all agree that Hosni Mubarak is no friend of liberty, but is his immediate ouster the best course for Egypt and the wider Middle East, and for the world at large?    

The Church generally does not support revolutionary movements, for the reason that they are usually violent, bloody and leave the country in question worse than before.  There are also other reasons that have to do with the Church's traditional views on earthly authority and its origins in Heaven.  But more recent pronouncements on the subject have tended to focus on humanitarian concerns.  This does not mean that the Church opposes changes in government and civil structures.  It's all in the way that it comes about.  It is well known that Pope John Paul II worked behind the scenes, as well as in front of the crowds, for the fall of communism in Europe.  But what he was advocating was change from within, done in a peaceful, just manner. Of course that "change from within" also included the personal conversion of the individuals who make up the body politic.  He opposed the revolutionary movements in Latin America because they were violent, with some even using the Gospel to advocate violence.  He knew that all the communist rebels were going to do was replace one oppressive regime with another.

I hope this is not the case in Egypt, but my hope is not strong.

I've begun to read a short work on the book of Revelation, and while it is timely to the topics of today, I'll wait before moving my reflections of world events into that direction.

On A Lighter Note: A Strange Coincidence

It was pointed out to me that since we are in the year 2011 there will be a lot of fun with dates and playing with numbers, like January 1 could be written 1/1/11 and in November we'll have 11/1/11 as well as the granddaddy of them all 11/11/11.  Not that I'm into numerology and such things, try this little trick at home:

Take the last two digits of the year you were born and add it to the age you will turn during this calender year, and see what it comes out to.  It should come out to the same number for anyone born in the last century. 

New Jersey's School Holidays

The New Jersey Department of Education just released a list of over a hundred and twenty religious holidays that a student could be excused from school for.  It represents a "minimum list" of holidays, and individual schools boards can add to it as they see fit.  All the major religions are there and even some not so major; even Wicca (are you a good witch or a bad witch?).  But clearly we have a problem.  Catholic feasts like the Immaculate Conception are lumped together under a generic "Christian" label.  Even the Orthodox get a separate mention for the Dormition of the Theotokos, which corresponds to the Assumption.  I mean, why should the Baptists get a day off for a holiday they don't even believe in?  (Nothing against Baptists, I love them dearly) Why should they ride on our coattails?  I mean, you don't see us taking Reformation Day off, do you?  The ACLU is going to hear about this! (OK, maybe not.)

Saturday, January 29, 2011

Fr. Barron comments on "True Grit" (SPOILERS)


A different take on "True Grit" from Fr. Robert Barron.

The Rite

The Rite O
(PG-13) for disturbing thematic material, violence, frightening images, and language including sexual references.

Oh, January, that cinematic landfill where Hollywood dumps movies they know are awful before they even roll the credits on the first preview. The newest entry in that long proud tradition is The Rite, an exorcism tale that hit the big screen this weekend.

The problem right off the bat with this well intentioned mess is that it gets its background all wrong (please don't let the "inspired by a true story" thing fool you).  Movies about police departments, the military or the legal system will go to lengths to achieve realism.  Directors and actors doing war pictures have been known to go through a truncated basic training, getting to know how a soldier operates in the field.  They'll at the very least talk to military people, past or present, to try and get it right.  Spielberg even had Holocaust survivors on the set on Schindler's List so their experience wouldn't be misrepresented.  No movie gets it all correct, and even last year's best picture winner, The Hurt Locker, took flack for alleged inaccuracies in its presentation of an army bomb disposal team.  But there is such a level of carelessness and ignorance in dealing with the Church and the priesthood in movies that it staggers my mind.  What's sad is that The Rite is actually sympathetic toward the priesthood and the idea of a divine call, and that it gets so much wrong is disheartening.

