Thursday, April 25, 2013

God and Baseball // "42" Movie Review

 



On a spring evening in 1903 the Ohio Wesleyan University baseball team arrived in South Bend, Indiana for a game the following day against Notre Dame.  The story goes that the hotel would not give a room to one of the visiting players, Charles Thomas, because he was African American.  The Ohio Wesleyan manager, indignant that his player was refused service, was able to get the clerk to agree to allow Thomas to stay in his room that night; but only that night.  The next day they would have to find different lodgings for him. When he got to the room the manager found his catcher sitting in a chair crying, violently rubbing his hands down the length of his arms saying, "Black skin, black skin, if only I could make them white."

That manager was Branch Rickey, and he would say years later that the scene of a man trying to strip off his own skin haunted him for decades, and played a key role in his determination to integrate Major League Baseball by signing Jackie Robinson to a Big League contract in 1947, as president and general manager of the Brooklyn Dodgers.  Some have called into question the veracity of this account, though  Thomas, who remained a life long friend of Rickey, vouched for it.  All agree that something happened that night, even if it didn't proceed exactly like the grizzled old baseball man and spinner of colorful tales related it.  Most agree too that Rickey's motivation for breaking the "gentleman's agreement" that kept blacks out of the Big Leagues for sixty years was manifold.  A social conscience? Yes. A desire for a bigger gate at the ball park?  Sure.  A hunger to win with the best players available, regardless of race?  You bet.  But there was also a little matter of faith, and it's on clear, if understated, display in the movie 42, the new bio-pic about Jackie Robinson.

In 42 (named thus for the uniform number he wore) Robinson (Chadwick Boseman) is the center of the story, but the people around him seem to have the most personality.  His wife Rachel (Nicole Beharie) grew up in Southern California where segregation, at least the legal kind, didn't exist.  She's a smart, self possessed woman, so the first time she sees a whites only women's room, on a pass through New Orleans, she does the only thing that seems natural; she goes in.  Leo Durocher (Christopher Meloni), Brooklyn's manager, is a hard living womanizer who likes to hang with gamblers and gangsters (the latter details strangely left out of the movie), but when his players revolt at the idea of having a "negro" play with them he lays down the law in no uncertain terms: you'll play with Jackie Robinson or you will be traded.  Wendell Smith (Andre Holland), a black sports reporter sent to accompany Robinson on his first spring training, has his own color line to break and seems to understand the wider implications of what our hero is doing more than our hero does.  Pee Wee Reese (Lucas Black) the Dodger shortstop and a team leader, is a southerner, at once inclined to give the new guy a chance, but struggles with cultural expectations, ultimately showing a very public sign of support for Robinson that helps change the mood both inside and outside the clubhouse. 

And then we have Branch Rickey (Harrison Ford): the gravel voiced, cigar chomping, Bible quoting baseball man who had already revolutionized the game by organizing the first minor league farm system when he was GM of the St. Louis Cardinals.  When he came to the Dodgers he established the first permanent spring training facility, and promoted the use of batting cages, pitching machines, batting helmets and was doing statistical analysis, stressing the importance of on base percentage over batting average, thirty years before Bill James wrote his first book.   Again, details left out of the movie, but show that he would have been a Hall of Fame executive even without his crowning achievement.

A question that is asked repeatedly of Rickey in the film, by Robinson especially, is "Why are you doing this?"   As we've seen, this is a man who could have rested on his laurels at this point in his career.  But yet something drove him on.  Yes, Rickey was a shrewd business man, and we shouldn't discount the material benefits he had in mind.  But in choosing a player for his grand move he didn't go for the best or most well known.  He went for a college man, a former military officer and a Methodist, perfect because "I'm a Methodist, God's a Methodist."  That combination of character and faith, in Rickey's mind, are what made Jackie Robinson the perfect candidate to endure the unspeakable hardships he would have to endure in the years to come.  When a rival executive threatens to keep his team from the field Rickey reminds him of his eternal destiny, that God might not judge the reasons for not playing his team that day to be sufficient.  Whatever role that long ago incident in the South Bend hotel may have played in the Jackie Robinson story, Rickey's faith was certainly a major factor in answering the question of why he took the risk.

While Rickey's religious convictions are on display in 42, Robinson's are not explored as deeply, though in real life he was just as devout as his boss.  I guess that is my one criticism of movie, apart from some slow patches that could have been tightened up, and a bit of contrived suspense at the end to give the story some type of payoff; that Jackie seems to be the least developed character in the movie.  Even before he's advised to not react to the abuse, so as not to give his enemies an excuse to point the finger of accusation back at him, he comes off as a tad stoic, a blank slate of sorts.  A day after seeing the movie the person who stands out in my mind is Harrison Ford's Branch Rickey, and while I recommend 42, a solid if far from perfect film, I'm not sure that's what the film makers had in mind.

Tuesday, April 16, 2013

Pondering Evil, Yet Again, Wearily




The Old Testament prophets tended to be very harsh when times were good.  They tried to remind people that life wasn't all about parties and wealth creation; that in the midst of the fat years there were still poor people not sharing in the prosperity, and not to be deluded into thinking that wealth, pleasure and power were substitutes for God.  The prophets reminded Judah and Israel that all things pass, and that chastisements eventually come for injustices and immoralities, so they shouldn't come to depend on their excess, and make a good examination of conscience.  Then, once the bottom fell out they changed tone, assuring the people that God hadn't abandoned them and the present trials wouldn't last forever.  In other words, they didn't kick people when they were down.  For us today religious figures who come out after a tragedy and get their Isaiah up, blaming a terrorist attack, a natural disaster or some other traumatic event that takes human lives on the sins of the people comes off as cruelly tone deaf.

We are still left with questions though.  We are not so accustomed to having the prophetic finger pointed at us as we are to point the finger at God, asking, "where were you?"  I weary of the question, not because it's a bad one, but because it has no response that can satisfy us.  The standard Thomistic answer is that God permits evil so that a greater good can come out of it.  In the big picture this is true, but I doubt that this explanation would make any sense to the parents who just lost their eight year old son in Copley Square.

I have adult nieces, some of whom work in and around Boston, one of whom is an RM who was called in to help at a hospital in the city treating victims.  After thanking the Lord that "all the girls are where they're supposed to be," as my father put it, I felt heart broken.  My eldest niece, the nurse, works in a children's burn hospital.  She sees terrible things on a day to day basis already, and all I could think of were the fresh hells she was being subjected to now.  She'll be thirty in a few months, but all I could see in my mind's eye was the baby wrapped up tight the way they do in hospital nurseries.  I still thought of her, and the others, as they were as children.  We want to protect our children from ugly things, and now it's impossible.  Even though they're not children anymore, it's a helpless feeling, to say the least.

I long ago reconciled myself with the problem of evil.  That people make wicked choices doesn't effect my faith in God.  That God permits evil is wrapped up in the gift of freedom; that He allows us to do good and accept Him means that he also allows us to do wrong.  Without that possibility we are slaves.  It doesn't mean my heart wasn't in my throat thinking about what could have happened if someone I loved was where they "weren't supposed to be" at 2:50pm Monday.  It doesn't mean I didn't feel rage seeing what had happened to people I've never met.

