Monday, July 4, 2016

Independence Day, 2016


We just finished Mass. Like Thanksgiving, we have one Mass today, bilingual - though skewed English. Unlike Thanksgiving, when the crowd rivals a Christmas day turnout, not many were in attendance.  It's the first year we're trying this, so it might take a year or two to catch on. Also, many of our parishioners have begun their summer vacations already, and are off to Mexico, Texas and Michigan, among other destinations. 

As I wrote the, Mass was bilingual. For us that usually means a smattering of English amid the readings and prayers done in Spanish. Most of our adult parishioners are Spanish speaking, and it makes the most sense to make that the dominant language. But the new Roman Missal has a Mass specifically for Independence Day in the US, so we used those prayers, which are only in the English US addition. 

They are beautiful prayers. The collect reads:

Father of all nations and ages, we recall the day when our country
claimed its place among the family of nations; 
for what has been achieved we give you thanks,
for the work that still remains we ask your help,
and as you have called us from many peoples to be one nation,
grant that, under your providence, 
our country may share your blessings
with all the peoples of the earth.
Through our Lord Jesus Christ, your Son, 
who lives and reigns with you in the unity of the Holy Spirit,
one God, for ever and ever.
The prayer over the gifts goes as such:


Father, who have molded into one our nation,
drawn from the peoples of many lands;
grant, that as the grains of wheat become one bread
and the many grapes one cup of wine,
so before all others be instruments of your peace.
The Prefes continues:


It is truly right and just, our duty and our salvation,
always and everywhere to give you thanks,
Lord, holy Father, almighty and eternal God,
through Christ our Lord.
He spoke to us a message of peace
and taught us to live as brothers and sisters.
His message took form in the vision of our founding fathers
as they fashioned a nation
where we might live as one.
His message lives on in our midst
as our task for today
and a promise for tomorrow.
The prayer after Communion sums up:
May the love we share in this Eucharist, heavenly Father,
flow in rich blessing throughout our land
and by your grace may we as a nation
place our trust in you
and seek to do your will.
Through Christ our Lord.
I felt a welling up of emotion as I prayed the collect. I was afraid that I was going to break down, to be completely honest. I experienced a deep feeling of patriotism, but not in any jingoistic way. The prayer acknowledges that we are one among the family of nations, not above them. At the same time we are unique. The prayers in general stress that we have been called to form one nation out of many different peoples. 
I'm not sure an experiment such as this has ever been tried before. This is what American exceptionalism means to me: that people come from far and wide, bring their traditions and customs, not so much melting them into an indistinguishable pot of molten goo, but placing them on the communal table, where they are shared, transformed, as well as transforming what came before. American culture is constantly being affected by the various immigrant groups that arrive. As an American of Italian descent who has visited the Old Country, I can say that being an Italian American is something distinct. I am an American, but hold a treasure different from my countrymen and women of different backgrounds. This doesn't change the fact that when I go to Italy I know that, no matter how much I love it and my family there, I am not Italian. My values have been shaped by Washington, Jefferson and Lincoln, not Garibaldi and Mazzini. 
As Mass ended, and we were processing out, I was again overcome with emotion. I feel as if something is slipping away right now. I am not ready to say that the American Experiment has failed, but it seems to be stalling. We are splintering at a time when we need unity more than ever. The ideals that have guided the country are good, but also need purification. We are locked into an individualism that will destroy us if we aren't careful. We are trapped in a materialism that is turning us inward, making us blind to the world around us, and needs of others. 
My prayer for today comes from the hymn America the Beautiful, which reminds us of our blessings, thanks God for them but also beseeches the Lord:
America! America! God mend thine ev’ry flaw,
Confirm thy soul in self-control,
Thy liberty in law!
America! America! May God thy gold refine 
Till all success be nobleness, 
And ev’ry gain divine!

Sunday, July 3, 2016

Some Random Thoughts for July 3, 2016



Blog Notes

I was taken aback at the response to my recent post on Sherry Weddell's Forming Intentional Disciples and the importance of developing a personal relationship with Jesus. It's been among the most visited posts, out side the of obituaries of deceased Salesians, that the site has had. 

