I'd been laboring over a post about the late comedian Lenny Bruce, when the news broke that Muhammad Ali's health was failing. When I went to bed last night Ali was still in the hospital battling a repertory ailment (one of a slew of illnesses he'd had to fight over the past three decades). This morning, he was gone.
The image that I saw accompany the story most often, from the Chicago Tribune this morning, where I first saw confirmation of his passing, to any number of sites on the web was of the iconic shot of him standing over a fallen Sonny Liston. It was their second fight, held on May 25, 1965 in the unlikely locale of Lewiston, Maine.
That photo of Ali (then still known as Cassius Clay), flexing his arm across his chest, built like a Greek god - his handsome, almost boyish face contorted into a mask of rage - roaring like a lion over it's conquered prey, became an icon. It indeed captured the essence of that young lion in his prime: defiant, strong, and proud.
He had already converted to Islam and would shortly make his name change legal and permanent. Like Bruce, a contemporary who's controversial stage act made him subject to arrest for violation of obscenity laws, Ali ran afoul of the law. In his case he refused induction into the military during the Vietnam War. While he didn't lose his freedom like Bruce did on several occasions, his stand cost him three years in the prime of his career. As Lenny Bruce found it almost impossible to get a gig, Ali couldn't book a fight since no state would grant him a boxing license. With his passport revoked, going overseas to box wasn't an option. He was a polarizing figure, and there were those who initially refused to call him by his Muslim name. His arch rival Joe Frazier always called him Clay just to get under his skin.
If he never had converted to Islam - allying himself with the Nation of Islam - or changed his name you could argue he probably wouldn't have gotten drafted to begin with. But he still would have been controversial. He was brash, quick witted, and boastful. He belittled his opponents verbally before humbling them physically in the ring. He said what was on his mind. Sure, some of it was show business: he had a lot of promoter in him, as well as fighter. But most of it wasn't an act. It was all Ali.
He would come back, becoming the first, and so far only, man to win the heavy weight crown three times - when being the Champ still meant something. I saw Ali relatively late in his career, vividly remembering him win that last title, reclaiming it from Leon Spinks. And I saw him when he could still jab and duck, weave and sting verbally. It was something to hear, and the saddest thing is that it's been three decades since the world saw and heard the legend in full.
This is but a thin outline. I'll be back with a deeper appreciation for Muhammad Ali. For now, I'll leave you with the image that tells the story.
Saturday, June 4, 2016
Friday, June 3, 2016
The Lesser of Two Evils is Still Evil
I watched a conference last night by Dr. Peter Kreeft, via You Tube, reflecting on the legendary 1978 Harvard commencement address of Aleksandre Solzhenitsyn, which he attended. Listening to his analysis, liberally sprinkled with quotes from the infamous speech, got a rant going in my mind. Solzhenitsyn's speech was no rant, but a very carefully crafted, spiritually informed, critique of Western Society in the last quarter of twentieth century. My words here, alas, are not so lofty. I can only hope someday to roughly approximate the Russian's wisdom and courage, and his rhetorical skills in expressing the truth. But for now, a few not so scattered thoughts, continuing my critique of this political season I've been engaging in of late.
I grew up in a partisan household where elections were approached as a matter of the Good Guys versus the Bad Guys. Even if the opposing candidate wasn't evil, his party was, and both had to be stopped if Western Civilization, or at least the Republic, was to survive. If your Good Guy wasn't the candidate you wanted from the beginning, and even if you had serious reservations, you voted for him because he was the "lesser of two evils." But what do you do when one evil seems just as evil as the other, but just in a different way?
This year I do not see any of the remaining declared candidates for President of the United States as having the moral fiber and / or competence to hold that office. Even taking into account that no president is ready from day 1 (each has had to grow in the job to one degree or the other), and we are electing a chief executive, not a pope, the choices this year are troubling. I do not see any potential third party alternative, or last second substitution for the presumptive nominees, that I would enthusiastically vote for either. This is because, no matter their personal qualifications, they are apart of a system has been rendered morally bankrupt, and whoever is elected will just perpetuate the bankruptcy. Though some candidates are claiming to be outsiders who'll shake up the status quo, in the final analysis the problem isn't the institution, its the hearts and minds of the people that is in need of shaking up.
To put it as plainly as I know how, culturally we are presently trapped in a materialistic, consumeristic, shell. Atheistic communism was defeated, but all that happened was that the world was made safe for agnostic capitalism. At least the Soviets had the conviction to say they didn't believe in God. We straddle the fence living in a perpetual doubt that we really don't want answered. Because if we answer that question it means we would actually have to commit to a way of life instead of living the illusion of plastic self determination and fluid identities. The consumerist culture doesn't challenge us, because all it is interested in is ever expanding markets. It doesn't judge, only affirms, in the hope that a new marketing beach head can be opened, and profits increased from the dollars syphoned off from the latest subculture gone mainstream. None of this encourages self examination, self doubt, or conversion of life. As long as the creature comforts are supplied, our basic assumptions left undisturbed, we are content to live in our shell.
Under these circumstances meaningful political change is practically impossible, never mind personal conversion, and what change can be had will be the product of unenlightened self interest or idealism divorced from reality. If the old cliche is true, that we get the presidents that the deserve, in this case we're getting the candidates that we deserve.
I am not saying that I'm not going to vote, or that you shouldn't. Voting is a grave responsibility that shouldn't be shrugged off or carelessly considered. All I'm saying is that as of June 3, 2016 there is no candidate that I have confidence in. The idea that I need to vote for one person because he or she, cankers and all, is still better than the alternative isn't good enough for me: not this election cycle anyway. I'm open to being persuaded, even by the present line up, as pitiful as it is. But if the choice is between two snakes, the fact that one's venom will take slightly longer to kill me is of little solace.
Thursday, June 2, 2016
The Divine Mercy of the Sacred Heart
![]() |
| An image of the Sacred Heart similar to what hung in my father's store |
In preparation for the Solemnity of the Sacred Heart I decided to put a few scattered thoughts together regarding this special devotion.
I've written before about my devotion deprived childhood. I went back to see where I wrote about it so I could link to the post, but I gave up the search. After six years and 774 posts (counting this one) I've lost track a bit of what I wrote where and when. Since I don't want to risk repeating myself unnecessarily, you'll just have to take my word on it: My, immediate post-Vatican II, generation wasn't schooled in the popular devotions of the Church the way previous generations were.