As for the cosmic reasons, I thought about when people came to Jesus asking about an incident when Pilate had slaughtered a group of Jews indiscriminately (Luke 13:1-5).  Jesus told them that they, and an unfortunate 18 who had died when a tower fell on them, were not singled out for destruction because they were "greater sinners" than anyone else.  He instead pointed out the need to repent for everyone, because murderous tyrants, falling towers or terrorists' bombs don't discriminate.  Evil is a part of our human condition.  We work for justice and peace, but mustn't be shaken in our faith when there are those who are for war.  It is for us to walk in the light of Christ so that we are always ready to meet him.  We pray for a happy, provided for exit from this life, but are ready for the unexpected.

In the end words do not suffice.  I do not know what greater good can possibly come out of this.  I was not there when God created the stars and set the earth on it's foundations, as He reminded Job when he asked a similar question.  I, like most of us, am numbed by the evil, and take solace in the random acts of kindness and heroism of performed by ordinary people on the scene.  And while these victims were certainly not being punished for their sins or those of their fathers and mothers, I am convinced that this darkness that covers us right now won't lift until we return to the Lord with sincere hearts and a repentant spirit. 

Friday, April 12, 2013

Fear Goes Dancing // Silver Linings Playbook Movie Review

 Silver Linings Playbook has been out since last November.  I have resisted seeing this movie all the while.  I made it through the Holiday Season avoiding it.  Then I navigated my way through Oscar time ducking it.  But Thursday this was the only movie even remotely worth seeing at a multiplex that boasts twenty-one screens (January obviously isn't the only dumping ground bad movies). Everything about it from the title to the premise screamed feel-good-inspirational to me, which means I normally walk the other way (one day I'll tell you why).  In light of the dearth of competition I held my nose, bought the ticket and succumbed to the inevitable.  

The good news: Jennifer Lawrence deserved her Oscar as the young widow, and the rest of the cast and crew deserved the nominations they received (you could make a strong argument for Robert De Niro for best supporting actor).  Bradley Cooper is believable playing a man suffering from bipolar disorder, even if it is a somewhat sanitized Hollywood take on it.  Director David O. Russell's often off beat song choices make up for the totally derivative and predictable sound track on his last film The Fighter.  Over all I liked this better than that earlier film, and found many of the individual elements in Silver Linings Playbook to be very well done and pitch perfect.

Until you put them all together.

Here's the problem.  I'm not a mental health care professional, but my vocation brings me in contact at times with people who suffer, and these poor souls really do suffer, from bipolar disorder, OCD, occasionally a person effected by paranoid schizophrenia crossed our doorway.  For the most severe cases these afflictions keep them from living anything approaching a normal life.  To hold down a job is close to impossible.  To maintain a stable relationship is equally difficult.  Many are like the main characters, otherwise able bodied adults living at home with their parents with out a job or prospects.  While I don't believe that the filmmakers are dishonest or have any bad intent (all the characters are three dimensional people treated with sensitivity), there is still a bit of unreality surrounding the story, that would have worked better if they had followed a more conventional tack. 

Cooper plays a former teacher who has probably suffered from bipolar disorder most of his life, but is only diagnosed after he catches his wife in the shower with one of her co-workers and does what most husbands would do in that situation, whether they were emotionally unbalanced or not; he beats the snot out of the guy.  After eight months in a mental hospital (part of a plea bargain that keeps him out of jail) he comes home to live with his parents.  A close friend invites him over for dinner, and oh yeah, they invite the sister-in-law (Lawrence) who is recently widowed and dealing with her pain by bedding every every Tom, Dick and Suzie she can get her hands on.  After a rude introduction they share their anti-depressant med history.  We know that true love is just a Zoloft away.

Cooper's father (De Niro) is a bookie who is more than a touch obsessive compulsive (see, it runs in the family).  They all want something. Cooper wants his wife back, De Niro wants out of the bookie business and open a restaurant and Lawrence wants to participate in a dance contest.  With out going into details (mainly because by now most of you have probably already seen the movie) these simple desires intersect and contradict and come to a neat resolution.

In the end this is a hard movie to give a firm recommendation to.  There were parts I really loved, and that made me regret my decision to skip this one for so long.  The sound track matches songs to situations perfectly, and often left me saying things like, "I know the artist, but what's the song?"  As anyone who knows me can tell you, if a movie stumps me on a song or an artist, it's done something.  The sequence where Cooper obsessively ransacks the house looking for his lost wedding video with Led Zeppelin's "What is and What Should Never Be" as the back drop is brilliant.  Jeniffer Lawrence, who was probably 20 when this was filmed, shows astonishing maturity in a role that many actresses in their thirties can't pull off.  De Niro, is well, De Niro; tough, but he shows a real tenderness as the father struggling to make things right with his son.

On the other hand, the neatness of the resolution and the unspoken message that two emotionally broken people can heal each other left me shaking my head.  I could point out that there are a lot of plot twists that are telegraphed, but that really didn't bother me because the performances were so good.  It is, as with most mainstream Hollywood movies, that we had to have the "silver lining," the unmitigated happy ending that belies the truth, that left me a bit cold.

The truth is that both of them have a hard road ahead of them, and two volatile personalities together usually leads to more explosions.  For those who suffer from emotional problems the solution is not that there is a cure, but that it is manageable.  While autism is not mental illness, what made Rain Man so good was the acknowledgement that the Dustin Hoffman character was never going to change.  It was Tom Cruse as the "normal" brother who had to change and accept his brother for who he was.  That ring of truth is missing from Silver Linings Playbook.

So, if I was forced to give a recommendation, it would be to see it.  Individual parts are, at times, exceptional and shouldn't be missed.  But put together as a whole I felt it missed the mark, by that much.   

Tuesday, April 9, 2013

The Office of Readings and the Book of Revelation


Priests and religious are required to pray the Divine Office, also known as the Liturgy of the Hours, everyday.  It is also referred to sometimes to as the breviary, the book that contains the prayers themselves.   These are liturgical in nature, which implies that they are recited publicly and in common, though diocesan priests normally pray it in private.  There are seven individual "hours" that are to be prayed at various times of the day, though there is some leeway on that.  Monastic religious normally pray all seven, secular clergy and active religious can choose one of the three "small hours" that are prayed during the daytime period.  As Salesians we pray Morning Prayer (Lauds) and Evening Prayer (Vespers) in common, while the priests have to find time on their own to fit in the other hours. Salesian Brothers are not required to pray the other hours, though they are free to. 

I make this brief introduction because periodically I'll be sharing reflections on one of the Offices in particular, the Office of Readings.  This is one of the major Hours, though it isn't attached to a particular time of day like the others are. It can be prayed at anytime, though most priests either pray it first thing in the morning before Lauds or, like I often do, treat it as a night office and pray it before saying Night Prayer and going to bed.  Like all the Hours the Office of Readings involves the praying of the Psalms (the usual three, though often it is a longer Psalm divided into three parts).  Then there are two lengthy readings, one from Sacred Scripture and the other from one of the Fathers of the Church, the writings of a saint on his or her feast day or, on occasion, a document from Vatican II.  This assured me that no matter how busy I get during the day, I am reading the Word of God daily and being nourished by the wisdom contained in Tradition.  One down part right now is that the English addition, which hasn't been revised since the 1970's, only has one cycle of scriptural readings where as the Spanish edition, updated in the '90's, has a two year cycle, thus containing a greater selection from God's Word.  Just as the Roman Missal was revised a recently, I understand a new English breviary is being worked on, and I hope that this deficiency is corrected.