The story follows Micheal Kovak (Colin O'Donoghue) who enters the seminary because of family pressure (plausible if this was 1951, or maybe if we were in some parts of the developing world today, but not in the contemporary United States).  He goes, planning on ditching right before making his "final vows" that make him a priest (professing vows do not make you a priest, ask any nun you happen to run into.  In fact diocesan priests don't take vows at all).   Four years later a priest / mentor is concerned when Michael passes his psychology and sociology finals but fails theology (that would be like saying a law student failed "law" but passed British literature; it makes no sense.  By the time a seminarian gets to the seminary he's specializing in theology and studying its various branches, not taking "core classes" like an undergraduate.  In the same way a law student studies torts and copyright law, among other things, and not law in some generic form).   Michael tells the priest of his doubts and he sends the young man off to Rome to take a class in exorcism, hoping it will shake him out of his unbelief (I'm not even going to go there, it would take too long).  Once there he's sent to see Fr. Lucas (Anthony Hopkins) a reclusive Jesuit and experienced exorcist.  Michael is sceptical, which is all well and good, but his unbelief endures longer than is reasonable.  Fr. Lucas correctly states that the prayers of liberation can take weeks or months to wear the demon down and defeat him (I've even heard years), but Michael, at the end of the film, is able to accomplish in an evening what Fr. Lucas couldn't get done after months of effort.  I won't go through every problem with the film, it would take too long, and yes, it's Hollywood, and they're making a dramatic film, not a documentary.  But getting some details right would be refreshing.

This particular sub genre of horror film is different from pretty much all the others because it's dealing with something that's real. It's rare, to be sure, but real all the same.  We had an exorcist speak to us one afternoon during a spiritual theology class (my lone exposure to the topic in 13 years of formation, outside of a couple of books I read on my own) and he said he had performed three exorcisms in his 15 years on the job.  Most people have some psychological problem that demands therapeutic or pharmaceutical treatment.  But the power of the Evil One is real and not to be taken lightly.  The movie weaves between reverence and humor in a way I don't think was always intentional.  It takes a low key approach to the scenes of possession when compared to the granddaddy of them all, The Exorcist, which did go over the top.  But it's also less informed on it's topic, never bothering to go into the causes for demonic possession which, when taken into account, make the final plot twist implausible.

The movie's only saving grace is its positive portrayal of the Church, the priesthood and faith in general, which I didn't take as a put on.  The priests were sympathetic, but human as well.  While it tried to present compassionately the struggles a priest goes through, it still can't compare with the Exorcist in that regard, especially William Peter Blatty's novel.  The Rite presents a Catholic Church that simply doesn't exist in the real world.  As much as I'm glad Hollywood was friendly this time, I wish they were also right.

Monday, January 24, 2011

Who Knows Where the Time Goes

It's hard to believe that it's been over ten days since I last posted something here.  When I say it's been busy, I'm not making some vague generality.  A parish normally quiets down after Christmas with the lull lasting until Ash Wednesday.  Then it's breakneck through May, what with confessions, Lenten programs, the Easter Triduum itself, 1st Communions, Confirmations, the backlog of infant baptisms that have to wait until Lent is over, the spare wedding here and there.  Summer brings another lull of sorts before September when school and religious ed begin again and it's a blur until Christmas. But nothing stopped after Christmas, and now January is almost gone and I'm not sure where it went.

There are a lot things I would have liked to have done this month, especially considering the feast of Don Bosco is coming up next week (never mind that today is St. Francis de Sales' feast day).  Francis de Sales in many ways is a key inspiration for me in working on this blog.  He wrote an incredible body of work, much of it in simple pamphlet form, to convince people of the truth of the Catholic faith during the Counter Reformation.  While these works might be considered polemic in the sense that they addressed controversies, defending the Catholic position staunchly, St. Francis was the Doctor of Charity who understood that it was not bombs or guns that would bring the separated brethren back into the fold, but loving kindness, as well as passionate and intelligent apologetics. I hope to follow in that tradition in some small way.


But the time has been a dictator, as Nina Simone would say, and I haven't had the time or the energy to put my full efforts into this space.  But I know I need to get focused, and the best way to do that is by developing a theme over a series of posts, and I've got one (but I don't want to let the cat out of the bag just yet).  For the rest of this week I'll write more on Francis de Sales and Don Bosco in preparation for the feast, and then on to a topic that I've been mulling over for quite some time.


But time; what a mystery.  I offer you all one of the great songs on the topic of time and change, by Fairport Convention, with the late Sandy Denny on vocals.

Wednesday, January 12, 2011

Black Swan

Black Swan
MPAA: Rated R for strong sexual content, disturbing violent images, language and some drug use.
Catholic News Service Media Review Office: O (morally objectionable)

In my quest to catch as many movies that will be getting Oscar nominations as I can I took time out of my R&R and saw "Black Swan."  Normally going to the movies is a part of taking a break, but this time it was work.  This is not a film that I would usually go and see.  Of the roughly twenty people at the midweek matinee I attended, I was one of three men.  It looked like the others were brought by their significant others, so I'm guessing that I'm the only man who went of his own accord.  But what made this movie work for me wasn't that it's a film that appeals to women more than men, but in the morally confused compass that guides it.