Which brings me to the Sacred Heart of Jesus. Growing up I saw the image in statue and portrait form, sure enough. We had an image of the Sacred Heart hanging high on the wall in my father's produce store, along with the Immaculate Heart of Mary, centrally located right across from the front doors, greeting everyone as they entered. I knew that the image was of Jesus, but I was always kind of befuddled by the exposed heart, looking not quite like a caricature, but not quite realistic either - kind of half way between the carnal and the cartoon like. It was never explained at the time, because I think my parents took for granted that it would have been explained in CCD (old school parish religious education classes, for you younger folk), and we weren't getting it in CCD because it wasn't a part of the curriculum. As I've said before, popular devotions were out of favor back in the '70's, so the image of Jesus' exposed heart, bound by the crown of thorns, bursting with light and flames was a bit off putting to me.
At the same time I was fascinated by this bit of iconography, and did do some reading up on it when I was older, learning about the 12 promises made to St. Margaret Mary Alacoque. Later, after I entered the minor seminary I read Cardinal Ratzinger's book Behold the Pierced One, which showed the continued relevance of the devotion in the face of contemporary objections. It had been a fabulously popular devotion for centuries, but fell almost completely out of favor after the Council due to the belief of some that it was unscriptural. You see, the heart itself is not a prominent biblical image. We who were brought up in the West identify the heart as the seat of emotions, but in the Bible, specifically the Old Testament, the kidneys, located deep in the interior of the person was so identified. It kind of makes sense if you sit and think about it, but nonetheless, culturally speaking, we can understand that flaming kidneys wouldn't quite have the same impact on us as a heart does, to put it mildly (it certainly wouldn't have made any sense to St. Margaret Mary). Short book that it is, it has been better than a quarter century since I read it, so I'm foggy on the details. All I know is that after reading the future Benedict XVI's modest treatise that image of Jesus' pierced heart, aflame and overflowing with divine love captured me once and for all.
This was because in the Sacred Heart I saw the interconnection of Jesus' humanity and divinity most clearly. We see Jesus the Son of God demonstrated by the miracle accounts, but otherwise the scriptures are spare, concise; defying any substantive psychological analysis of Jesus the man. Mark, in particular, describes Jesus' emotional state at times, but otherwise it's easy to walk away from the New Testament accounts with the image of a rather stoic savior. The Sacred Heart offers us a glimpse at a passionate man, deeply in love with His people. It is a love that is at once collective - for all humanity, but at the same time very particular. He knows each of us by name. He has counted every hair of our head. He known what is the best in us, but He also knows the evil that we are capable of - yet He loves us all the same. He desperately wants us to respond to His call, to accept his love, but Jesus won't force Himself on us. He pines like an unrequited lover when He is rejected, but never with bitterness. He loves, even to the point of giving His Body and Blood in sacrifice. He loves with a human passion, yet with the infinite power of God.
That Jesus would appear to St. Margaret Mary and speak of the love in His heart for us makes tremendous sense. He was speaking to her, a simple yet devoted daughter, in a language she could understand (and I'm not talking about French). By extension, He was speaking to the entire culture, and while the heart may not be a scriptural image of consequence, that God is Love, and that His love is passionate, is. Jesus was going to use whatever means necessary to get that vital message across. Unfortunately we missed the forest for the trees, getting hung up on, quite frankly, an esoteric detail and missing the larger, obvious message.
Over the past twenty years we have seen the rise of another popular devotion in the Church - the Divine Mercy. It looks similar to the Sacred Heart in many ways, and some see it as a rival to that older devotion. There has been objections to the Divine Mercy among some pastors and professional theologians as well. I heard one priest complain that it's a spiritual regression: a pre-Vatican II atavistic throwback promoted by "that Polish pope." I'll leave the meaning of the anti-Polish crack to your own surmising, but the objection overall is motivated by the assumption that the Council either discouraged or outright eliminated popular devotions, which is simply not true. Though the roots of the Divine Mercy go back to a time when the Sacred Heart was still very popular, I've often wondered if God wasn't anticipating the objections to the older devotion and sort of saying, "Okay, let's see'm say that My mercy isn't biblical." So, When the Sacred Heart fell out of favor, here's the Divine Mercy to pickup where it left off.
And here we need to make an important point: the Divine Mercy doesn't replace the Sacred Heart. The two devotions compliment each other. The Sacred Heart brings us deep into the psychological interior of Jesus. It shows us His motivation for going to the cross for us. As Pope Benedict would highlight in his encyclical, Deus Caritas Est, in Jesus we see eros and agape, the passionate and the unconditional forms of love as defined by the ancient Greeks, perfectly balanced. The passion He has or us (eros) is kept from being a selfish desire by his universal, unconditional love (agape), which in turn is kept from being impersonal and cold by the presence of eros. What then breaks forth from deep inside His very core is the Divine Mercy that is showered upon humanity. St. Faustina described Jesus' love (the Sacred Heart) as the flower and His Divine Mercy as its fruit.
The irony of all this personally is that even though I was taken up with the Sacred Heart a long time ago, I never really practiced the devotion with any regularity. On the other hand, I was one of those unsure about the Divine Mercy, coming to it in only the last few years, but now the chaplet is a regular part of my prayer life.
While the Divine Mercy has become important to me, I am very conscious of what lays behind it. Jesus' mercy bursts forth from a heart on fire with love. He wants us all to be saved, and His heart aches, longing for our return after we have sinned. Jesus is not some well intentioned, but distant philanthropist who loves humanity as an idea, but can't stand people in the flesh. He took on a human heart, not because He needed to, but because we needed to know unambiguously that God is love. He came and made His dwelling among us, sharing our joys and pains. He wasn't play acting, those emotions were real. The Sacred Heart of Jesus makes visible in invisible tenderness and passion of God. Jesus went to the cross not simply out of duty. Jesus was obedient, yes, but His was not a servile, grudging compliance to the Father's will. It was a loving embrace of humanity, but more powerfully a loving embrace of you and me on a personal level. Because of that self sacrificing love I know what Mercy is. Because the Second Person of the Trinity took on a human heart, I can see, touch and taste the invisible Divine Mercy everyday.
Saturday, May 28, 2016
Friday, May 27, 2016
Jesus, the Jews, the Eucharist and the Hermeneutic of Contenuity
I'm in the middle of reading two books right now. One is a book length interview of Cardinal Robert Sarah (I understand it should be pronounced sar-AH), the Prefect of the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments. It's called God or Nothing, and in it he he speaks of his early life growing up in Guinea, his years in priestly formation, and his becoming archbishop during a turbulent time in his nation's history (the interview is more far reaching than a simple autobiography, but that's what I'm up to at this point). The second is Jesus and the Jewish Roots of the Eucharist: Unlocking the Secrets of the Last Supper by Brant Pitre, a professor of sacred Scripture at Notre Dame Seminary in New Orleans. Since the Solemnity of the Most Holy Body and Blood of Christ is coming up on Sunday, I'll say a few words about the latter book. I will have something to say about Cardinal Sarah's book soon, though.
I haven't finished either book, so I won't be offering an actual review or exhaustive critique Mr. Pitre's work. But I do have some first impressions.