The Office of Readings usually tackles a book at a time, spreading the selections out over a period of days or weeks.  From this Second Week of Easter through about the sixth we'll be reading the Book of Revelation.  I will be offering reflections as we go along.  But these will be personal reflections.  I will not be trying to answer questions of the controversies of the book, and I am certainly not offering anything scholarly.  What I will offer is something more along the lines of a Lectio Divina;  this is the way I heard the Lord speaking to me and how I believe he wants the Word to influence my life as a disciple.  This is probably the most difficult book of the Bible to do this with because of its obscure symbolism and wild imagery.  We tend to look at the universal meaning first, but I do believe God is saying something to us, not just about the End of Days or the plight of empires, but about our lives here and now in the micro setting of our lives.  

I've taken enough time on the setup.  Soon my first reflection on John, Patmos and the Seven Letters.

Monday, April 8, 2013

The Church is One | Columbia Catholic Ministry


Mad Men Season Six

I'll be writing a more complete reflection on the new season of Mad Men once a few episodes are in the can and some sort of narrative theme has been established.  But a few quick observations on last night's season premiere.


1. (CORRECTION:  In the original post I identified the setting of the season premiere as the week between Christmas and New Year's Eve 1968.  I was critical of what I thought was the choice to skip the entire year, one of the most turbulent in American history.  The episode itself keeps the date somewhat  ambiguous.  I based my dating on a New York Post preview that cited a news paper headline Don reads while he's at the beach to reach the December, 1968-January '69 time frame.  It seems after investigations made by the various bloggers out there, putting the clues together as only those intrepid guys and gals with even more time on their hands than I do can, that I'm a year off, and we have not missed out on all the fun and frolic of that volcanic year of 1968 [and looking a the episode again on demand makes me want to kick myself for missing the Green Bay - Oakland Super Bowl reference, that as a sports fan should have been the dead give away].  

First, I'm embarrassed at the flub.  Secondly, I'm glad that I was wrong.  Third, in light of the earlier start date, it seems really quick for so many of the "straights" at SCDP to have gone all groovy with the hair and cloths.  These trends take time to bubble up in the culture, and while it's certainly not completely out of place, with this revised timeline the changes seem more radical than at first blush.  

I read one article that argues that all the obsession over such details is silly, and I'm not going to dispute the fact that as a bit of a history nut I probably pay too much attention to such things.  But I do think the context matters, even if you can enjoy the show without it.  Most historical dramas use the past as a way to comment on the present.  A film like M*A*S*H was really talking about what was going on in Vietnam at the time and bore no resemblance to the Korean Conflict.  A Man for All Seasons, while taking it's setting in Tudor England much more seriously, was exploring very twentieth century notions of conscience.  I would argue Mad Men does the same in reference to our consumeristic society.  But unlike M*A*S*H it does take it's historical setting seriously to the point of making it almost another character.  I disagree with critics who say the show works well the least when the stories interact directly with the events of the time.  I find Matthew Weiner and his writers are actually pretty subtle in that department and the detail only adds to he experience.  As I observed about Season Five I felt there were times the story could have taken place at anytime, which loses some of the magic.  I will admit that there is a balance to be struck between letting the story unfold naturally and forcing it to follow historical events in a contrived way.  I think Mad Men does it, and here's to hoping they continue)

2. The Old Don Draper is Back, Sort Of.  When last we saw our anti-hero he was sitting at a bar being hit on by proxy; one sweet young thing making a pitch on behalf of another.  Don had been faithful to his second wife up to this point, but the look in his eyes said the streak was about to end.  While we go the full length of the season opening two parter without a hint of infidelity, the closing scene brings us the ugly truth.  Not only is Don cheating, but he's doing it with the wife of a close friend; a neighbor, even.

I did read one blogger who was surprised he was cheating again. I wasn't (I can't see how you could read the season 5 finale any other way than that this was the road he was taking). Who he is cheating with did catch me by surprise.  Don hasn't had many (any?) real friends out side of Anna Draper, his "widow."  Now he seems to have a real respect for Dr. Rosen that is contradicted by this most wretched betrayal.

But there is a difference.  Don seems guilty, something he never did before.  The season one or two Don saw life as now and death is the big sleep in which there are no dreams and from which no one wakes.  So take what you can when you can and make sure you have a clean path to the door if a jealous husband shows up.  Now he's reading Dante and wondering about hell.  When asked by his illicit love what his New Year's resolution is he replies, "to stop doing this."  The old Don may have said these words, but with a twinkle in his eye and an inch of irony covering the words as he demonstrated the very thing he was going to give up.  Now he is a man conflicted; still in love with his wife but struggling to put on the new man. 

3. Betty Francis is Wacked.  I came in last night after the first commercial break, so when I saw Betty get all up in Henry's grill about his response to a teenage violinist I didn't have the context for her putting him on the spot until I caught the first twenty minutes on the replay.  It still didn't make any sense.  And maybe it wasn't supposed to.  Otherwise she tries to mentor the young musician, essentially trying to help her not make the same mistakes she made as an aspiring model.  She goes looking for her after she runs away and winds up on the set of Midnight Cowboy (not literally, of course) with a bunch of hippie squatters in an abandoned New York building.  Can you say, awkward?  To be honest I didn't really get who the house guest was and why they were responsible for her.  Even after she runs away Betty seems to be the only once concerned about a 15 year old wandering in the City.  What this character's journey is supposed to be, I'm not sure.  But it seems Weiner and his crew are setting her up for a wild ride.

4. A Pleasant Surprise. Usually when a character leaves SCDP they are off the show as well.  That was a fear when Peggy Olson jumped to a rival agency.  Not only was she in the show last night, she got a considerable amount of story time.  Here's hoping the trend continues.  

Friday, April 5, 2013

Oz The Great and Powerful

There are a few films that I don't believe anyone is ever going to have the guts to remake. Citizen Kane for one. Casablanca is another (though there was an attempt at making a TV series out of it in the 80's).  I would add almost anything by Stanley Kubrick, though again a TV mini-series was made of the Shining.  In fairness this was a try at being truer to the Stephan King source material than Kubrick had been.  Gus Van Sant made an ill advised shot for shot remake of Psycho in 1998, which was almost universally panned.  We may do prequels or sequels or spin offs focusing on once minor players, but rightly or wrongly certain films defy duplication because of their iconic stature.  And even attempting an origin story or sequel can be dicey in these cases since we are always going to have the original in our minds.   

The Wizard of Oz is one such film that defies recreation, and the deep impression it made on generations of youngsters makes adding to the story problematic.  An attempt was made by Disney at a sequel in the 80's to disastrous effect.  Now they've tried an origin story, Oz the Great and Powerful, with Sam Raimi directing, that has the critics polarized.  Though it's hanging on by its fingernails to a "Fresh" rating on the Rotten Tomatoes site, a majority of the "top critics" featured have savaged it.  The Daily News' Elizabeth Weitzman went so far as giving it zero stars.  I was not expecting to see it, thus I knew the critical buzz going in, something I generally avoid if I know I'm going to write something.  I must say, as I was watching the movie all I could think was, "OK, it ain't exactly Dorothy and Toto, but it isn't that bad. In fact, it isn't bad at all." 

John Franco plays the title role of a carnival huckster who finds himself transported to the magic land of Oz when he tries to escape from a jealous strong man via a hot air balloon.  He encounters three witches, played by Mila Kunis, Rachael Weisz and Michelle Williams.  All appear good, but are they?  Yes, we have Munchkins and flying monkeys, along with tinkers and lake fairies added to the mix.  A few of the conceits from original movie are used, most notably that many of the people he encounters in Oz bare uncanny similarities to those he left behind in Kansas.  There is a doubt sown as to whether all this is really happening or it's just his imagination.  But neither is used fully, and unlike the original you are left believing that Oz is a real place.