From the beginning it's clear that Nina (Natalie Portman), an up and coming ballerina, is a basket case.  She's living claustrophobically at home with her overbearing mother (Barbara Hershey, reminding me ever so slightly of Piper Laurie in "Carrie"), she has a history of self mutilation, is repressed, passive, and lacks any self confidence (which makes me wonder how she got as far as she did in such a competitive field). Her director (Vincent Cassel) acknowledges her technical prowess, which makes her perfect to play the "White Swan" in Swan Lake but complains she doesn't have the passion to play the seductive "Black Swan."  But she unwittingly changes the director's mind by rebuffing his romantic advances with a well placed bite, revealing the fire just below the surface. 

But in winning the role she so covets poor Nina's problems only get worse.  She has competition from a sultry newcomer (Mila Kunis), who may not have Nina's skills but possesses the passion that makes her perfect for the Black Swan. She feels guilt over replacing the company's aging and self destructive star (Winona Ryder, in a bit of art imitating life).  She also descends into what can only be described as paranoid schizophrenia, at the very time she takes the director's advise to free herself through sexual experimentation.  She sees people who aren't there, her mother's paintings take on lives of their own, and the viewer begins doubting what is real and what is a product of Nina's increasingly deteriorating mind. 

A point the movie seems to be making is that true freedom and self actualization comes from the elimination of inhibitions and indulging in unfettered sensual pleasures.  Obviously, I don't agree with that, but the movie itself seems to under mind its own point, with Nina's increasing self actualization being accompanied by increasing levels of insanity.  After all the barriers are knocked down Nina indeed dances the ballet of her life, but at quite a cost.

In one of the literature courses I took in college the main character of a book we were reading had a transformation from a shy milquetoast to a rather bold assertive fellow after his first sexual encounter.  The professor explained that the author was trying to say that we don't become fully human until we engage in sexual activity, an opinion she concurred with.  My initial thought was:  Mother Teresa, John Paul II, Therese of Lisieux, John Bosco, oh yeah, they never really actualized themselves as human beings, did they?  "Black Swan" makes the same mistake my professor did all those years ago.  Being human is more complex than we understand, and while our sexuality is an important part of what makes us who we are, the contemporary mind has exaggerated its place a bit.  The people I mentioned above had great passion, and lived their human lives to the fullest even though all were life long celibates.  They found themselves by giving themselves to others in selfless acts of love.  Mother Teresa's writings reveal a woman of tremendous passion, but it was not focused inwardly.  It was pointed out to the world in the service of others.  Any other path leads to self absorption, and possibly self destruction.

To be fair Nina's transformation involves more than just a sexual awakening, and it is important to learn how to get up on your own two feet and stand up for your self.  But the movie, always dealing in extremes, has Nina embrace a total will to power.  Her coming of age is won after a totally unapologetic pursuit of her goals that tolerates no rivals.  She becomes completely focused on what she wants and is even willing to kill for it.  In the end I'm guessing the film makers want us to see Nina as a heroine.  I couldn't help but see her as a tragic one, destroyed by the very journey of discovery and self realization that was supposed to save her.

I would be amiss if I didn't mention the "strong sexual content" that the MPAA alerts viewers to.  I'm going to save a fuller exploration of sex in movies for a later post, but for now I'll say it is pretty strong stuff.  Nudity is avoided, but not much else is left to the imagination.  It strikes me that if the material is strong, you don't have to resort to explicit content.  While I don't agree with the world view the film puts forward (if it even has one), the material is strong enough, the performances good enough, that they didn't have to resort to shock.  But as I wrote, more on that later.

Monday, January 10, 2011

I Stand Corrected

In my review of the new Narnia movie I questioned how Susan and Peter, the elder Pevensie children, made it over to the US in the midst of World War II.  I have it on good authority that there was a wartime program of bringing children to the US to escape the Blitz.  One review I read later explained that as young adults the two had some service related jobs that brought them to the States.  Either way their transatlantic journey was not implausible as I first imagined.

Thursday, January 6, 2011

The Chronicles of Narnia: The Voyage of the Dawn Treader

Chronicles of Narnia: The Voyage of the Dawn Treader
OO 1/2
Rated PG for some frightening images and sequences of fantasy action. 