As Catholics, and I'm guessing this is true of Christians in general, we tend to have an ambivalent attitude toward Judaism. After a tragic history of mistrust that saw the Christian majority in Europe oppress and segregate the Jews for centuries, and then having to come to grips with the unspeakable barbarism of the Holocaust, we have tended to at once come to appreciate our Jewish sisters and brothers, and their religious and cultural heritage, but we also want to simply leave them alone. I mean this in the sense that we fear adding unintended insult to the very grave injuries they have suffered, so we will praise, but not really make any other observations.
Speaking for the Catholic tradition, the thaw in relations actually started before World War II, when Pope Pius XI opened up a dialogue with Jewish leaders as early as the 1920's (this initiative was unfortunately thwarted by more reactionary forces within the Curia), stating the incompatibility of antisemitism with the faith, and he famously proclaimed that Catholics are "all spiritual Semites."
While we have taken into account the difficult history between us in how we conduct our interfaith initiatives, there is no doubt that the specter of the death camps has influenced how we relate with our elders in the Faith in a particular way. We are careful not to target evangelization initiatives toward the Jews, so as not to appear to be proselytizing. While the average Catholic today is probably more aware of the Jewish roots of Christianity, and of Jewish practice in general, than was the case in generations past, it strikes me that the focus is still on the uniqueness of the Jewish religious tradition, both ancient and contemporary, as opposed to it's possible continuity with Catholic ritual and belief. I think I understand why we would want to show the proper respect. But in stressing the "otherness" of Judaism, while still recognizing it's beauty and power (I don't know about you, but I get teary eyed when I talk about the Ma Nishtana to my Scripture classes), are we not overlooking Jesus' claim that he came not to abolish the Old Covenant but to fulfill it?
Though his is a popular treatment, Mr. Pitre does an impressive job combing through, not just the Old Testament but, the Talmud and Mishnah as well: the vast collections of rabbinic commentary and collected Jewish oral tradition in order to understand what 1st century Jews would have been thinking about in terms of the coming of the messiah, as well as the nuances of Temple worship that aren't mentioned in the canonical Scriptures. Just as we have the concept of Scripture and Tradition, the Jews also have a body of non-canonical literature they rely on to help them understand the Bible and how it's been interpreted over the centuries (I'm not qualified to really speak to a comprehensive Jewish theology of revelation, but there is no doubt that these writings are very important to understanding their religious and cultural tradition). The picture that is presented is of a religious practice that is certainly unique, but with more similarities to Catholicism that you may have thought. He also over turns some accepted presuppositions we've been laboring under for years.
One such premise that we take for granted is that First Century Jews were anticipating a political-military messiah who was going to liberate Israel from Roman rule and reestablish the Davidic Monarchy. Pitre contends that this is only partially true. Many Jews were actually awaiting something greater than simply political and economic liberation: they were awaiting a new Exodus, with a new Moses who would repeat the miracle of the manna in the desert. The miracle of the manna only lasted as long as Israel was wandering in the wilderness, and was recognized as something supernatural in origin. As soon as they entered into the Promised Land the manna stopped appearing on the ground, as did the appearance of quail in the evening, through which God had supplied His people with flesh to eat, something also considered to be a supernatural occurrence.
The idea here is that Jesus is the new Moses, who inaugurated a new Exodus by His passion, death and resurrection (Luke's Gospel makes direct reference to this in it's account of the Transfiguration). But just as the Hebrews didn't go directly into the Promised Land after leaving slavery in Egypt, Christians are wandering in the wilderness of this world until Jesus returns to lead us into the eternal Promised Land; the Heavenly Jerusalem. In the meantime we have the new manna, the Eucharist, the Bread of Angels, to sustain us on the journey.
This is only one aspect of a rather complex and interconnected picture that Mr. Pitre offers the reader of ancient Jewish practice and its connection with the Catholic faith. I guess what I'm picking up after getting about halfway through the book so far, is that we tend to look at Christianity, and specifically Catholicism as some grand departure from the Jewish religion. In reality, if the entire record is examined, we come away with a clear continuity between the two traditions, that doesn't destroy the uniqueness of ether religion.
What I'm also seeing is the wisdom in the Catholic insistence on Revelation being contained in both Scripture and Tradition, not Scripture alone. While the Bible gives us the basis of belief, and nothing in the Tradition can contradict Scripture, the ongoing oral tradition, liturgical rites, commentaries by the Fathers and Magisterial pronouncements passed on through the ages sheds light on what the Scripture means. It tells us how the eternal Word has been applied in the concrete situations of history on planet earth, and again, shows forth the continuity of the faith guided by the Holy Spirit. The more I read the Old Testament the more I've come to see this continuity between the two dispensations. But it's subtle and can be easy to miss. When the extra-Scriptural Jewish sources are taken into account the connections become much clearer.
In all this, I've come to a greater appreciation of my own Catholic tradition, but this and other reading I've done in this vein, has also led me to a greater appreciation of the Jewish faith. It is unique, and needs to be cherished on its own terms. But it would be spiritual blindness on our parts to not acknowledge the clear continuity between our religions.
I'll finish both Cardinal Sarah's book and Mr. Pitre's, and have further thoughts soon.
Thursday, May 26, 2016
Qoheleth and the Chasing After Wind, 2016 Style
I've been laboring the past week or so to consolidate my thoughts, and give a spiritual explanation for the very concrete political issues that we are facing. I've written much that I've decided to put aside for now, but that I'll probably try to incorporate into future posts. But it's all rather unwieldy and disjointed, which means that I'll need more time to reflect on these things before really being able to articulate where I'm coming from. But if I were to try to encapsulate what I'm thinking, I would use the words of that ancient sage of the Old Testament Qoheleth:
I have seen all things that are done under the sun, and behold, all is vanity and a chase after wind. (Ecclesiastes 1:14)
A reading of the entire book will give you an insight into my thinking on this, but at least take a look at the first chapter.
Elsewhere in that chapter we are told that generations pass, but the rivers continue to run to the sea as always, indifferent to our existence. We are just the latest inhabitants in a long line that have come and gone since creation. Anything we think is new was done already by generations long past. It's just that we have no memory of these things, and the sad truth is that future generations will have no remembrance of us. I believe that this communal amnesia can be true in any society, but is especially acute in one like our own which has willfully abandoned tradition and rejected the transcendent.
In this we are actually faced then with a double dilemma: We are disconnected from a sense of history or tradition on the earthly level, but we are also cut off from a sense of the eternal. We are slaves of the present moment with nothing to guide us but the capricious dictatorship of our own emotions. All is a visceral chasing after the wants and desires of the moment. The present obsession with gender identity, for instance, is the result of a culture which has no reference point beyond five minutes ago, trapped in a self contained universe the size and consistency of a walnut shell. We are our own measuring stick of reality since there is no history, no tradition, no eternal outside our shells to consult. We are each the universal Magisterium of a personalized orthodoxy, and woe betide the person guilty of heresy against our personal dogma.