The bottom line is, I didn't love this movie but it isn't the unmitigated disaster some have made it out to be.  Yes, it's adding on to a legendary film that many people, including myself, practically have memorized; a hard thing to live up to.  But remember that L. Frank Baum wrote several books about Dorothy and the land of Oz; why not try to adapt more of these stories to the screen?  The Wizard of Oz itself was not a very popular film when it was released in 1939, only gaining it's large audience when it started to get shown on TV in the '50's.  I'm not sure Oz the Great and Powerful is destined for that kind of immortality, but for a rainy day you could do worse. 

Thursday, April 4, 2013

Roger Ebert (1942-2013)



I was going to the movies Thursday afternoon when I checked the Drudge Report for any news on the North Korean crisis.  I know, one of their missiles couldn't hit Guam, let alone the main land U.S., but they could cause all sorts of other mischief that could have us stumble into war.  At the top left hand corner of the page were a series of headlines about the crisis, but as I scrolled down there was a photo of a familiar, bespectacled, roly poly man.  Bellow was the simple headline: "Ebert Dead."

Roger Ebert was the film critic for the Chicago Sun Times for 46 years, and co-hosted, along with the late Gene Siskel, a TV show for over 30 years that ran under various names that popularized film criticism.  He was the first film critic to win a Pulitzer Prize, and both he and his partner in cinematic crime were greatly influential on many a budding film critic, including yours truly.   

Ebert was born and raised a Catholic.  Though he had strayed from the pious orthodoxy of his youth, he always identified himself as Catholic.  I must say, while I didn't always agree with his views on religion or film, he was always fair.  I remember a review he did of the film Mass Appeal, a favorite of many liberal Catholics.  While he sympathized with the point of view of the protagonists, he felt the opposition were treated like caricatures when the more traditional position deserved a fairer hearing.  Thus he gave it a "Thumbs Down," much to Siskel's surprise.  He also gave a strongly positive review of Mel Gibson's The Passion of the Christ, when that film was accused of being anti-Semitic and too violent (he did feel it deserved an NC-17 for the violence, but didn't necessarily think the explicitness was out of place).  He was a man of the left who never let his political convictions stop him from saying a movie wasn't any good, no matter how much its heart bled.  

I know some people who thought he could come off as a bit pompous or as a know it all (I can't say that I was one of them).  A montage of outtakes from the 1980's that can be found on You Tube shows him to be viciously witty, and a tad cruel to his less articulate co-host.  But there was a humanity to his critical approach that showed a sensitivity to actors and subjects that taught me that to review a film is not simply a matter of understanding the technical aspects of the cinematic arts, but that you have to allow yourself to feel; that the emotional response to a film was just as important, more so even, than the intellectual considerations.

So I went to the movies this afternoon, but couldn't quite get myself to write a review.  I will though, in spite of the fact that I was distracted a bit once I shut my phone off and the credits rolled.  I will write a review, just, not right now. I never met Roger Ebert, of course, but in a way I felt like he had been my teacher; he and Gene Siskel both.  So, I mourn as for a lost mentor.  I pray for him, and his widow, Chaz.   

Eternal rest grant unto him O Lord, and let perpetual light shine upon him.  May his soul, and all the souls of the faithful departed rest in peace. Amen

Look here for a complete obituary,  

Wednesday, April 3, 2013

Why I Wear the Roman Collar (Most of the Time)






Two anecdotes:

Holy Rosary Parish has an adoration chapel that is attached to the residence where the Salesians live.  There is a small vestibule between the residence and the chapel, and the hours the Blessed Sacrament is exposed intersects the community prayer times, so it is common for members of the public to be with us as we pray, or to run into people coming or going in the hall.  There is one regular, an Irish lady, very devout, who is unafraid to tell you what she thinks, though always in a very pleasant manner.  It was an afternoon just before evening prayer and I had no responsibilities down the hill that night, so I had changed out of my clerical shirt into "civies," as we call them.  This lady stopped me at the door of the chapel and said, "Father, where is your Holy Collar?  I told you, you should always wear the Holy Collar!" Being tired, and in no mood to argue, I replied, politely mind you, "It's in the holy laundry." She protested, a bit frustrated with my flippant response, but I kept on moving into the chapel for evening prayer.

Anecdote Number Two: A friend of mine who is assigned to a high school was flying home for the Easter break, wearing his clerical shirt.  The lady sitting next to him on the plane was unimpressed, and in fact was quite hostile.  She said that he should be ashamed of himself wearing such a thing, considering the horrible things priests have done.  This lady went on to proclaim an unholy litany of crimes and mortal sins committed by members of the Catholic clergy over the years.  Fr. Matt, a far better man than I, in his typical passionate but charitable way told the lady, "I share your hurt and burn with the very same indignation. However, just as every officer doesn't abuse authority given or every teacher violate the trust of their students, so not every priest commits scandal."  I'm not sure that answer satisfied her, but it was more thoughtful and measured than I would have come up with on the spot.

I do wear the Roman collar regularly.  Certainly any time I'm ministering publicly, and usually, though not always, when I travel (I would say that more an more I choose to when traveling by air).  If I am around the house, out with friends or family, or simply running out to the Shoprite for milk I usually don't wear it, or at least I won't go out of my way to, unless the function calls for formal attire.  There are priests who wear it all the time, under every circumstance.  Others hardly wear it at all.  I guess if I were to pick an extreme, it would be toward the "wearing it too much" side, though I've always been a fan of moderation. There is a movement toward abandoning clerical dress among priests, and I think it a mistake.  Many priests don't don the collar because they see it as something that sets a barrier between themselves and the people; that it promotes a class system that Jesus would have rejected.  Is clericalism a danger? Sure it is.  But I encountered plenty of clericalism in my travels through Latin America and the vast majority of priests wear lay clothing there.  Clericalism has no dress code, so I wear it with absolutely no concern that people think that I'm putting on airs.

I wear it because symbols are important, and Catholicism relies heavily on symbols to get it's message across.  The collar is a symbol: it is the symbol of a public commitment to the Gospel.  It is a symbol of the simplicity of life I have been called to; there is no wasting time deciding what tie matches which shirt in the morning.  The black shirt symbolizes mortality, that I am to witness to the transience of life and that my heart is set on the world to come (this is a reason I reject colored clericals, though there are certainly good reasons to wear lighter colors, especially in the heat of summer).  Most of all it shows that there are still men following the call in an age of unbelief.  Is there a chance that the sight of the Holy Collar could stir up negative emotions in some people who have had bad experiences in the past?  Yes.  Nonetheless it's worth the risk if it reaches others positively.  If someone does have a negative reaction, like that woman had with Fr. Matt, it opens up an opportunity to share and change hearts that probably wouldn't have happened otherwise.     

Parenthetically, I know and work with religious sisters who are very dedicated and faithful.  But I do believe it was a mistake for many of them to abandon the habit; not because a piece of cloth makes them better religious, but because they lost the ability to be public symbols of something larger than themselves.  I do wonder if rejecting the habit did something to exacerbate the vocation crisis; with so many religious, both men and women, out of sight, are they also out of mind to the public as well, especially to young people?  Does a habit for sisters have to include a veil (the question is not rhetorical, I really want to know)?  In Mexico many sisters wear distinctive cloths that clearly identify them as religious that do not include a veil.  It's a complex issue, I know, and my intent is not to finger point or condemn, simply to raise the question.