I am at a distinct disadvantage walking into any Narnia movie because I haven't read the books by C.S. Lewis that the films are based on.  Or maybe that's a good thing, since I can review the movie on it's own terms without nitpicking over whether they included every detail from the original stories.  This is not just idle chatter on my part, because if the new Narnia movie (Chronicles of Narnia: The Voyage of the Dawn Treader) falls short of it's predecessors, as I believe it does, it might be because they tried to include too much.  From the little I have read, of the three this film is the least faithful to its original text, and considerable simplifications were made. But the plot still takes too long to come into focus as they seemingly tried to cram as much as they could into a tween friendly 115 minutes.

The story begins with siblings Lucy (Georgie Henley) and Edmund (Skandar Keyens) living out the final days of World War II with their uncle and aunt in Cambridge while their older brother and sister are off in America (how they got there safely in the midst of the War is a mystery to me, but I'll let that one go by). The returning characters are joined by cousin Eustace (Will Poulter), a budding skeptic who has no patience for his cousins' talk of Narnia and other fairy tales.  Even after he gets swept into the fantasy world by way of a magical painting he doesn't believe what's happening is real, concluding it must be some perverse trick.  Ben Barnes returns from the last film as Caspian, though he's lost his mixed up Spanish-Eastern European accent and speaks as a Englishman.  They are now at sea, though the purpose of their voyage remains a bit murky. 

Since explaining the plot briefly is impossible, I won't. The problem with the story in general is that it takes too much time for the movie to decide on its objective.  We go through about three false starts before our intrepid adventures figure out what it is they were brought back to Narnia for. This was a bit frustrating, because just when it gets my imagination going, the film switches gears and moves into another direction.  Just as the action heats up, it stops abruptly to give us more exposition to set up the next episode.  It's not until the last third of the movie that things really begin to get going, and then it ends. 

That said, I'm recommending the movie, especially for younger teens.  There are solid lessons to be learned about courage, loyalty, resisting temptation, and self acceptance.  The action is solid, especially in the climactic sequence.  The returning actors know their roles, but don't seem bored by them.  While out side of Cousin Eustace there aren't any new characters to speak of, there is a clear passing of the baton that sets up the pictures to follow.  Does The Dawn Treader pale in comparison with the first two movies?  Yes it does.  But on a rainy afternoon it's worth the ride.  I just hope next time they trim the sails a bit.

Monday, January 3, 2011

Pizza and Wings

I hate decorating for Christmas.  Call me Scrooge if you will, but it just seems like a colossal waste of time and energy.  I don't mind Christmas decorations, mind you, I just don't want to be the one to put them up. Bah! Humbug!  So after wasting most of the Advent Season I got one of our parishioners, a young man who used to work in the office, to help me drag the artificial tree down stairs and decorate it.  It was just a few days before Christmas, and he came by after work.  After we got that and the Nativity scene set up and lit, we went out for pizza and wings. We were met by another of our intrepid youths.  Both guys are in their mid twenties, one got married this past spring and the other has been seeing a young lady for the last few months.  I'll call them Steve and Eddie, because they actually read this blog from time to time and I don't want to embarrass them.

After we settled into Michelino's, a pizza place up the street from the parish, Eddie, the newlywed, began peppering me with questions.  "What do you think of Fr. Benedict Groeschel?" "Do you believe Jesus really rose from the dead?" "Have you ever watched Fr. John Corapi?" "Do you really believe in the True Presence?"  These questions, and some others, weren't asked in an accusatory way.  It was more like a boxer feeling out an opponent in the early rounds of a fight.  He was trying to figure out who I was and what I was about (even though we had met years ago at a Salesian leadership retreat).  I've been blessed to have been to many talks and retreats given by Fr. Benedict, and admire him greatly.  I'm not as familiar with Fr. Corapi, but have caught his TV programs and radio shows, and like him as well.  As for the doctrinal issues, my only answer was that I wouldn't have given up marriage and family for a myth or a metaphor.

Eddie seemed relieved in a way at the answers I gave.  He said that I was one of the few priests he knew who held such "by the book" beliefs.  I was saddened to hear that, actually.  I don't consider myself too far in one direction doctrinally.  I'm not pushing for a Tridentine Mass to be said in my parish, though I have nothing against it.  There are people who think I should get more worked up over Catholic politicians who don't let their faith influence their politicking.  I tend to avoid controversy, really.  My forays into controversial topics here has been pretty limited, actually.  But there are certain basics we must hold to; such as the True Presence of Christ in the Eucharist, the bodily resurrection of Jesus, the supremacy of the Pope, devotion to the Blessed Mother, and the Virgin Birth, the great mystery we celebrate during the Christmas Season.  If not what is the point being a Catholic?