What I also like is that it drew some comments. I welcome them, especially those who disagree with me. I moderate them, but I only block comments that are insulting and abusive, spam and, from proselytizers. Otherwise I enjoy a good debate. This may be self serving, but I tend to do better with them in written form. I would have made a terrible trial lawyer, because I'm not always good on my feet. I'm one of those who thinks of what I should have said an hour after the confrontation. But when I have even a few minutes to think I generally can make an intelligent response. I may not always be right, but at least I'm coherent.

In general the blog has seen an increase in traffic over the last couple of months. I unofficially "relaunched" the blog in May after about six moths of sporadic activity. I don't think Bishop Barron has anything to worry about, but it's nice to see that The Ax is growing. I don't get too deep into the analytics, but I've noticed that more and more hits are coming through Facebook. I've always posted the link there, so why traffic from there is increasing right now is a bit of a mystery.

Thanks for reading and for your support. If there are any topics that you want me write on, let me know. Don't be afraid to leave a comment, and keep on spreading the word.

Gearing up for World Youth Day

In less than two weeks I'll be leaving for World Youth Day in Krakow. There are six going from the parish, joining another 80 from various Salesian works of the Eastern Province. Ours is an extended pilgrimage, beginning in Barcelona, Spain, then crossing the Pyrenees into France where we'll hit Lourdes, Taizé, Lisieux and, Paris before concluding in Poland. 

The biggest point the other organizers and I have tired to make to the young people going, is that this is a pilgrimage - a spiritual journey. In the Middle Ages pilgrimages were associated with doing penance; making reparations for our sins and the sins of the world. Sometimes pilgrimages were done in thanksgiving for favors received through the intercession of a saint, or involved a trip to a shrine where a favor was then asked for. The graves of saints, especially martyrs, were popular pilgrimage destinations, along with the greatest pilgrimage of all, to the Holy Land. The journey was also a reminder that we are pilgrims on this earth, journeying to heaven. This isn't a permanent home, but a stop along the way to eternity. Whatever the reason, these trips were always done in the spirit of prayer, fasting and penance. 

With all the stops we're making along the way, especially in Barcelona and Paris, it's easy to look at this as a tour or a vacation: but it isn't. We won't be staying in 4 star hotels or eating at Zagat rated restaurants. The journey will be difficult. The hope is that by doing without and trusting that God will provide, we will grow deeper in confidence of divine providence. 

But in a deeper way, a pilgrimage is a way of growing closer to God, allowing Him into a our lives in a more profound way. God can only really get through to us when we are unattached to material things. We can better hear His voice when everything has been stripped away - our love of money, electronics (especially cell phones), fashions - even food and drink. When we look at material things as tools - instruments that help us live rather than the reason why we live, and learn to do without what we really don't need, God speaks to us, as he always does, but we are better able to listen. A pilgrimage, correctly entered upon, is a chance to grow in that spirit of detachment, thus growing closer to God.

My hope is to be able to blog as I go, chronicling the pilgrimage, if not day by day, at least three or four times over the two weeks. I'll be keeping a journal, and if need be post some things when I get home. Pray for me and all the pilgrims, that we may gain all the graces the Lord wants to impart on us.

Camille Paglia Frustrates the Be-Jeebies out of Me, but I Love Her Anyway

I know that I wrote about university professor, author, social critic and feminist gadfly Camille Paglia in the past (I'm too lazy right now to go back in the archives to find it), but she's been on my mind again lately. 

I saw an interview she did recently on ReasonTV, a libertarian channel on You Tube, where she blasted the PC atmosphere of the contemporary university which is driven in large part by a bloated, entrenched bureaucracy made up of leftist control freaks. Paglia is no social conservative, yet has beliefs many fellow progressive academics take issue with. She believes that the extended, multigenerational family is the best household arrangement (though admittedly not possible in this day and age), and while women should certainly have the right to pursue a career, they shouldn't be discouraged from marrying early and having large families, if they are so inclined. 