As I wrote above, there are those who object to the wearing of a habit or clerical clothing by priests and religious, but most of those who object are priests and religious.  I have never heard a parishioner, a student, or a lay colleague complain that we wear the collar too much, or that they feel somehow alienated by it.  Many will complain when we don't, and some are scandalized if our dress is a little too worldly.  Are there times when "dressing down" is acceptable?  Of course; even Bl. John Paul II wore "regular" cloths, including shorts, when he went camping.  On a regular basis though priests and religious do a greater service than they know by wearing their habit or clerical clothing, particularly when they're "on duty."  It is a way to preach without ever opening your mouth. 
Karol Wojtyla went hiking with these students in 1954. Pope John Paul II has maintained an active outdoor life throughout his tenure as bishop, cardinal and pope.
Bishop Wojtyła kicking back with some friends, sans cassock

Saturday, March 30, 2013

Holy Saturday: A Time to Think

Today is taken up with the long wait.  From Holy Thursday night through Good Friday there is a flurry of liturgical and devotional activity surrounding the life of a parish; an Hispanic parish even more, or it seems so to me.  There are English services, then we do it again in Spanish, with the traditional Stations of the Cross taking the form of a procession through the streets, with actors playing out the rolls of Roman soldiers, good and bad thieves, the women of Jerusalem, the Virgin Mary, and of course Jesus, along with the rest of the "cast of characters."  Police need to close the streets to make all this happen.  But once the dust settles late Friday night there is a quiet that descends.  The next idem on the agenda is the Easter Vigil that doesn't begin until after dusk Saturday.  This leaves time for the final preparations, true, but since most of the heavy prep work is already done, there is even more time to simply sit and think.

These are a few things that have been preoccupying my mind.

Pope Francis

I was at the Salesian High School President's Gala last week and the topic of the new Pope did come up.  Everyone I spoke to praised Pope Francis, but one person I spoke to was concerned.  She was impressed by Francis' humility and common touch, but said, "He has to realize that he is the Pope.  He can't act like everything is normal.  His life will never be the same again.  There are people who are going to want to hurt him, and he just shouldn't rush into crowds like he's been doing." (She was referring to when the Holy Father greeted the people on the street after Palm Sunday Mass, driving the security people crazy.)

Francis is not the first pope to try the patience of his security detail.  I know a former Secret Service agent who was assigned to protect Blessed John Paul on his U.S. visit in 1996 and tells the story of asking the Holy Father to simply wave from the steps and then proceed directly to the limo after an event at St. Patrick's Cathedral in New York.  There was a huge, cheering crowd waiting for His Holiness on Fifth Avenue.  The agent saw a sea of potential threats.  To John Paul II it was God's people, be they Catholic or not, and he was going to reach out to them.  So the Pope turned to the agent and said, "You can stay here if you want, but that is where the people are, so that is where I'm going."  The agent could only shrug, roll his eyes nervously and follow the man in the white cassock.

But there are other aspects of Pope Francis' informal style that are putting people off.  He is already being criticized by those on the "right" for what appears to be liturgical laxity.  He came out on the Loggia of St. Peter's after his election in the traditional white cassock, but without the red mozzetta, and was only handed a stole by the Papal M.C. just before giving the Urbi et Orbi blessing.  He held the Holy Thursday night Mass in a youth prison (a bit déclassé, but oh well), but then he had the effrontery of breaking Church law by washing the feet of non-Catholics and girls.  Too much, indeed.  Pope Francis has consistently chosen the simpler rout in all his public appearances. While "liberals" take heart in these low church displays, they are not happy with other aspects of the pontiff's "style."

For all his lack of interest in liturgical pomp Francis is simply not the progressive savior many on the left were hoping for.  Theologically he is right in line with Popes Benedict XVI and John Paul II. 
So, no married or women priests, no change in the teaching on contraception, while a big yes to social justice and advocacy for the poor it's still a no (and being a Latin American an ironic no) to liberation theology as a means to that end.  And a no to sacramentalizing same sex unions.  For those expecting the Catholic Church to transform Herself into the World Council of Churches, your wait continues, and will into perpetuity.    

Facebook Advocacy

This week many people, including more than a few I'm connected to on FB changed their profile picture to an image of a reddish equal sign on a deep red background to symbolize their support for gay marriage.  Most, if not all, of the people who did this in my "universe" are not gay, but were showing solidarity to the cause.  This flurry of activity coincided with the oral arguments being made before the Supreme Court on two cases that impact this issue.  I have written extensively here in this blog on the topic, and weary of having to once again explain my opposition to calling a relationship, even a committed one, between people of the same sex a marriage in the Christian understanding of what that means.  But I will make two observations about what I saw this week.

First, I saw a lot of sloganeering, but very little reasoning.  It was political debate by Hallmark Card.  Personally, I'm not sure what the same sex marriage lobby thinks matrimony is, or how they define it from the various postings I read, beyond that if you love it you should be able to put a ring on it (a clear legal standard if I ever saw one).  If we are going to say that the sex or gender of the individuals shouldn't pose a limit on their ability to get a marriage license, then what should? Age? Number?  I know that no one likes the slipper slope argument, but we do have a polygamist tradition in this country that has been known to play loose and fast with age of consent laws.  If we are going to argue that the limiting of marriage to people of different sexes is arbitrary (which I do not) then what are age of consent laws?  They vary from state to state with some setting up sliding scales that formulate how much of an age difference between partners has to be before it goes from being consensual sex to statutory rape.  If we follow the FB playbook there really is no reason to place any limits, are there?  If the definition of marriage is going to be so wide open, I'm not sure what interest the state has in regulating it at all.

Second, a word of warning to gay marriage advocates:  Do you really want the Supreme Court deciding this?  They intervened in 1973 on the abortion issue and it has not left us since.  The truth is that if Roe v Wade had never happened abortion would still be legal today, probably in every state.  Some states would have tighter restrictions than others, true.  There would still be a pro-life movement looking for even greater restrictions and eventual abolition, along with a pro-choice movement looking for greater access.  I doubt though that the issue would be this divisive because it would be in the hands of the people, not in the hands of unelected judges.  Even Ruth Bader Ginsberg, who in my mind is practically a eugenicist, has acknowledged this problem with the high court's decision.

My prediction? If the issue is left to the states gay marriage will become the law of the land within five years.  If things play out like it has in the Scandinavian countries that started issuing marriage licenses to same sex couples twenty years ago there will be a rush on city halls by gay couples, followed by a run on divorce lawyers, and then the percentage of gay couples seeking marriage licences with become a statistical trickle when compared to their straight counterparts (it's interesting to me that the Canadian government, which legalized gay marriage a decade ago, has stopped keeping marriage and divorce statistics.  What is it they don't want us to know?).  If the Court decides you'll get what you want right away, but then we'll have protests and wrangling for decades to come because people will feel this was something forced on them from above.  Either way I see the legal recognition of gay relationships as marriages as being a further erosion of the social structure, but allowing it to proceed more organically will do less damage and really give people a chance to think about what is being proposed and not just throw out catchy slogans.

Easter is Near

My final reflection is that Lent is over, the Triduum is almost completed and Easter is almost upon us.  The point of this cycle for those already baptized is to experience renewal.  We are to look back at our lives and see where it is we are not in line with what Christ taught and lived and make corrections with God's grace .  In other words, it is a time to repent.  For those looking to the Church to alter Her teachings or practices, I quote Mother Teresa, who when asked by a reporter what in the Church needed to change, replied, "You and I."  Being a disciple of Christ was never about getting what we want, or going the easy road.  At times the Apostles themselves questioned if what was being asked of them by the Master was reasonable.