On a personal level, the answer I gave about living chaste celibacy for the sake of the Kingdom wasn't just some flippant remark.  If Jesus didn't really rise from the dead, if it was just some "spiritual" return, or a group hallucination, or, worse yet, a fabrication, than any sacrifice we make, even the smallest, is a waste of time, never mind the putting aside of family life.  It is that Jesus is Lord of life with power over death, the Bread of life that gives us his very self by way of the sacraments that makes the vows poverty and obedience, as well as chastity, worth living.  That Jesus' message of repentance and mercy needs to be preached to a new generation is what gives purpose to sacrifices religious and priests make.  That Jesus was an historical person, who lived at a particular time in a particular place; that the events of his life were witnessed to and handed down in both written and spoken form;  that his death had a special significance beyond that of other deaths; that his death did not end with the grave but in resurrection in a body, both glorified and tangible;  that we are destined for that same resurrection is the foundation of the faith.  Without it let us eat, drink and be merry, for tomorrow we die.

If I am one of the few "by the book" priests out there (and I know that there are a lot more than just me), then we can see why the vocation crisis is so deep.  If priests are skeptical about the basics of the faith, who will actually see the priesthood as something to aspire to?  If the Mass is just a memorial in the ordinary sense, why sacrifice to be able to celebrate it?  Young people do have generous hearts, but they want to give themselves for something real, not a fable.  If we don't believe it's real, they aren't either, or else they will believe in the truth but not in us as credible ministers of God's Word and sacraments. Either way we shouldn't wonder why so few are following in our foot steps.

Saturday, January 1, 2011

Snowy Day, Dream Away

First off I want to wish all of you a happy, healthy and prosperous New Year, filled with all the Lord's blessings.  It wasn't my intention to take over a week off from the blog, but since the passing this week of Fr. Hector Poulin, SDB most of my time was taken up with helping to coordinate the funeral arrangements.  This was Fr. Hector's last assignment before going to St. Philip's Residence in Tampa, Florida.  He had been suffering from Alzheimer's, and Fr. Pat Diver, my predecessor here, had done God's work caring for him until he needed more specialized care.  So we had the funeral here at St. Anthony's yesterday, New Year's Eve, with the burial up at our cemetery in Goshen, New York.  But I did start on a reflection on the weather before things got too crazy, and  here it is:

The best laid schemes of priests and pastors oft get buried under 31.8 inches of snow.  Last Sunday, the day after Christmas, I waited out the storm here in Elizabeth, hoping to get out Monday.  The last time I tried to beat a winter storm to New England I ended up right in the middle of it, crawling a long at 15 miles an hour, barely keeping on the road.  So I hunkered down for the night.  The next morning the sun was out, even if the birds weren't chirping, so I figured I could make my  get away.  I shoveled a path from the garage to the street and I tested out our new four wheel dive Honda.  Not that I'm trying to sell you cars folks, but it passed with flying colors.  It was after 1PM before I got going and figured the main roads would be cleared.  Needless to say the roads, even Elizabeth Avenue, were a mess.  Added to that, every entrance to the Jersey Turnpike was clogged with semis, vans and other assorted and sundry vehicles stuck in the snow.  No matter which approach I tried, the results were the same; there was no way to get out of Elizabeth.

The story was the same all over the Metro Area;  un-plowed streets, stuck cars and mass transit shut downs.  It would be easy to jump ugly on the poor sanitation department.  If it is true that the New York City sanitation worker's union was using the blizzard to stage a labor slowdown then you'd have a gripe, to put it mildly.  But we as a people have to come to grips with the fact that the government is not bigger than the weather.  There are going to be times when even the best, most efficient municipality is going to get overwhelmed by mother nature.  This was the type of storm that happens maybe once in a generation around here.  I'm not sure if it's more correct to say that we've been conditioned, brain washed or spoiled into believing that the government is some all powerful force that has the ability to save us in every situation, and make everything right in an emergency with time to spare.  But it just doesn't happen that way.  These are human institutions that can do great good, but are also limited and fallible.  As much as we don't want to believe it, the street isn't always going to get plowed quickly, the garbage picked up promptly and, more disturbingly, the ambulance might not always get there on time.