To put it very succinctly, at the root of her thought, it seems to me, is a reaction against the primacy of the political in not only art and literary criticism, but in how we view life in general. She claims that the impact of biology and psychology on the choices we make have been put aside in favor of a social critique based solely on political considerations. All art, music, drama, social attitudes - the entire perception of reality, is to be assessed by how it promotes a political goal, not how it matches up with human nature in its entirety. That a woman might want to have children instead of a career, she argues, is a natural consequence of biology that shouldn't be dismissed or suppressed. She doesn't believe that gays are born gay (keep in mind, she is a boldly "out" lesbian, and has been since so before it was cool), rather that homosexuality is a choice arrived at by a multitude of factors, including the the psychological. The points of view she puts forward are never discussed in left wing academic circles, she contends, not because they are false, but because they don't correspond to the left's political aims. 

What I find frustrating about her, is that she believes in the structured meaning in art - that words have a significance, rejecting much of post modernity's assumptions. Yet, she remains an atheist. (Have patience with me here.) I don't know if her atheism represents complete materialism, or simply that she doesn't believe in a personal God but would allow for some metaphysical reality. I just can't see how she can hold the positions that she does and not realize that, while biology and psychology need to be a part of the analytic conversation, objective meaning can't be reached by the natural sciences alone. They are sign posts, but ultimate meaning comes from a non-material source. Most people, in the West anyway, call that source God.

I put Paglia in the same camp with the late senator Daniel Patrick Moynahan whose work, before he took office, on the effects of public assistance programs in the '60's showed that welfare causes family breakdown, not the poverty which the welfare is meant to alleviate, but he still couldn't get himself to break with liberal orthodoxy on the topic. In Paglia's case, she sees that the secular progressive program has gone off the rails (she says that the celebrating of transgenderism and the proposed multiplicity of genders is the sign that a culture is collapsing, not getting stronger), but still can't get herself to part company completely with it. Maybe because she does see embracing the gay lifestyle as a choice, not a predetermined state of being, she finds it hard to reject that choice after so many years. To admit to a spiritual reality, a divine intelligence, personal in nature, would make her have to ask too many questions that are just too painful to face. Who knows?

I believe that there is something perceptive in Paglia's work, something spiritual, or at least that she sees the spiritual reality beneath the material surface. She understands the essential connection between religion and culture, appreciating faith, while nonetheless rejecting it. Not to be sappy or condescending about it, but I pray for her. I think that there are religious people who have totally rationalized religion, losing sight of the importance of poetry and art in the understanding and communication of Catholicism. Paglia, an atheist, gets it. She could be a great champion of a Catholic cultural revival, if only she turned back, and believed what she clearly is able to see.

Friday, July 1, 2016

Bishop Barron on College Campus “Safe Spaces”

Brexit and the Failure of Secular Christendom


I was as surprised as anyone by the decision of the UK electorate to leave the European Union. I've long been a "Eurosceptic," for lack of a better term, but was sure that the uncertainty created by leaving the European political and economic community would turn the tide for the remain camp. I'm not skeptical of the EU because I don't like the idea of it, or can't see the benefits of it. I've been a skeptic from the beginning of the long term viability of the EU for the same reason I don't believe in socialism: it's a political, economic and social construct that goes contrary to human nature. 

I'm using "human nature" here in a very broad sense. I'm not suggesting the the EU is an abomination crying to Heaven for vengeance, or somehow runs afoul of the Divine will. What I am saying is that there is a part of us, ingrained, that has a love of country, be that territory large or small, formally constituted and recognized by the UN, or is simply a geographical expression, that is not easily extinguished. Along with a sense of nationhood comes a cultural identity, that involves varied aspects of a people's communal life, from the food we prefer to the form of government we adopt. Any attempt to pave over national loyalties or flatten out cultural differences will never succeed indefinitely, unless you go the Assyria route; that is disperse the vanquished, assimilating them among the nations. So, short of forced inter-ethnic breeding, eventually a people's natural sense of being a part of something larger than themselves as individuals, yet distinct from their global neighbors, will break through.