This is not about condemning, judging or any of the like.  I am a sinner.  I have my own crosses.  I have my own impurities that need to be burned away by God's grace.  I, as a priest, have to preach, but not as one who commands, but as one who offers the Gospel to others, as I myself try everyday to live in a better, purer, more holy way this awesome call I have been given. 

I pray for all of you during these Holy Hours.  Please keep me in your prayers as well.  

Thursday, March 14, 2013

Some Further Reflections on Pope Francis




A day has passed since the election of Pope Francis, and here are a few more scattered thoughts on the new Bishop of Rome.

You Can't Have a First Without a Second

Officially, the new pope is to be known as Pope Francis, without any Roman numeral after it.  We would only start calling him "the First" if a successor took the name Francis for himself.  For instance, until Queen Elizabeth II assumed the thrown of England her Tudor predecessor was simply known, during her reign and after her death, as Queen Elizabeth.  What is interesting is that Pope John Paul I broke that precedent by declaring himself "the First" when he took his papal name.  It was suggested to me that he "knew" there would be a second.  Maybe a prophetic voice was speaking through him, but I doubt Albino Luciano though his successor would come quite so quickly.

Instruction on Certain Aspects of the "Theology of Liberation"

Yesterday I wrote that Pope Francis has a deep dedication to the poor, and that he knew liberation theology (LT) from the inside.  Both statements are true, but this should not lead to the impression that he supports that theological outlook.  He has been highly critical of LT, criticism that has led to a bit of a rift between himself and the Jesuits, the order he was a member of before becoming a bishop. A few Latin American religious I know were hopeful of a cardinal from their region being elected for the very reason that he would be sympathetic toward LT.  I'm afraid they will be sourly disappointed 

I do not claim to be an expert on LT, but having studied in a Mexican seminary I did get the opportunity to study it in its "native setting," if you will.  The Salesian Theological Institute in Tlaquepaque, Jalisco was not conservative or traditional in the ways we think of here in the U.S., but the professors were for the most part schooled in Rahner and von Balthazar; pretty main stream European theologians.  There was a particular course on LT, and one of our pastoral theology classes was pretty much coming from that approach.   We had seminars on indigenous theology, which is an offshoot of LT.  I don't want to get off track on a critique of the Theology of Liberation, but to say it was presented to me by several professors, both in Mexico and here in the U.S., as an all or nothing proposition.  Either you take it all or you reject it.  Well, if that is the case, I say goodbye and good luck.  While I sympathize with aspects of it, there are simply too many holes in it for me to embrace it in its entirety. 

As Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger wrote a controversial instruction on LT, that was not a full condemnation, but stated there were deep problems with some expressions of it.  When he became Benedict XVI many of the proponents thought they could just wait him out, and a successor, especially from Latin America, would look more kindly upon their cause.  If they thought approbation would come from Pope Francis, they are seriously mistaken.

A Jesuit Pope

Technically, if a member of a religious order becomes a bishop they leave their community and become a member of a diocese.  This has to do primarily with the vow of obedience; bishops belong to the universal Church, and as successors of the Apostles they can't be subject to a religious superior.  Nonetheless many, probably most, religious bishops still identify with their order.  It is not uncommon for them to sign their names with their congregation's initials after their name, like I would put "SDB" after my signature to identify myself as a Salesian.  When they retire they have the right to be taken back into one of their order's houses to live.

But more than these practicalities, to be a Salesian, a Franciscan or a Jesuit like Pope Francis is to imbued with a particular spirit and spirituality.  We are all Catholic, all disciples of Christ, but we each have different styles of living out that discipleship.  Another added wrinkle is that Francis was a member of a Salesian parish in his youth, and maintains a strong devotion to Mary Help of Christians and Blessed Artemide Zatti, a Salesiam brother.  He also presided at the beatification of Zeffirino  Namuncura, a Salesian alumni from Argentina who, like Dominick Savio, died young.

What the pope being a Jesuit will mean, especially considering his strained ties with his community, I can't say.  Jesuits are intellectuals, but they are also missionaries.  Time will only tell.    

Wednesday, March 13, 2013

Viva Il Papa: First Thoughts on Pope Francis



First Impressions:

We were in the middle of our afternoon session at the Provincial Chapter when the white smoke started billowing from the Sistine Chapel chimney (more of us were looking at our laptops and tablets than the presentations going on).  We continued with our meeting for about another twenty minutes before finally adjourning to watch the drama together on TV.  And it really was drama.  This entire interregnum has been strange owing to it coming on the heals of a retirement as opposed to a death.  In spite of the intrigue reported on in the press, there was more of an atmosphere of business men getting together for board meetings rather than a spiritual gathering to choose the next Vicar of Christ.  But once the white smoke started and our eyes were fixed on the loggia doors I felt real suspense for the first time. 

I guess my first thought was that Francis looked a bit overwhelmed.  He looked a bit stiff, a bit old, considering all the talk of the cardinals going for a younger, more physically vibrant figure.   I wondered if we were looking at a compromise candidate or a transitional pope (two in a row?), one who will keep the seat warm until the one they really want matures or else gains the proper support.  Upon a second look at the video I would say that the Holy Father looked a touch more natural than at first viewing. Beyond that, in the few hours since he has become pope I have learned more about the man, and have come to the conclusion that first impressions in this case may be deceiving. 

What's in a Name?

In the past popes often chose their name to honor a predecessor who had helped them along the way to the Chair of Peter, or to show a desire to follow in a particular pope's footsteps.  Since at least John XXIII and Paul VI new popes have tried to say something about the kind of pope they want to be, giving hints as to an agenda they might be trying to follow.  What could the choice of Francis mean?

Before I knew he was a Jesuit, the first thing that popped into my head upon hearing his chosen name was Francis of Assisi.  As Cardinal Archbishop of Buenas Aires he sold the episcopal residence, lived in a simple apartment, took the metro to work (he doesn't own a car) and cooked his own meals.  Someone reminded me of Francis Xavier, the Jesuit missionary saint who traveled to India and Japan, dying on the way to China.  This would show a commitment to the New Evangelization and the priority of spreading the Gospel in a secularized world.

But his action upon going out on the Loggia show a clear link to the founder of the Franciscans.  He wore the white cassock, but without the usual fur lined cape and stole that new pontiffs usually don for their first post election appearance.  He presented a simple figure. He spoke of himself as the Bishop of Rome, who presides in charity over the other churches.  This hearkens back to Ignatius of Antioch, bishop and martyr of the late first, early second century who thus described the Roman church in one of his letters.  Again, a more humble, simple discriptor that points to the roots of the Church.  Could he be pointing to a need for simplify?  A need to get back to the roots of the faith and evangelization?  St. Francis' mission was to rebuild a Church that was falling down because of corruption and scandal.  What is Pope Francis trying to tell us about his choice of name?

Liberal or Conservative?


As Cardinal Jorge Mario Borgoglio, Pope Francis was critical of economic policies in his native Argentina that advanced some in the society while leaving many more in poverty.  In general his has been outspoken criticizing the unjust distribution of wealth and the need for Third World debt forgiveness.  So, he's liberal, no?  Well, he's also called abortion the "death penalty" for the unborn and is a staunch supporter of marriage as a union between one man and one woman.  So, he's conservative, right? 

Pope Francis is the perfect example of why you can't use contemporary political categories to label popes.  In the teachings of any recent pontiff there will be things to both comfort and enrage people on all sides of the political spectrum.  The bottom line is, if you were hoping for sweeping changes on Catholic moral teachings, you are out of luck.  If you are hopping for someone more sympathetic with the cause of social justice and has a clear understanding of liberation theology from the inside, you should be pleased.