We know somewhere inside that this isn't right. We have a feeling somewhere in the deep recesses of our consciousness that we are being played; that we are being kept anesthetized by a chasing after technological gadgets. With head phones or ear buds firmly embedded, eyes pasted to the screen or vacantly staring into the mid-distance, these gadgets keep us cut off from active participation in the society by audio-visual narcotics - both soft and hard. The constant input from various media platforms feed us what we should think and how we should feel. This is simple stimuli though, fueled by raw emotion, not real substantial content. These entertainments keep us amused for a moment, but there isn't anything that forces the mind to think or question. Like a junkie we know that these electronic drugs are killing us, yet we're convinced that we'll die without them.
The crisis we face right now is that our political culture, like the rest of it, is also disconnected from temporal history and transcendent values. Religion, for its part, has been reduced to politics and politics has been made a religion. I'd say ideology has replaced religion, but I'm not sure we're that sophisticated these days. There is nothing wrong with politics, in its proper place. And it's not that it is necessarily subordinate to religion as an institutional reality (that's a different debate, I think), but it is subordinate to God and the values that flow from His eternal wisdom. Since our politics are disconnected from a sense of national tradition and eternal truth we are, again, left to the whims of the moment.
The discontent that has contributed to the rise of both Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders is rooted in that almost subliminal sense that the powers that be have been taking advantage of the present spiritual and historical disconnect to keep the masses chasing after the high tech wind, diverted by dead end self examinations, thus rendering us easier to control. Both men are appealing to some desire to recapture the vision of what being an American means, and Mr. Trump, at least, appeals to the idea that this is or was a Christian nation. Mr. Trump has no ideology accept raw nationalism, and Mr. Sanders' rage against the system is clothed in socialist principles, but his is still an emotional call to arms. Both men are charismatic in their own way, yet otherwise lack the standard resume of someone seeking the presidency, and that's the reason why they are making such an impact, and Mr. Trump as secured his party's nomination.
Because so many have flocked to Mr. Trump and Mr. Sanders doesn't mean that they are right to do so, or that these two people represent the best antidote to the current crisis. But Ted Cruse, along with any number of other contenders on his side, and Mrs. Clinton are the established order as far as many people are concerned. They are one's who have controlled the levers of power and are perceived as having led us down this path to begin with. They are being rejected because of this "insider" status, not in spite of it.
Some commentators are critical of the respective party faithful for having abandoned the reasoned, conventional approach. It is argued that they are reacting out of anger (which is at least partially true), or they are nostalgic for a white dominated America of the past (more than implying racism), or they are sexist against Hillary Clinton (which I find unpersuasive). There are many different other reasons I've heard as well, most rather conventional, much rather condescending: all a chasing after the wind. Because the people are turning over the system doesn't mean that they are wrong to be angry and fed up, or that they shouldn't demand something other than what the respective party apparatus is putting forward. But with no intellectual or spiritual roots grounding their anger, the electorate is grasping for the first charismatic leader they hear who's been able to tap into their discontent: Messieurs Trump and Sanders keep it simple, they keep it visceral. Their rejection of the establishment isn't just lip service, even if they're really not equipped to back it up once in office. But the desperate voter isn't thinking that far ahead, and so the chase for wind continues.
End of Part One
In this we are actually faced then with a double dilemma: We are disconnected from a sense of history or tradition on the earthly level, but we are also cut off from a sense of the eternal. We are slaves of the present moment with nothing to guide us but the capricious dictatorship of our own emotions. All is a visceral chasing after the wants and desires of the moment. The present obsession with gender identity, for instance, is the result of a culture which has no reference point beyond five minutes ago, trapped in a self contained universe the size and consistency of a walnut shell. We are our own measuring stick of reality since there is no history, no tradition, no eternal outside our shells to consult. We are each the universal Magisterium of a personalized orthodoxy, and woe betide the person guilty of heresy against our personal dogma.
We know somewhere inside that this isn't right. We have a feeling somewhere in the deep recesses of our consciousness that we are being played; that we are being kept anesthetized by a chasing after technological gadgets. With head phones or ear buds firmly embedded, eyes pasted to the screen or vacantly staring into the mid-distance, these gadgets keep us cut off from active participation in the society by audio-visual narcotics - both soft and hard. The constant input from various media platforms feed us what we should think and how we should feel. This is simple stimuli though, fueled by raw emotion, not real substantial content. These entertainments keep us amused for a moment, but there isn't anything that forces the mind to think or question. Like a junkie we know that these electronic drugs are killing us, yet we're convinced that we'll die without them.
The crisis we face right now is that our political culture, like the rest of it, is also disconnected from temporal history and transcendent values. Religion, for its part, has been reduced to politics and politics has been made a religion. I'd say ideology has replaced religion, but I'm not sure we're that sophisticated these days. There is nothing wrong with politics, in its proper place. And it's not that it is necessarily subordinate to religion as an institutional reality (that's a different debate, I think), but it is subordinate to God and the values that flow from His eternal wisdom. Since our politics are disconnected from a sense of national tradition and eternal truth we are, again, left to the whims of the moment.
The discontent that has contributed to the rise of both Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders is rooted in that almost subliminal sense that the powers that be have been taking advantage of the present spiritual and historical disconnect to keep the masses chasing after the high tech wind, diverted by dead end self examinations, thus rendering us easier to control. Both men are appealing to some desire to recapture the vision of what being an American means, and Mr. Trump, at least, appeals to the idea that this is or was a Christian nation. Mr. Trump has no ideology accept raw nationalism, and Mr. Sanders' rage against the system is clothed in socialist principles, but his is still an emotional call to arms. Both men are charismatic in their own way, yet otherwise lack the standard resume of someone seeking the presidency, and that's the reason why they are making such an impact, and Mr. Trump as secured his party's nomination.
Because so many have flocked to Mr. Trump and Mr. Sanders doesn't mean that they are right to do so, or that these two people represent the best antidote to the current crisis. But Ted Cruse, along with any number of other contenders on his side, and Mrs. Clinton are the established order as far as many people are concerned. They are one's who have controlled the levers of power and are perceived as having led us down this path to begin with. They are being rejected because of this "insider" status, not in spite of it.