I'm not saying we shouldn't demand that the government do its job, but to understand that it doesn't replace our responsibility to prepare ourselves and use common sense in times of crisis.  Sometimes we should just stay home (memo to self on that one) and out of the streets, and enjoy the downtime while it lasts.  Also, people out of the streets means fewer cars stalled and abandoned that makes the city's job of plowing that much tougher.

Well, that's all I have to say about that.  But there is a wider point to be made about our reliance on government and whether we've become a nation of wussies (yeah, I'm going there).  More next time. 

Thursday, December 23, 2010

True Grit


True Grit OO 1/2
PG-13 for some intense sequences of western violence including disturbing images   

Back when I saw "The Social Network" I was surprised to see a trailer for an updating of the 1969 John Wayne western "True Grit."  The question that came to my mind immediately was, why?  Is Hollywood really so bereft of new ideas that it has to go back to retread a movie that was a bit behind the times even when it came out (remember that 1969 was the year "The Wild Bunch" was released)?  I have to be fair, and state upfront that I've never been a big fan of westerns.  I like John Wayne, but was more familiar with him in movies like "The Quiet Man" and "Flying Tigers."  It always struck me that the original "True Grit" was a bit overrated, as was the Duke's performance (if he was going to get an Oscar it should have been for "The Shootist," or maybe "The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance").  I know a number of Duke fans that are probably pretty sore at me right now, but that's the way it goes, Pilgrim.

My greatest fear when I saw that trailer was that this was going to be some postmodern, Sam Peckinpah meets Quentin Tarantino, bloodfest.  I was determined not to see it, but succumbed  to the temptation, mainly because it was made by the Coen Brothers.  The 2010 "True Grit," based, as was the original, on the 1968 novel by Charles Portis, is darker than the 1969 vintage.  This is to be expected considering the team tackling the project, but its no "re-imagining."  In fact I was surprised how much of the original dialogue was left in tact (I cheated and saw the John Wayne version again to prepare myself).  The violence here is more graphic, as you might imagine, but not over the top.

The Coen Brothers' goal was to be more faithful to the book, and from what I gather that is where the main differences between the two versions can be found (not having read the novel, I have to take their word for it).  So, It's the same story as the older movie.  14 year old Mattie Ross hires U.S. Marshall Ruben "Rooster" Cogburn to chase after her father's killer, Tom Chaney, who has escaped into Indian territory, and is thus out of reach of the local authorities.  They're joined along the way by Texas Ranger La Boeuf (pronounced La Beef) who wants to bring Chaney, who goes by several aliases,  back to Texas on a separate murder charge.

Jeff Bridges has the unenviable task of following the Duke into Rooster Cogburn's eye patch, and takes the sure road by moving the character in another direction.  Rooster is still a surly drunk, but he allows his face and eyes (I mean eye) to do more of the talking.  Any one is an improvement over Glen Campbell, who was shockingly awful as the La Boeuf  the first time around. In his place Matt Damon brings humor and, at times, his best Matthew McConaughey impersonation to the show.  The real revelation is young Hailee Steinfeld in the role of Mattie Ross, the 14 year old girl seeking to avenge her father's murder.  She has good presence on the screen, and comes off as smart, naive, tough and innocent all at the same time.  Not an easy task for an experienced adult actor to pull off, let alone an adolescent of any kind.  Josh Brolin, who plays Chaney, has very little screen time for someone who got his name listed above the title.  While he does what he can with the little screen time he has, he's not even the most interesting villain in the movie.  That distinction has to go to Barry Pepper who plays the leader of a gang Chaney has joined up with.

The Coen Brothers are talented film makers, and "True Grit" is very well made.  While the film displays their trademark use of light and dark, comic and action timing and a generally engaging visual style, I found this a very straight forward movie, which is a change for them.  This is possibly because they weren't looking to reinvent the wheel this time out, as much as grease it up a bit. 