Watch Out Curia

As I wrote, Pope Francis stressed his position as Bishop of Rome, and mentioned the need to "evangelize the city."  This is an odd thing to say for the Universal Pastor whose concern is for all the churches.  Could be be making a veiled comment about the state of the Vatican itself?  There was much talk during the sede vacante about the Curia, the Church's Roman bureaucracy, and it's need for reform.  There was a perceived split inside the College of Cardinals between the Curial insiders (who want to maintain the status quo of secrecy, but who also tend to be more liberal doctrinally) and the outsiders from the U.S. and other parts of the world (who want a more transparent Church government, but who also tend to be more conservative on doctrinal issues).  My gut tells me His Holiness is a New World Pope with a desire to streamline the bureaucracy.  Again, in the spirit of Brother Sun, simplify, strip down, keep the Church simple, but agile and responsive to contemporary needs. 

These are my first impressions.  Only time will tell how much is right and how much misses the mark.  Let's pray for Pope Francis, that he may follow the will of God and have the stregnth to lead his flock. 

Tuesday, March 12, 2013

Conclave Day 1.2: At the Provincial Chapter

STONY POINT, N.Y. - As the cardinal electors began the conclave in Rome I was participating in day two of a more humble, somewhat less noteworthy assemblage of ecclesiastics here in Rockland County.  The Salesian's of the Eastern U.S. and Canada are holding our triennial meetings known as the Provincial Chapter.  Every Salesian Province world wide are holding them at some point during this year as a way to prepare for the General Chapter taking place in Rome coming up next year.  Those world wide meetings happen every six years, so that the local chapters that don't line up with them handle issues particular to the given province.  The other difference between the chapter I'm on now and those "off year" chapters is that we will elect a delegate to accompany the provincial to Rome for the three months of meetings that will begin in February, 2014.

If it sounds exciting, it's not.  The going can be deadly tedious.  Right now is not so bad.  Actually, what we're doing is pretty important.  We are debating the very meaning of our life as disciples of Christ, and how we are and should be living it out as sons of Don Bosco in 2013.  Today focused on our life as mystics, which always a slippery wicket.  Ours is a active, apostolic congregation that sees action as a key part of our spirituality.  At the same time we are being called to explore what some consider more monastic forms of spirituality in order to avoid superficiality and an activism that can blind us from remembering why we are engaging all the hard work of our everyday life.  The small group discussions have been fruitful.  We don't always agree with each other, but it is in the disagreements and the attempt to reconcile the differences that I believe the Spirit is often speaking to us.

The tedious part will come when the writing committee comes back with an initial draft and we have to all agree on wording.  Have you ever seen 44 men argue over the placement of a comma?  It's not pretty, let me tell you. Once it's done the final document is sent off to our generalate in Rome, and hopefully it will make some impact on the proceedings their next year.

These meetings will go on until Monday, the 18th.  The cardinals will have done their work and elected a pope by then, or at least I hope and pray.  Obviously we are in meetings all day and most evenings, so we are not glued to the TV.  The advent of smart phones and tablets have made sneaking a peak at the various news feeds a bit easier.  It was like March Madness today, but we were looking to see what color the smoke was coming out of the Sistine Chapel as opposed to which teams were getting knocked off our brackets. 

Well, one bright spot is the nightly social we have where we get to just relax and enjoy eachother's company.  So I am off, and will be back soon with more thoughts on the goings on at the Vatican and Stony Point.

Conclave Day One: A New Pope and the Prodigal Son





STONY POINT, NY - This morning (afternoon in Rome) the cardinal electors will enter the Sistine Chapel, after the celebration of the Eucharist in St. Peter’s, to formally begin the election of a new pope.  Since Pope Benedict announced his retirement a month ago the press has been abuzz with speculation over a possible successor.  The U.S. media in particular have asked if the cardinals a will choose a progressive who will usher in sweeping changes or a conservative along the lines of John Paul II or Benedict XVI.  Others ask if he will be someone from Latin America or Africa.  All this speculation misses the point a bit, though I admit that a pope from outside Europe would be significant.  In the end the cardinals are not electing a political candidate who needs to conform to some kind of party platform, or at least they shouldn’t be.  They are electing the man best qualified to protect the invaluable inheritance of the Church.  The pope’s main role is to conserve the spiritual treasure handed on from the Apostles, and oversee its authentic development.

This past Sunday most of us heard the story of the Prodigal Son at Mass.  In preaching I usually focus on the loving and forgiving father who eagerly accepts his wayward son back, or maybe the hard hearted older brother who finds forgiveness difficult or the Lost Son himself in all his pitiable desperation.  I guess what struck me this time around was the line that the Lost Son had squandered his inheritance.  Was our Lord speaking of money?  On a literal level; sure.  But there is a deeper meaning as well.  If we recall, Sunday’s first reading from the Book of Joshua told of the Israelites finally entering the Promised Land after forty years in the desert.  The first thing they did was to celebrate the Passover: the memorial of their liberation from slavery in Egypt.  To this day Jews celebrate the Passover to recall the great works God has accomplished for them, and points to the great spiritual heritage encapsulated in the Law and the prophets.  At the Seder Meal, when he youngest of the house asks that ritual question of the oldest: why is this night different from all others, the answer is the story of their Exodus.  This is something to be remembered always, along with the Law received later on Sinai.  These form a spiritual inheritance to be cherished and followed in gratitude to the generous God who freed them from bondage.  What the younger son squandered by his life of dissolute living was more than a material fortune, but more importantly he wasted a spiritual inheritance beyond price given to him by his father.

When we sin, especially when we have allowed sin to become a vice, we are turning away from the path of the Lord, in a way rejecting the great spiritual heritage that has been passed on to us from the Apostles.  This is an inheritance that we should hold close to and not squander.  Is God a forgiving, compassionate Father?  YES!  We should never despair that He will turn us away when we sin if we come back in sincerity of heart.  But we are called to something great, and offered a treasure greater than can be stored in all the bank vaults of the world.  It is not to be squandered but preserved, lived and passed on to future generations.

The role of the pope is to preserve both the moral teachings of Christ and His Church and the Apostolic Tradition in its entirety.  His first duty is not to create new doctrines, alter old ones, or change long standing disciplines that are unpopular.  His main responsibility is to preserve.  This is the heart of papal infallibility.  Over the centuries the Church has seen charismatic figures like Francis of Assisi, Thomas Aquinas, Catherine of Sienna, Don Bosco and Dorothy Day, to name a few, who have challenged the status quo.  It was the pope, along with the college of bishops in general, who asked if the movements they inspired represented authentic promptings of the Spirit in harmony with Tradition and Scripture or if they were passing novelties out of step with the living tradition of the Church.  Each of these examples represents a positive response, but only after periods of trial and testing.  There is a constant tension between charism on the one hand and authority on the other; one seeking to push ahead and the other looking to hold fast to the tried and true.  Both have their place, and it is the pope, who represents authority, to test, probe and finally make a judgement with the help of the Spirit.

We are the inheritors of a great heritage passed on by the Apostles, that in reality goes back even farther to Moses and Abraham.  This inheritance is to be lived and cherished.  No matter who the pope ends up being his first job will be to foster, protect and spread this gift from God.  I certainly hope he is open to where the Spirit wants that Tradition to move, and the courage point out where it is being squandered by false teachers.