Some commentators are critical of the respective party faithful for having abandoned the reasoned, conventional approach. It is argued that they are reacting out of anger (which is at least partially true), or they are nostalgic for a white dominated America of the past (more than implying racism), or they are sexist against Hillary Clinton (which I find unpersuasive). There are many different other reasons I've heard as well, most rather conventional, much rather condescending: all a chasing after the wind. Because the people are turning over the system doesn't mean that they are wrong to be angry and fed up, or that they shouldn't demand something other than what the respective party apparatus is putting forward. But with no intellectual or spiritual roots grounding their anger, the electorate is grasping for the first charismatic leader they hear who's been able to tap into their discontent: Messieurs Trump and Sanders keep it simple, they keep it visceral. Their rejection of the establishment isn't just lip service, even if they're really not equipped to back it up once in office. But the desperate voter isn't thinking that far ahead, and so the chase for wind continues.
End of Part One
Tuesday, May 24, 2016
Wishing You All a Blessed Feast of Mary Help of Christians!
A few thoughts, adapted from an article that
appears on the Salesian Sisters website, as we celebrate the Feast of Mary Help
of Christians Today:
Devotion to Mary Help
of Christians was spread far and wide through the work of St. John Bosco and
continues to be propagated in the world by the Salesian family which recognizes
and invokes Mary Help of Christians as its principal patroness. From the very beginning, St. John Bosco, the
great educator, placed his work as a priest and founder under the protection of
Mary Help of Christians, to whom he turned for every need. His confidence in Our Lady's help and protection
was greatest when when things were difficult or confusing, and he would often
turn to her, saying, "So, shall we begin to do something?” Don Bosco
placed all the works and religious communities he founded under her maternal
protection. In 1862, Don Bosco said to Fr. Cagliero, one of his early
Salesians, "Our Lady wants us to honor her with the title of Mary Help of
Christians. The times are so sad that we need the Holy Virgin to help us
preserve and defend the Christian faith".
The precious memory
that Don Bosco left us regarding great devotion to Our Lady Help of Christians
is two-fold. In the first place, Don
Bosco wanted us to be a living monument of gratitude to Mary Help of
Christians. The second is that he always
wanted us to know that Mary was a protector and guide for us . In a singular
experience which Don Bosco had on his last visit to the Salesian Sisters in Nizza,
Monferrato, Italy on August 23, 1885, he had a mystical experience that drove
this point home. After the new Sisters
had received their habits, and the young women had entered the novitiate, Don
Bosco, moved to tears, spoke to the Superiors who had gathered there. Several times, Don Bosco repeated: "Our Lady is really here, here in your
midst ... strolling in this House and the covers with her mantle."
As we celebrate this
feast of Mary, Help of Christians, may we always honor her by our holy lives
lived in faith for her Son, Jesus Christ.
DB Good Nights: Mary Help of Christians
I'm posting this in the morning even though this is a traditional Salesian "Good Night," but any time of day is appropriate to listen to this important message from Fr. Abraham, the Delegate for Youth Ministry for the Eastern Province of Canada and the United States. I hope all of you have a blessed and joyful feast of Mary, Help of Christians, the Madonna of Don Bosco!
Monday, May 23, 2016
Mary Help of Christians and Saint John Bosco
May 24 is the Feast of Mary Help of Christians, the Madonna of St. John Bosco. Here is an explanation of the devotion and the image that hangs in the basilica dedicated to her in Turin, which was built by Don Bosco in the 1860's. The video is put together by a Salesian from the Philippine's, featuring a commentary by Cardinal Joseph Zen, SDB.
Wednesday, May 18, 2016
Rules For Radical Chic
Most of my analysis of the 2016 election has been focused on the Republican side of the battle, but now I do want to change my focus to the Democrats.
In the last few days the MSM has begun to pay more attention to the divisions within the Democratic Party. In the public mind Bernie Sanders is a latter-day Don Quixote: an idiosyncratic but dedicated social justice warrior who's refusing to concede defeat, even though his chances of beating Hillary Clinton are only possible mathematically. In the world of probabilities he has a greater chance of being struck by lightning in a coal mine than surpassing Clinton in delegates, and has only slightly better odds at forcing a contested convention in July. But he's persistent, saying he's going to stay in the race until every vote is counted, though his campaign says he will not pursue a third party run. His persistence is generally applauded, but that he feels embolden to continue his impossible dream is a sign that not all Democrats are on the same page.
More than his persistence, it's the persistence of his followers that is drawing concern as opposed to admiration. There's been much made of the violence at Donald Trump rallies, but people are now noting that Sanders' supporters can be disruptive themselves. The reported disruptions at the Nevada State Democratic Convention were, in part, directed toward Senator Barbara Boxer, a Clinton supporter who is far from a conservative. Similar to the GOP, the Democrats are facing their own anti-establishment insurgency. Not long ago Boxer would have been called a progressive, but Sanders' open espousal of social democracy has left conventional liberals looking a bit staid. There are now serious questions if the establishment and the insurgents will be able to coalesce to insure a November victory. Worse yet are concerns that things could turn ugly at the convention.
In this vein California's other senator, Diane Feinstein, has raised worries that Philadelphia 2016 might be the new Chicago 1968, where the Democrat's national convention was marred by riots in the streets and turmoil in the hall. Her reference to a possible 1968 redux, and specifically the negative effects it could have on the electorate is a veiled reference to the election results of that year: a fractured Democratic Party didn't unite sufficiently around the establishment candidate, Vice President Hubert Humphrey, allowing former V.P. Richard Nixon to win a narrow victory. In spite of Nixon's disgraced exit from the presidency in 1974, the Democrats would hold the White House for only four of the next 24 years.
The irony here is that many Democratic establishment figures today were the radicals of 1968, or their heirs. That year Hillary Clinton, a college senior, worked on the failed campaign of Eugene McCarthy, the anti-war outsider who in a loose way is analogous to Sanders this time around. She, and others of that generation would be familiar with the thought of Saul Alinsky, the groundbreaking community organizer who's confrontational style shaped generations of left wing activists that followed. Though his supporters down play the influence, it's hard to imagine that President Obama was a community organizer in Chicago and wasn't acquainted with Alinsky's tactics, as well as experienced in their implementation. The irony now is that those who fought the power way back when, and carried the mantle later on, are now the power, and are getting a dose of their own medicine.
The Democrats, as I see it, are caught in a dilemma. They have positioned themselves as the progressive party, though some of them are more progressive than others. But the progressive movement needs to be constantly moving forward, and can't tolerate any drag on the forward momentum. Even if progress really isn't as complete as we would like, there's a time to say we won, and move on to the next issue lest the faithful lose interest. In spite of the progress that still needs to be made in terms of race relations for instance, the general feeling is that sufficient strides were made that we can turn our attention to the area of sexual politics, embodied in the gay rights movement, framing the issue in the same way the precious struggle was. Now that gay marriage is the law of the land, we have to move to transgender rights. Once there is a perceived victory on that front, whatever that will represent, we will have to move on to the next issue, and the next and the next. We are never at the point where we can be satisfied, because human and social progress, by it's very nature, never stop. The only good status quo is the one we just upended in the name of equality and social justice. We believe that Utopia is just around the corner, just on the other side of the mountain, across the sea, but when we arrive we'll realize that there are still more obstacles to overcome, and overcome them we will. In the end we are Sisyphus rolling the rock up the hill only to watch it roll back down, which means the there really is no end - in part because none of the problems are ever really solved. So new issues are brought to the fore are old ones, left half completed, are kept in reserve for the time when there seems to be a lull in the storm and another cause is needed quickly to rally the troops. In that case any cause will do, as long as it keeps the engine of progress fueled. There is no rest, only grinding, sleepless progress.