For all my reservations walking in, this ended up being a movie I wanted to like and recommend.  It was slow in parts, but the Coens always seem to bring you back to something interesting eventually.  Through it all the question that came back to me was why was this movie made to begin with?  I won't spoil the end, which differs in some specifics from the original, but to say we get to see Mattie as an adult.  We see the consequences of her journey, and I could only wonder if it was worth it.  Roger Ebert and the late Gene Siskel use to always criticize films that used children in danger as a plot point.  They felt it was cheep and exploitative.  This doesn't exactly fall into that category, but Mattie sees and does things that no 14 year old should have to.  In a sense we see her innocents taken from her before our eyes.  There is no way that the physical and emotional scars she experienced didn't change her, and not for the better. The ending doesn't take that into account, one way or the other.  The film makers never ask the deeper questions, which is a missed opportunity, really.  Unlike most Coen Brothers movies I can think of we have the style, but it's not serving any real purpose.

I've started giving these "hallow" ratings, which is all a bit of a lark, to tell the truth.  But I actually had trouble deciding on a number rating for "True Grit."  The production values, the acting, the cinematography, the writing are all of the highest caliber.  But the lessons are murky, if at all, and that's a shame.  In a world ruled by violence and the will to power, "True Grit" seems to be saying that revenge is its own reward, no matter the cost.  In my book no amount of movie magic can make that right.  While I'll be rooting for Ms Steinfeld to get a nomination for best supporting actress (you could even argue best actress since the story is told from her perspective), I'll be hoping the Coen Brothers return to deeper waters the next time out.

Monday, December 20, 2010

Vocation Talk III

In wrapping up this series on vocations, it's important to acknowledge that God's call is a mystery that unfolds over time.  There may be a moment when we get a flash of recognition that points out for us the direction we should go.  But if we actually sit down and think about our life we can see how the Lord was preparing us for that moment of decision.  Some people don't get there because they've never been open to this idea that God is calling them to something.  Perhaps they've never had guides or mentors to help them.  Maybe they simply have never been evangelized properly.  It could be that they've accepted uncritically "the spirit of  the world" that tells us that our lives really have no meaning beyond what we decide as individuals; there is no need to reference anything or anybody outside ourselves, let alone God.  Worse yet are those who try to turn someone away from following a vocation, especially to the religious life or priesthood.  There may be the need to ask a person to wait before actually entering a formation program, especially if there are questions of maturity involved.  But to try to sabotage a vocation is a grave offense.  It is a denial that the vocation is God's, not ours, and needs to be treated like a gift that should not be obstructed, rejected or ignored.

While those who maliciously hinder someone from following their vocation have put themselves in a grave moral situation, those who have the call also have a responsibility to be open to where God is leading them.  This gets us back to my original point from the first post on this topic.  It is true that Don Bosco's belief that those who do not follow their vocation are going to Hell is extreme, and not the way we would present the issue today.  At the same time I'm not sure we haven't given in a little to the "spirit of the world' I wrote of above.  It's popular today to say that if we don't follow God's "Plan A" there's always a "Plan B."  God is merciful and will never abandon us to a miserable existence, but gives us all the opportunities we need to be happy in this life and be with him forever in the next, even if we don't do what he asked of us the first time around.

I don't disagree with this proposition, actually.  I do believe that God gives us more chances in life than we realize, even if we don't follow His so called "Plan A."  But our spiritual journey involves surrender to God's will.  This means that we put aside our own desires, wants and aspirations, pick up our cross and follow Christ where He leads us.  In doing this we end up fulfilling ourselves and using those gifts and talents we've received in a deeper way than if we had followed our own desires.  But if we say no to God the first time, will we have the spiritual wherewithal to say yes to "Plan B," "C" or even "D"?  It doesn't matter what we opt for, in the end life in Christ means self denial and submission to His will.  If we fail to do that then the question we need to ask is what kind of purgation are we preparing for ourselves.  If "No" has become the default position of our lives, than yes, I believe the eternal consequences may be even worse than a stretch in purgatory.

I have to state clearly that I reject any proposition that turns salvation into a formula and doesn't allow for God's mercy to breath.  I reject any doctrine that says "If you do A, B or C Heaven awaits, and if you do D, E or F Hell is a certainty." God's grace and mercy is greater than any theological formula.  But if we have set our lives on a course away from God's will we put ourselves in grave danger. The farther we move away from God the more difficult it is to steer ourselves back.  The more we become use to doing our own will without reference to a Divine call or standard the more it becomes a habit that proves harder and harder to break.  We may not always perceive God's call perfectly.  We may not even fulfill it perfectly.  We may have to struggle with pride and selfishness as we grope along the path of life.  But as long was we are moving with God, in the right direction, He will lead us home safely.  As long as we remain attentive and open, then we will be ready to see the other possibilities he has in store if we did pass on God's primary vocation for us.  But no matter the road we end up walking, it will always lead through Calvary first before bringing us to the Empty Tomb.