Thursday, March 7, 2013

As the Cardinals Gather: Sede Vacante Part II. Or "I'm Dreaming of an American Pope?"

Boston's Cardinal O'Malley: Papabile?


I must admit that I feel more than a bit inferior as Catholic bloggers go.  I don't keep in contact with any cardinals, curial or otherwise.  I have no inside track on the Papabili, those poor souls most talked about in the press as contenders to be the next to wear the red shoes.  My one claim to fame is that I was ordained a priest by Oscar Cardinal Rodriguez, SDB of Tegucigalpa, whose name emerged in pope watching circles as early as 2001 and continued to get a lot of buzz before the conclave of 2005.  While he's not on most "experts" short lists now, he's still getting some mentions this time around.  I really don't even have enough time these days to scan the press so I can give you my penetrating inexpert analysis.

But I have done some superficial reading and listening, which has lead me to the conclusion that March 2013 is shaping up to be much like August 1978, and April 2005.   In both 1978 and 2005 voices in the press and in some quarters of the Church were calling for a pope who would follow through on what they considered the logical conclusions of Vatican II: an end to mandatory priestly celibacy, the ordination of women, the relaxing of the traditional prohibitions of contraception and premarital sex.  Today we can add the call for some type of recognition of same sex unions, even if it falls short of actually considering them sacramental marriages.  Along with these very specific reforms, there was a desire to see a more decentralized Church, where local dioceses had more autonomy, much like in the Orthodox Churches or the Anglican Communion.

As I wrote the last time out, I think all this talk of doctrinal shifts is a chasing at shadows.  Every new pope since at least Pius IX in 1846, with the possible exception of Leo XIII, was thought to be the one who was going to "modernize" the Church.  In each case doctrine remained substantially unchanged, with the exception of the two Marian pronouncements.  Some did make structural changes in how the Church apparatus functioned, or made adjustments to certain practices, like the lowering of the First Communion age by Pius X, but none can be called doctrinally progressive in the contemporary sense.  Even Paul VI, seen as the progressive implementer of Vatican II, reaffirmed the Church's teaching on contraception, priestly celibacy and the all male priesthood, as well as speaking of Satan as a real force rather than as an abstraction or metaphor. 

Judging by what I am managing to catch in the press the cardinals right now are not so caught up with doctrinal questions as they are with structure issues.  La Stampa's English edition is setting things up as a fight between the Italians in the Curia against the Americans.  The U.S. contingent is looking for broad reforms including greater transparency in the Vatican, and a Church bureaucracy that serves the interests of the pope and not it's own counter agenda.  The curial Italians want to maintain the status quo.  What I'm hearing is that while Europeans and Latin Americans are leery of an American candidate, the African and Asian contingents have a great deal of respect for the U.S. cardinals, and so a Papabili from the New World is not as far fetched as it has been in the past.  

Among the Americans New York's Cardinal Dolan is the name that gets the most press, but Boston's Sean Cardinal O'Malley's name is emerging as well.  He's seen as someone who reformed the Archdiocese of Boston, epicenter of the sex abuse scandal, with both Sunday collections and enrollment at the local seminary on the rise in the last few years.  While an American being elected pope is still a long shot, it's nice to know that simply being from the United States doesn't automatically disqualify someone from ascending to the See of Peter.

I wrote that this time around was shaping up to be much like interregnums of the past.  But there is at least one big difference, I think.  Since this conclave has followed on the heals of a retirement as opposed to a death, the cardinals have had more time to think dispassionately about what they are doing. There is no mourning a beloved Holy Father, or sentimental feelings that a new pope needs to continue someone's legacy.  While Benedict is loved still, there is a recognition that a new direction, at least in terms of governance, needs to happen, and many of the cardinals are willing to spend the few extra days to make sure they do it right.  I pray they are doing the spiritual preparations as well as they appear to be doing the administrative due diligence.

Next week, as the conclave begins (I hope) I'll be in Provincial Chapter meetings.  We don't get locked in or anything, and there's no smoke, white or otherwise, but these are official deliberations in which we set out an agenda for the next three years and prepare for the General Chapter in Rome next year.   In the midst of the general sessions and small group break outs I'll keep one eye on Rome and the other on the keyboard.

Friday, March 1, 2013

Sede Vacante


 http://www.prophecyfilm.com/sedevacantism/sedevacantism.png


Port Chester, NY-The Chair of Peter is officially vacant.

As some of you know, I've been pulling double duty of sorts, filling in at Holy Rosary Parish here in Port Chester, while still maintaining some office hours at St. Anthony's in Elizabeth, NJ.  The Lord willing I'll be back to my old post at St. Anthony's by June.

Yesterday was one of those office days in Jersey.  Between consulting with my vicar Fr. George (who's done a great job filling in for me) and my secretary (who's had to have the patience of Job) I caught the coverage of Pope Benedict's last hours as the Vicar of Christ.  I felt very emotional watching the coverage.  It is true that Benedict isn't the charismatic figure that John Paul II was, but he still has a presence that radiates the love of Christ.

I recalled my trip to Australia for World Youth Day in 2008.  At the end of the closing Mass the Holy Father was saying his thank yous, and announced the worst kept secret of the week: that Madrid would host the next WYD.  Before he gave the final blessing, he simply told us that he was going.  I spontaneously said, just above a whisper, "No."  I wasn't the only one.  It felt like there was a quiet wave no's spreading through the crowd.  It was the no of a child who didn't want his father to leave.  It was the no of the two disciples along the road to Emmaus who tried to convince our Lord to stay for the hour was late and the night was drawing near.  I felt in a very visceral way that Peter was here with us, our link back to Christ, and I didn't want him to go. It had nothing to do with being close to power, and everything to do with the fatherly presence he exuded.

I felt that yesterday at 2pm local time when I went to the switch that controls our church bell.  As the top of the hour struck I flipped the switch and the bells rang signifying that the Seat of Peter was vacant.  Although the Pope is not dead, Peter was gone, and it was hard to see the difference. 

Opinion on the Holy Father's decision is split.  Some, including Cardinal Pell from Australia, have questioned the decision.  While being critical of Benedict's governing style, he fears this could lead to future pontiffs being pressured to step down by those who oppose them.  Others, of a more progressive stamp than His Eminence, are happy with the move, and are wasting no time offering their two cents to the cardinal electors as they prepare for the conclave.  For them the Church needs a more practical leader who will listen to others after two intellectual popes.  Popes, they argue, who were so smart they didn't think they needed to listen to anyone.

As for the first opinion, I agree that there is a danger that what Cardinal Pell is afraid of could happen.  In this case I trust the Holy Father:  this retirement was long in the planning, and reputedly included that surprising consistory from late last year that added seven new cardinals, all from outside Europe.  I didn't care, though, for the critique of the Pope Emeritus' reign.  I think Princes of the Church should reserve such comments for pre-conclave meetings and not give the press more reasons to speculate on Church divisions.  As for the second, many of these same liberal voices will criticize Pope St. Pius X for not being sufficiently intellectual to address the subtleties of the Modernist crisis, a crisis they claim was imaginary.  In fact the only pope that they will hold up is Blessed John XXIII, and maybe Paul VI.  They are chasing at phantoms, always hoping that the next pope will give them the "reforms" they itch for but will never come. There may very well be reforms coming, but not the kind I think many of the intellectual class will expect.

Yes, Peter is gone.  But we are not abandoned.  The Lord will supply, not always the pope we want, but the pope we need.  Let us pray that the cardinals are open to God's will, and the man chosen is prepared to say yes, and follow through on it.  

Without a Pope From AOP