Mrs. Clinton may be liberal, but she's no progressive, at least not in the mold of Mr. Sanders. She's happy with the social changes wrought in the last few years, but she didn't spearhead them, and was initially against some of them. She wants to control the system, not burn it down. The thing is, right now, even though their party has controlled the executive branch for seven and a half years, many in her party don't simply want more of the same. No, they want to dismantle the entire social, political and economic system and start over from scratch, because that's what progressivism is all about: keep people discontented, keep them focused on an enemy, keep them caught up in the process even though there are never any lasting results. A garden variety liberal like Clinton, who may be for equality and redistributing wealth, but's still in bed with Wall Street and the big banks, looks awfully passé right now. It's true the there are many Republicans who can't get themselves support Trump, but don't be surprised if many Democrats who've felt the Bern can't get themselves to pull the lever for Hillary.
What will happen in November? We need to be careful in making predictions off of the past alone. History doesn't repeat itself, but it does often rhyme, as Mark Twain may have, but probably never, said. It's true that the establishment in the Republican Party could fail to support Trump, with many GOP voters either staying home, leaving the top of the ballot blank or crossing over to Hillary (if she gets the nod). But the twist here could be that the reverse happens with the Democrats, if the establishment candidate fails to win over the progressives, who then stay home rather than vote for someone they don't believe in (somehow I doubt that any sizable number of progressives would vote Trump, but who knows?). Then what happens? It may come down to who's supporters are most enthusiastic, in which case Trump could squeak it out, in the style of Nixon. Maybe there will be enough of the electorate that's still in the mainstream to go with the known quantity, making Hillary, at last, the first woman to be president, while paradoxically maintaining the status quo.
But I'm standing by my claim that we are in new waters, and anyone's guess will be as good as anyone else's. But this analysis has stayed on the political level. Next time I want to try to observe the scene through the lens of faith.
Tuesday, May 17, 2016
The Popes of World Youth Day – the Popes of Mercy
I'll be going to World Youth Day in Poland this July along with a group sponsored by the Salesian Eastern Province. Here's something I wrote with Fr. Dominic Tran, SDB for the WYD Salesian Facebook page.
World Youth Day 2016 and the Extraordinary Jubilee that goes until November 20 share a common focus: the Mercy of God. This convergence of themes is no coincidence and these great themes came together as the result of the work of the giant figures, the shepherds the Good Shepherds has given to the Church in recent years—Pope St. John Paul II, Pope Benedict XVI and Pope Francis.
St. John Paul was the great promoter of the Divine Mercy devotion and the cause of St. Faustina. He said, early on in his pontificate, "Right from the beginning of my ministry in St. Peter’s See in Rome, I consider this message [of Divine Mercy] my special task. Providence has assigned it to me in the present situation of man, the Church and the world. It could be said that precisely this situation assigned that message to me as my task before God." He beatified and Canonized St. Faustina and established the Second Sunday of Easter as Divine Mercy Sunday. He saw mercy as the remedy for humanity after all the wars and atrocities of the 20th century: it was now the time to return to God and seek forgiveness and to turn to one another in a spirit of reconciliation and mercy.
Pope Benedict XVI, being a great theologian, gave us the theology of God’s mercy. With his very first encyclical, he emphasized, “God is love, and he who abides in love abides in God, and God abides in him” (1 John 4:16). These words from the First Letter of John express with remarkable clarity the heart of the Christian faith: the Christian image of God and the resulting image of mankind and its destiny. In the same verse, Saint John also offers a kind of summary of the Christian life: “We have come to know and to believe in the love God has for us”.
In a world where the name of God is sometimes associated with vengeance or even a duty of hatred and violence, this message is both timely and significant. For this reason, I wish in my first Encyclical to speak of the love which God lavishes upon us and which we in turn must share with others. (Deus Caritas Est, #1)
Pope Francis also has stressed mercy from the beginning of his time as the Vicar of Christ. Just a few days after his election in 2013 he said, “God's mercy can make even the driest land become a garden, can restore life to dry bones ... Let us be renewed by God's mercy, let us be loved by Jesus, let us enable the power of his love to transform our lives too; and let us become agents of this mercy, channels through which God can water the earth, protect all creation and make justice and peace flourish.” He has never ceased to call us to be a Church of mercy, both seeking out God’s forgiveness and living mercy in our lives. He has both promoted the Divine Mercy chaplet as a “powerful medicine” but also called us to go out and live mercy in our lives.
In this way St. John Paul II, Benedict XVI, and Francis can be called the Popes of Mercy. As it is said, JP II introduced the what - Divine Mercy, Benedict taught us why, and Francis shows us how.
Monday, May 16, 2016
MSM: Still Not Getting It
I've long ago stopped watching the Sunday political shows like Face the Nation or Meet the Press, along with any number of the other political round tables that fill the airwaves, usually though not exclusively, on the Lord's Day. It's mainly that I don't have the time to watch them, as opposed to abandoning them because I've lost faith in their veracity, like I have the national evening news. Opinion shows are exactly that, people giving their opinions: I know what I'm getting. More and more the network's hard news shows are anything but, delivering a sedative shot of human interest, celebrity gossip and freak weather pieces to lull the audience into a stupor so as not to alarm them with the real news happening in the world. I'm not even going to dip my toe into the whole debate as to whether the Main Stream Media (MSM) are fair and balanced. All I'll say is that hard news is not being reported on the "Big Three," making them apart of the bread and circuses or contemporary American life.
I say this as a way of setting up a clip I stumbled on to as I was surfing YouTube. I'm not sure what algorithm suggested this clip for me, but it's from a PBS News Hour broadcast that aired last week, after Donald Trump became the presumptive GOP nominee. The New Hour runs during the week, and is a hybrid of the evening news and a round table program. The clip below is of a regular segment featuring commentary from Mark Shields, a liberal columnist, and David Brooks, a moderate conservative who writes for The Times. In fairness, both are pretty moderate, or at least present them selves as such, in offering their perspective. Shields has been around forever, being a veteran of CNN's Capital Gang and The McLaughlin Group, among other shows. David Brooks has risen in prominence by positioning himself to be the thinking man's conservative in the mold of a William Safire. Both are canny, but conventional in their thinking, as is demonstrated by by their commentary here.