As I wrote, this is not to say that the European Union is an unreasonable proposition. The main justification for the EU's existence is that it supplies a common transcontinental economic market that benefits all Europeans, and with it the free transport of people and goods over international boarders, which have essentially been erased. This may be true, but what the European Union is really about, on one level, is avoiding World War III, or at least another large scale European land war. The operative theory here being that countries with interdependent economies are less likely to wage war on one another. On another level (and this is where the skepticism come in) I'd argue that it's about France and Germany exercising political and economic hegemony over the continent. I liken it to a reestablishing of the Holy Roman Empire, secular-technocrat style. I think the first reason is understandable considering Europe's history of destructive intra-continental wars over the past five hundred years (the last century in particular). The other is just an elitist power grab under a noble pretext. I'm certainly right about the first motive (the official EU website says as much). You might take issue with me on the EU's second raison d'être - but I'll stand by it. 

All this is predicated on the idea that the diverse ethnic and national groups of Europe will be able to find common cause with each other. But what do people in Ireland and Poland have in common? They once shared a common religion, Catholicism, which is still relatively strong in Poland but has been all but abandoned by the Irish. Otherwise they are different ethnically, culturally and linguistically.  The same can be said of Portugal and Greece or Finland and Cyprus, and any number of other random pairings of European nations. Europe possesses a great diversity of cultures and language groups with very little in common other than an accident of geography - yet they are expected to join together in, not just an economic partnership, but a political union as well. 

This is a difficult proposition. The (unholy) Romans were able to keep a far flung, multicultural, polyglot empire together for quite a long time by force of arms (the Pax Romana wasn't always so peaceful). They also had the wisdom to allow the conquered to maintain as much of their national autonomy as possible (as long as they paid their taxes to the Caesar of course and, with the notable exception of the Jews, offered his image a sacrifice of incense once in a while). They also built roads and water systems that benefited the entire Mediterranean Basin and beyond. The EU isn't content to collect taxes and build aqueducts, but looks to form a superstate which passes and enforces rules and regulations, binding on all the peoples of Europe no matter their culture or local traditions. They don't enforce their rule by military might (as of now), but by economic sanction and PC shamming. 

To reiterate, there are good reasons for the EU. Since we are so far removed from World War II it's lost on many of us just how destructive that conflict and World War I were to European society. We may not be aware, as well, of the fact that there were four major wars in Europe between 1853 and 1945 that cost hundreds of millions of lives. Add to that the continent has a long history of wars of religion, wars of conquest, civil wars, dynastic wars and, revolutions. The desire to join together in common economic and political cause so as to avoid future calamity makes sense.

There is one problem. It is a myth to think that people will be and stay united for purely economic motives. This is one of the great contemporary heresies that has taken root; the primacy of the economic in human affairs. Economics is important, but eventually all economics, like all politics, is local. People in Germany don't want to continually bail out Greece and Greece will tire of having to accept debt relief conditions from Brussels, no matter how just they may be in the eyes of the other member states. I've read that some EU officials envision a federal system similar to the United States that would make regulatory enforcement possible, but the US and EU are different realities. In spite of the call for states rights from time to time in the US, Wisconsin really doesn't see itself as a different nation from Arizona. Even a possible Texit, the often rumored secession of Texas from the Union, is unlikely - though not completely unimaginable. This is because we have a common history, a common language, a diverse but still mostly common culture. The US doesn't stay together because its economically expedient. We stay together because of a common history forged through common struggle. Europe has the struggle, but none of the cohesion. 

There is an irony in all this. Some of the regional independence movements, like in Catalonia and Scotland, want to break from Spain and the UK, respectively, while staying in the EU. They are too weak not to be vassals of somebody, but think it's better to be under a distant, faceless lord than the one locally they know too well and never liked much anyway. It's to the EU's advantage for the nation states to break down into their regions, gaining independence of a sort, while remaining linked to the union because of their inability to be truly independent, autonomous states. The whole menagerie of nation-less ethic enclaves then become easier for a centralized federal European government to control.

But how long will their fealty last before these small groups feel somehow neglected and discriminated against by the powers that be? How long before nationalist movements arise - not calling for the same borders as before, necessarily - to assert their local autonomy against the entrenched, centralized bureaucracy? 