Sunday, December 19, 2010

The Fighter

The Fighter OOO

Rated R: officially for profanity, drug abuse and boxing violence. There is some mild sexual content, at least as mild as R rated movies go.

I must admit that I broke my number one rule in preparing for a movie review, which is not to read other notices before seeing a movie I intend to critique. I didn't read the entirety of Kyle Smith's review of "The Fighter" in the New York Post, and still haven't, but did see the first line as I was cruising through the website the other day.  He wrote, "Pity the boxing movie that thinks it can be both 'Raging Bull' and 'Rocky.'"  While I liked the movie more than Smith, that line kept coming back to me while watching the new Mark Wahlberg, Christian Bale vehicle.  For a moment I thought the quip was my original thought, but quickly realized that it was too good a line and must have come from somewhere else.  While the insight isn't original, its nonetheless true. "The Fighter" does try to play it both ways: it wants to be a gritty and realistic character study of self destruction and family dysfunction and an uplifting underdog story with a rousing ending.  It's not a great movie, and its weakness is this playing of both themes, the result being that "The Fighter's" conflicting spirits end up diluting each other.

The story follows the misadventures of Dickie Eklund (Bale), a drug addled, washed up boxer from the fighting town of Lowell, Massachusetts, and his younger half brother Micky Ward (Wahlberg), a promising young fighter trying to make it to where his brother never did.  Micky is managed by his mother and trained by the unreliable Dickie, both of whom seem to be using rather than really guiding him.  There is a menagerie of half sisters sired by I'm not sure how many fathers, that serve as comic relief of sorts (they remind me a little of a cross between the witches from Macbeth and the evil step sisters from Cinderella).  Throw into this the always watchable Amy Adams, playing against type as a tough working class bartender, and you get an interesting mix of characters in what amounts to an opera played at the poverty line.

It's easy to like the Wahlberg character, because well, he sort of plays this same likable person in every movie.  He does it well, so I won't knock it.  Bale and Adams are clearly bucking for Oscar nominations. For her part Adams is less flashy, but very convincing in her turn as a college drop out  whose life went into a direction she didn't plan.  Bale channels his inner Robert De Niro / Daniel Day Lewis, obviously having lost all kinds of weight for the part.  I didn't recognize him at first, he looked so emaciated.  He also does one of those total immersions into a character, were the viewer forgets the actor he or she is watching, a quality that has made Lewis so admired.  He's no Daniel Day, and it's tempting to accuse him of going over the top, but in truth I've met people like this;  braggarts and posers who really have nothing to back it up on the inside.  Does he over act? Yeah, a little, but in real life all self delusional Could-Have-Beens usually do.  

Just as Bale's performance begs comparisons to others, so does the entire style of the movie.  Director David O. Russell begins in a semi documentary mode, then moves into a more conventional film language as things proceed, but he always seems to hearken back to Marin Scorsese, especially in the soundtrack.  But unlike the Master, who uses music to evoke a mood and recall a particular time and place, Russell's choices are from all over the map and are only there because they might sound cool, not because they may actually comment on the action (think of the use of Donavon's "Atlantis" during the murder of Billy Batts in "Goodfellas").  He even has the audacity to use The Rolling Stones' "Can't You Hear Me Knocking," a Scorsese favorite. But true to form he plays Keith Richards' famous guitar intro and the song's rousing chorus, but omits any lines with drug references.  As with the rest of the movie, he want to keep it real, just not too real.  
   
In fairness, I liked the theme of conversion and redemption that the movie develops.  Dickie really is a different, better  person at the end of the story, and I didn't take that as a cop out.   As is my complaint with so many contemporary movies, they are so concerned with getting that happy ending and making everyone look good that the story loses its edge.  While I bought Dickie's conversion, I think the rehabilitation of Alice, their mother, was less believable.  "The Fighter" was made with the cooperation of its two real life heroes, so I can understand that they don't want to sell dear old Ma down the river.  But she is so unlikable all the way through the movie, and her actions so consistently self serving, I couldn't believe that it was all just some sort of misunderstanding.

So, this isn't a great movie, and will regrettably get the Oscar buzz it so craves but doesn't really deserve.  But for the performances of the central actors, including Melissa Leo, whose character Alice may have been unlikeable, but was always entertaining, I give this one OOO (3) out of four Hallows.