They are reasoned, reasonable, and stuck in 2004. They admit that they misread Trump, didn't think he would get the nomination, and underestimated the mood of discontent in the nation. They still don't believe he can win in November though: Trump is shallow, crude, and unprepared for the highest office in the land. For now the people, in their anger, will flirt with Trump but in the end they'll go with the safe choice: the conventional politician Hillary Clinton-or so they think.
They, and others in the MSM, can continue to think that way at their own peril. The prospect of a Trump victory is real: not certain, but very real. People understand that the political system is broke: that the republican mechanisms are jammed. The economic system might be even more impaired. If the economy falters going into the fall, and September-October seems to be the time, even in a non-recession year, when the market goes into a downward "correction," the people just might feel desperate enough to hand the nuclear code to someone who has never worked in government before.
Let me be clear, I'm not endorsing Donald Trump, or any candidate. But as one of my intellectual heroes, Marshall McLuhan, said about his otherwise detached observations on mass media: it's not that he liked it, but he wanted to know how it worked so he could figure out where the switch was and turn it off. We can criticize Mr. Trump all we want; we all know his defects. But a conventional way of approaching the issue isn't going to work at stopping him, if that's what you want to do. Hit pieces in the New York Times accusing him of misogyny or sensational, but tenuous, attempts to link him to the KKK are not going to work. Those methods worked in the past, on conventional politicians. We are beyond the conventional right now, and we'd best figure out how Trump is succeeding, not just bemoan the fact that he is.
Unfortunately Shields and Brooks, along with many of their fellow pundits are stuck on the ordinary. The ground is shifting under their feet, but have no idea what to do but wait for the shaking to stop and hope the house is still standing because it always has. They are like Bob Dylan's Mr. Jones with his pencil and pad watching the strange scene pass, but not really getting it. If this is the level of opinion being offered on the air maybe I haven't missed that much by skipping the political shows.
More on this later. But for now, enjoy:
I say this as a way of setting up a clip I stumbled on to as I was surfing YouTube. I'm not sure what algorithm suggested this clip for me, but it's from a PBS News Hour broadcast that aired last week, after Donald Trump became the presumptive GOP nominee. The New Hour runs during the week, and is a hybrid of the evening news and a round table program. The clip below is of a regular segment featuring commentary from Mark Shields, a liberal columnist, and David Brooks, a moderate conservative who writes for The Times. In fairness, both are pretty moderate, or at least present them selves as such, in offering their perspective. Shields has been around forever, being a veteran of CNN's Capital Gang and The McLaughlin Group, among other shows. David Brooks has risen in prominence by positioning himself to be the thinking man's conservative in the mold of a William Safire. Both are canny, but conventional in their thinking, as is demonstrated by by their commentary here.
They are reasoned, reasonable, and stuck in 2004. They admit that they misread Trump, didn't think he would get the nomination, and underestimated the mood of discontent in the nation. They still don't believe he can win in November though: Trump is shallow, crude, and unprepared for the highest office in the land. For now the people, in their anger, will flirt with Trump but in the end they'll go with the safe choice: the conventional politician Hillary Clinton-or so they think.
They, and others in the MSM, can continue to think that way at their own peril. The prospect of a Trump victory is real: not certain, but very real. People understand that the political system is broke: that the republican mechanisms are jammed. The economic system might be even more impaired. If the economy falters going into the fall, and September-October seems to be the time, even in a non-recession year, when the market goes into a downward "correction," the people just might feel desperate enough to hand the nuclear code to someone who has never worked in government before.
Let me be clear, I'm not endorsing Donald Trump, or any candidate. But as one of my intellectual heroes, Marshall McLuhan, said about his otherwise detached observations on mass media: it's not that he liked it, but he wanted to know how it worked so he could figure out where the switch was and turn it off. We can criticize Mr. Trump all we want; we all know his defects. But a conventional way of approaching the issue isn't going to work at stopping him, if that's what you want to do. Hit pieces in the New York Times accusing him of misogyny or sensational, but tenuous, attempts to link him to the KKK are not going to work. Those methods worked in the past, on conventional politicians. We are beyond the conventional right now, and we'd best figure out how Trump is succeeding, not just bemoan the fact that he is.
Unfortunately Shields and Brooks, along with many of their fellow pundits are stuck on the ordinary. The ground is shifting under their feet, but have no idea what to do but wait for the shaking to stop and hope the house is still standing because it always has. They are like Bob Dylan's Mr. Jones with his pencil and pad watching the strange scene pass, but not really getting it. If this is the level of opinion being offered on the air maybe I haven't missed that much by skipping the political shows.
More on this later. But for now, enjoy:
Sunday, May 15, 2016
Fr. Robert Barron on The Holy Spirit in the Life of the Church
This video is from a couple of years ago, so some of the specific references to wild fires and tornadoes are a dated, but the overall message is timeless.
Saturday, May 14, 2016
Wednesday, May 11, 2016
A Reflection on What a "Poor" Wounded" Church Means
In these meetings it's easy to look at spread sheets, graphs, demographic projections and the like and conclude that the Church is a business like any other, and we are to make decisions based on the bottom line alone. But I can say that both in the case my Salesian superiors and on the diocesan side with Archbishop Cupich, that the message is clear: what we are about is the mission of evangelization. Whatever decisions are made are not meant first and foremost to improve the financial bottom line but to make us more effective proclaimers of the Word and ministers of the Sacraments. We are being called to discernment in the Spirit.
Part of this process is going to mean an examination of the material possessions of the Church. What buildings and institutions help us move the mission forward? Which served us well in their time, but their time has passed and we need to let them go? Which were products of a triumphalistic age meant to demonstrate the Church's power and status in the world, and again, need to be let go of for the sake of recapturing the Church's true identity? This can be a painful process. We're talking about parishes, schools, hospitals, retreat centers and any number of other works that people identify as the places where their faith was born, fostered and nourished. These are more than buildings, for many they are home.
But we are called to not be bound by buildings, or anything material. They are tools in the service of evangelization, and we need to be open to switching tools when they no longer meet the needs of a new age. But, as I wrote, this isn't easy. In the 25 years since I entered Salesian formation, we have parted ways with incredibly significant works: schools, parishes (including one that represented our oldest presence in the Eastern United States), even our house of formation in Newton, New Jersey where generations of Salesians were formed, both intellectually and pastorally. Each closure or transfer of administration back to the local diocese was like a cut. A few of our men literally lost their vocations over these changes. I don't judge what's in a person's heart, but I will say that those who left over these changes forgot that basic truth that the building or institution isn't the mission, but its servant.
There are further changes coming for the Church in the U.S. We can look at mergers and closures as the death of something. But we are best served by maintaining a spirit of discernment, with our eyes fixed on Jesus and how He is best served.