The great over reach of the EU is that they are not content with an economic alliance, but are seeking to build an empire. Unlike Napoleon or Hitler, they're doing it without firing a shot, and I give these imperial architects the benefit of humanitarian good will. But like both men, the masters of the EU, even if they differ from those despots in their intentions and methods, will find it difficult to hold their conquests together. With no common cultural thread to bind them, the economic one will prove insufficient over the not so long term.

Europe had a binding force at one time - Christianity. When Christendom was in bloom Europe was far from idyllic (there was the Hundred Years War, among other conflicts). But there was also great movements people, commerce and ideas across a continent united by a common faith with a common language, Latin. Religion and culture go hand in hand, shaping and influencing each other (I've heard it argued that there is no lasting culture without religion). Religion, the Christian religion, proved to be the binding cultural force that helped a united Europe, in spite of it's ethnic, linguistic and cultural diversity, to resist invasions from the East on several occasions. It was Catholic thinkers like Augustine and Aquinas who brought Platonic and Aristotelian reasoning into the Western mainstream. Contrary to what many atheists and agnostics would like you to believe, it was Christian Europe that developed the university system and scientific method, and many priests have been at the forefront of scientific research. 

Without Christianity, and the Catholic Church, Europe as it is today wouldn't exist, yet contemporary Europe has rejected it's Christian roots. It began jettisoning Christianity intellectually with the Enlightenment and legally with the French Revolution. The wars Europe has suffered since then, each one more destructive than the one before it, had nothing to do with religion, but were fueled by secular humanist ideologies with the goals of political and economic domination. It now is relying on economic interests, guided by secular humanist principles, to fill the role religion once had - with the same goals in mind. It reminds me of a popular definition insanity: doing the same thing over and over again expecting a different result. 

I hope Europe can avoid war in the future, and I don't believe that another large scale continental conflict is inevitable, but Europe will never find lasting peace and unity apart from its Christian identity. I certainly don't believe that they will be able to resist the clear and present danger presented by radical Islamists without the spiritual roots Christianity provided them in the past. 

The EU has imperial goals, lets not fool ourselves, but they don't have the intestinal fortitude to accomplish it - because they really don't believe in anything. They don't believe in their own heritage, anyway, or in the values that brought them this far. They have sown in the flesh since 1789, abandoning their vital spiritual roots, and are, and have been, reaping corruption, but seem to be in denial about it. They are so invested in a Christendom without Christ that many of the intellectual and political class are too blind to stop, look and reexamine their secular methods which have failed them over and over again. 

In the wake of the Brexit, my guess is that the EU, feeling wounded, will double down on trying to solidify their transcontinental experiment. I didn't think that it had a future in the early '90's, and I see nothing now to dissuade me from that opinion. The EU has no future because it has no spiritual roots. It had one cultural dynamic that could have given it a chance at uniting the continent's diverse groups - the Christian faith, and it rejected it. The only hope Europe has at gaining economic stability and political security is to rediscover their Christian roots, while allowing a decentralized governing structure that recognizes local differences in culture. 

Keep Moving Forward (7/1/16) from AOP

Thursday, June 30, 2016

St. John Bosco Parish Bulletin Letter for July 3, 2016



This is the parish bulletin letter to run this Sunday, the day before Independence Day.

Tomorrow is Independence Day here in the United States. In celebrating the 4th of July we remember the day in 1776 when the members of the Continental Congress voted to declare the 13 Colonies of Great Britain to be free and independent states, forming a new, sovereign nation. The Declaration of Independence, which they signed, proposed that the government's role was to ensure the citizens the rights to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. These have been our nation’s guiding principles for the last 240 years. 

Patriotism is a virtue which celebrates the positive aspects of a nation's spirit. A country is bigger than its government, like as human beings we are not just a physical body, but we have a soul as well. These three principles, life liberty and the pursuit of happiness are like the soul that animates national body, giving it purpose and direction. We might be able to mention other ideals that are a part of our national spirit, but these are the three most fundamental aspects.