I think of Pope Francis' call to be a poor Church for the poor: one that goes to the peripheries, reaching out to the spiritually wounded. It's a Church that "thinks outside the box," not bound by convention or tradition, as opposed to being guided by the living Tradition. A Church that makes the institution the focus becomes caught up with maintenance and self preservation instead of service. It looks inward instead of outward, becoming self-referential and irrelevant to the outside world. But a Church that eschews the outward trappings of power and status becomes a true sign of contradiction to the world, and more vital than we can imagine.
I also think of Pope Emeritus Benedict who, when he was still Fr. Ratzinger, wrote of a Church smaller, but more faithful. He took some heat when he repeated these words as pope, because some thought he was envisioning the Church an exclusive club of spiritual elites. But if we look back to his original words from the late '60's, we see quite the opposite. He wrote, in part:
"It (the Church) will become small and will have to start pretty much all over again. It will no longer have use of the structures it built in its years of prosperity. The reduction in the number of faithful will lead to it losing an important part of its social privileges.” ... "As a small society, [the Church] will make much bigger demands on the initiative of her individual members" …. . “It will be a more spiritual Church, and will not claim a political mandate flirting with the Right one minute and the Left the next. It will be poor and will become the Church of the destitute.”
But when the trial of this sifting is past, a great power will flow from a more spiritualized and simplified Church. Men in a totally planned world will find themselves unspeakably lonely. If they have completely lost sight of God, they will feel the whole horror of their poverty. Then they will discover the little flock of believers as something wholly new. They will discover it as a hope that is meant for them, an answer for which they have always been searching in secret."
The vision of Fr. Ratzinger is not one of a spiritual elite, but one of a concentrated yet powerful force that is the antidote to postmodern impotence. It is a spiritual communion, united by Christ, that contradicts contemporary isolation and the disjointed logic of the moment.
This process of transformation will make great demands on all of us. More is going to be asked of us all: greater flexibility, greater humility, greater patience, greater faith. There's no doubt that this is a daunting reality. But we have a choice: we can either pretend everything is alright as it is, and no change is necessary-which is to live in a fantasy land. We can acknowledge the challenges, but see the solution as a recapturing of some past glory, or use some old agenda to meet new realities, which is bound to fail. Or else we can look at this as a moment of opportunity, an adventure in the Spirit. It will call for new solutions, true, but will also mean drawing from the store house of the Church's accumulated wisdom of the past 2,000 years. It will mean bold action, as well as prudent discernment. It will mean being open to the Spirit that calls us into an ever deeper relationship with Jesus Christ, the one we are called to proclaim: never forgetting that it is He we serve, it is He who is our portion and cup. He is the only riches that we have to share with the world.
Sunday, May 8, 2016
Odds and Ends on the Bread and Circuses
I just want to follow up a little on what I wrote the other day concerning the ongoing campaign for president.
A friend of mine commented that he was a bit surprised at the little fervorino with which I concluded the piece. I didn't take it as a criticism, but an observation, one that nonetheless got me thinking. I write on many topics here, from pop culture to current events to all things Catholic. No matter the topic I certainly try to connect everything back to faith in Jesus Christ and the truth of the Catholic religion. I've also tried not to make that the sole justification for my point of view as presented here. Not that faith isn't enough; it's more than enough for me. But I'm not trying to preach to the converted: I'm hoping to reach those who either don't believe, or my accept Christ but aren't sure if the traditional beliefs held by the Church are still valid. Arguments from authority or tradition aren't effective in persuading most people because so many don't trust authority or respect traditions as still being valid. So I avoid making Scripture or Apostolic Tradition the reasons to believe (though as I've said, they're good enough for me) as much as show that these two fonts of Divine Revelation are themselves reasonable. In light of this, I rarely give the hard line pitch to accept Christ and His Gospel, preferring a more subtle approach.
In normal times this strategy is perfectly fine. And there is still a place for this approach today (we're basically talking about the method used by many solid Catholic apologists). But for me, I believe the Lord is calling me in a different direction: to be more explicit, more "evangelical," for lack of a better term. We are living in a time of decision, and I'm not simply referring to the election, though the presidential campaign is a microcosm of the crisis we face. So desperate times call for clarity of purpose and the bold proclamation of the Gospel.
One reason that we (I'm speaking of practicing Catholics) are at this cross roads is that we have, either explicitly or implicitly, accepted the idea that our religion is about the here and now exclusively. Marx charged that religion is the opiate of the people, drugging them with promises of a future paradise so as to anesthetize then to the injustices of this earth. We uncritically accepted the charge, and proceeded to turn the Church into a social service agency or NGO. The Church's charitable works and advocacy initiatives are essential to Her identity, but are one ore by which the barque is moved forward. Without the proclamation of the Gospel in its completeness: the call to repentance because the Kingdom of God is at hand, we become just another political party or lobbying group, moving in circles since we have only one ore, offering temporary solutions to perennial problems.
For too long people of faith, with all good intentions, have tried to effect change through the political process. Maybe we thought that we could be a leaven that influences the system, making it more Christian. Maybe we thought that one side or the other better reflected Gospel values, or worse thought one side was the "Catholic Party." In this way some were even deceived into seeing one candidate or another as "God's Candidate," even if subconsciously so. We have gotten into bed with political movements that are flawed in the misguided notion that the very real political implications of the Gospel render our faith another political movement. Archbishop Sheen predicted this identification of religion with politics, and how destructive if would be to the faith.
Many of us clung to the Republican party because they got the life issues right, and generally defended traditional marriage. Others of us clung to the Democrats because of their record as being pro-labor and more concerned about the plight of the poor and disenfranchised. We ignored the parts of their platforms that didn't jibe by telling our selves that one part of the Gospel was more important than the other. We convinced ourselves that God doesn't care about our prudential judgments or private morality, as long as we were against abortion or for a larger social safety net.
But we were used, by both sides. But not just people of faith were duped. I believe the rise of Donald Trump and the persistence of Bernie Sanders is rooted in the fact that people of both the left and right feel betrayed by their respective parties. They know the the system is broken and corrupt. I don't believe that any of the three candidates left standing are the solution. They will either lead us into tyranny or further economic and spiritual ruin: but probably all three things. But the American people are desperate: a very dangerous atmosphere in which to select a new president.
In future posts I'll get into more details, especially about how I see things shaking out over the next six months. I'll only say now that we may see a third or even fourth party candidate run, and we may have the first election to be decided by the House of Representatives since 1824. I'm no prophet, nor the son of a prophet, I'm just riding a hunch. But my thoughts here will not be guided solely by human logic or conventional wisdom. We got in this mess because we took God out of the picture. We're only going to get out of it by inviting Him back in and seeing the world through spiritual eyes.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)