While there isn’t necessarily a conflict between being a Disciple of Christ and holding to the these patriotic ideals, there can be if we don’t understand what life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness should mean in light of the Gospel.

The right to life means respecting the dignity of human life from conception to natural death. It means caring for the sick and suffering, the immigrant and the disadvantaged. It’s treating everyone with dignity. Do we live that ideal right now as a nation?

Liberty allows us to perfect our God given gifts and abilities. Liberty is not just doing what we want to do, but being free to do what we should do in light of God’s call. Liberty makes us free for doing good - it’s not simply freedom from responsibility. As a culture, do we see liberty as first and foremost a call to responsibility and a charge to use our talents for fostering the common good?

The pursuit of happiness, which is related to liberty, is usually seen as the individual’s right to pursue material prosperity. But God calls us to blessedness. We are blessed when we know God as a friend, live His commandments, and faithfully fulfill the responsibilities of everyday life. Happiness is a passing thing. Happiness can be taken away, or we can feel unhappy if we don’t get what we want. But being blessed is a spiritual reality not tied to our material condition. St. Francis of Assisi had no material possessions beyond the cloths on his back, yet he was exceedingly blessed by God. While we should have the right to pursue material wealth for ourselves and our family, we should know that this kind of happiness is very limited and passing. God calls us to something greater – He is calling us to seek His blessing.


As we celebrate Independence Day, let us also meditate on what our national values are, and how we as Disciples can better perfect them in the light of the Gospel. 

Thursday, June 23, 2016

A Personal Relationship with God - Yes, it's Possible, and Essential for Catholics

In preparation for my upcoming World Youth Day pilgrimage, I took my iPad on vacation and tried pounding out a post of two. My hope is to stay blogging while on the road, chronicling our journey, if the places we're going to have wifi connection. This dry run had mixed results. The actual typing on the screen went well, but editing and re-writes proved to be more difficult tasks. I'm the king of typos, and this is riddled with them. Now that I'm home I went back over it on my laptop, so hopefully it's a bit more polished.

PLYMOUTH, MA - I brought some homework with me, as I lounge around my brother's house, taking in the unobstructed view of Plymouth Harbor. There don't seem to be as many pleasure or sporting boats out there this year. I'm guessing it has to do with some work that's being done on the docks. There are big cranes on the pier and just off in the shallows. There's also a big construction project, on dry land, just down the street. The 1820 Court House is being renovated and a large extension is being built that will facilitate its transition into the new Town Hall. 

2020 marks the 400th anniversary of the pilgrims' landing, and preparations are heating up, with the recent work serving as a sign. My brother, one of the selectmen in town, is on the anniversary planning committee, and there are a lot of moving parts. Elizabeth R, aka Her Majesty the Queen, has been invited for the official celebration in four years. She'll be 94 (there's longevity in her line so I wouldn't bet against her still being among the living in four years), so we'll have to see if she's even accepts, let alone is up for the travel. Bet your boots I'll be angling for the opening benediction if she shows up. I hear that, while Supreme head of the Church of England, she has a soft spot for us papists.

As for my homework, I've been reading through Sherry Weddell's Forming Intentional Disciples. I watched a couple of talks she gave at Mundelien on You Tube in preparation for reading the book, and am now going through a quick reading in these days. There's a lot of hype in Church circles right now about Weddell's evangelization approach. Many dioceses are adapting her principles as a template for their pastoral planning and evangelization programs, and she is an in demand speaker.

I have a grave, philistine doubt when it comes to people who seem to burst on the scene and become the theological or pastoral flavor of the month (Weddell has actually been around for a while, but has become better known in the last four or five years). For the last several decades Catholics have been trying to find the magic formula for keeping cradle Catholics from leaving and new converts coming in. It would be easy to assume that Weddell's methods are just the latest thing that will be hot today, and forgotten tomorrow.

The difference for me personally is that listening to her speak, and now reading her book, is like a kick to the gut. 

Weddell challenges many assumptions that we have about why so many Catholics stay lukewarm, leave the Church or, if they aren't Catholic, don't feel moved to enter. We tend to assume that defectors weren't well catechized, or had some deep disagreement with Church teaching, or were divorced and remarried, and so went to an ecclesial community they felt was more accepting of their situation. Anecdotally, I certainly know people who fit into one of these dynamics. What Weddell found in her research was that, while some may leave for these reasons, for the most part people leave the Church and go to a Protestant community because they don't feel that the Catholic Church offered them a personal relationship with God. Those who leave for no religion don't believe in a personal God or, if they do, that a relationship with God isn't possible. She's found that there are many people still in the Church, including clergy and lay leaders who don't know that such a relationship is possible. In her travels, visiting dioceses across the fruited plain, Weddell has encountered more than a few Catholics, by her reckoning, who don't even believe in a personal God (YIKES!).

In one of her talks Weddell describes an interview with a lay director of a major Catholic non-profit, who had no idea what she was talking about when asking the person about their personal relationship with God. After trying to approach the question from several different angles she concluded that this person, a leader in the Catholic Church, really didn't believe in a personal God, or else really didn't see the question of a relationship with Him as being terribly important. The sad truth was that the person in question could have been heading up any secular non-profit organization. He or she may have been bright, professional and otherwise qualified - but wasn't a Disciple. Unfortunately, while I've met a great many very dedicated lay leaders, people of true faith, I've also met a few Church workers, hard working and competent as they may have been, who fit that description. 

I can attest as well, that I have met or heard of people who left either the Catholic Church, one of the Orthodox churches, or mainline Protestantism, who spoke of never having had a personal relationship with God before now, and now feel at home in their new faith community. They'll say that they weren't Christian before, though having been brought up in what I know are Christian faiths. Again, a philistine doubt and cradle Catholic skepticism led me to think that there had to be some other, above mentioned, reason for their separating from the Church, especially focusing on the idea that they weren't well catechized (let's face it, if you grew up from the '70's on you probably didn't receive a very sold catechetical formation, K through12th grade).

But what Weddell writing is a wake up call. The reasons why people leave are deeper than simply not having received good catechesis. It's about not having received an integrated formation that accompanied them through the stages of growth from seeking God to living as a disciple. These stages are not separate, in many ways, but are interconnected and ongoing through life. It is a constant process of conversion that deepens our commitment to a dynamic discipleship in Christ.

Because I'm still reading the book I'm not going into details, but want to really focus in on one big point that she makes - that a personal relationship with the living God is not only possible, but essential to true discipleship. Weddell writes that Catholics are just not accustomed to speaking of their religious experience. But this has to change if we are going to really begin to retain, gain and form intentional Catholic disciples.

Catholics tend to focus on the objective truth of the Faith. Non Catholics, Protestants in particular, who enter the Church often come to "Rome" after they discover the Church Fathers, and investigate Church history. As famed Anglican convert, Blessed John Henry Newman, once said, "to be deep in history is to cease being Protestant." There are emotional conversions to Rome, but the pull of conversion often comes after someone falls in love with Christ, comes to sense that there is something more than what evangelicalism or the broader Protestant faith offers, they discover the historical roots of Christianity, a path that leads to the Catholic Church. 

Evangelicals tend to focus on the subjective experience of accepting Christ as personal Lord and Savior. We can give all the historical and theological reasons why Catholicism is the true Church Christ founded, but many of us don't have the ability to touch hearts by articulating why we believe on a personal, gut level. We are living in an age where heart supersedes the brain, feeling trumps reason. Somehow we need to better express the subjective experience we have living out the Catholic Faith, not just the objective reality underneath it.

For instance, we have the Sacraments, specifically the Eucharist, which I celebrate everyday. For me it is a very personal encounter with the risen Lord, a union with Him and sharing in His once for all sacrifice made mysteriously present through the power of the Holy Spirit. Evangelicals and other Protestants don't see it that way. They see it, at best as a simple memorial of the Last Supper, at worst as an empty ritual bordering on magic. 

I pray the rosary everyday, meditating on the various mysteries, the vast majority of which are drawn directly from Scripture. Through this ancient prayer I ponder the key events of Jesus' life as if I were there, looking through the eyes of the Blessed Mother, asking the Lord to help me grow in the virtues the mysteries represent, as well as praying for the my needs and those of my loved ones. They see vain repetition. 

In my devotional life I maintain an active friendship with the Saints. In them I am surrounded by a great cloud of witnesses who went before me, encouraging me to perceiver in faith to the end as they did (Hebrews 12:1). They are the sign that Jesus is the resurrection and the life, God of the living, not the dead (Matt. 22:23-33). They are the ones described in the Book of Revelation offering the prayers of the "holy ones" that rise up to the Heavenly Thrown like incense (5:8). Evangelicals and nondenominational Christians see all sorts of things, from idolatry to necromancy.

For me, the key is to not to get so caught up on objections that are thrown at us, but to instead focus on why we believe.

I have always been baffled by people who tell me that being a Catholic somehow means that I haven't accepted Christ as my personal Lord and Savior. I generally don't know how to answer the objection because the assertion seems so stupid it's beyond taking seriously. Sorry to be so blunt about it. But the people making the accusation aren't stupid, and many are former Catholics who made it through religious education or even Catholic school never having had that personal encounter with the living Lord. The problem isn't them, and it isn't the Catholic faith. The problem is us (by us I mean pastors, bishops, religious educators, et al). We have not done a good enough job sharing the treasure we hold in our hearts. We've taken for granted that the objective truth and power of the Sacraments will do all the work for us. We haven't appreciated that subjective dispositions are needed for the grace we receive in them to fully flower and bear fruit. We need to be more open about sharing who Jesus Christ is to us, and how he has changed our lives.

I leave you with disturbing questions that we all need to ask ourselves (or they should be disturbing if we call ourselves disciples) Who is Jesus? Do I have a personal relationship with him? And related to that, has He changed my life?

Wednesday, June 22, 2016

Fr. Robert Barron on St. Thomas More & the Bishop of Rome


It's hard to believe it's been six years since Pope Benedict XVI visited England and spoke in Westminster Hall, the place of St. Thomas More's condemnation. The reflection of then Fr. Barron on this historic event is just as valid today as it was then.

St. Thomas More from Catholic News Agency

Tuesday, June 21, 2016

Out of Town

PLYMOUTH, MA - I'm taking a few days away to visit the folks. I might clean up and finish off a post I was working on before I left, but otherwise I'm closed for business until Friday night. I have scheduled some postings from the Apostleship of Prayer and Bishop Robert Barron, like the one about the Saint of the day, Aloysius Gonzaga. Until then, you are in my prayers.

St. Aloysius Gonzaga From the Apostleship of Prayer

Saturday, June 18, 2016

Walls and Bridges - Very Scattered Thoughts on Illegal Immigration


I stood convicted yesterday morning during meditation. It wasn't a harsh rebuke, but I became very aware of a great sin of omission that I am clearly guilty of. I've published close to 800 posts in the last six years - most are original along with a healthy number of posts from other sources, and haven't written a word explicitly about immigration reform. For most of my priestly life I have worked with immigrants, ministering to them, advocating for them on a grass roots level. But I have remained silent here, and that needs to change.

Part of my reticence has been rooted in an innate fear of being controversial. The other is my aversion to speaking about politics in public. The first is pure cowardice on my part, a resistance to suffer for the Gospel. The other has more justification, especially as I understand the life of Don Bosco, who had to navigate the founding of the Salesian Congregation through rough political waters, while also maintaining the unity of his men. Don Bosco was a fierce advocate for young people, and did speak boldly, but he never adopted a party platform along the way. He said things that had clear political implications, without getting political. Of course my error, my spiritual blindness, my sin, is not seeing the issue of immigration as one of faith first, politics second. It is possible to speak the truth as I've experienced it, which does have political implications, but like Don Bosco doing so without endorsing one party or the other. 

To make it plain, I don't believe that 11 million people enter another country by accident (how we know it's 11 million people, since they're undocumented, I'll never know - how do we know it isn't 5.5 million, or 22 million? Sorry for the digression). A nation doesn't surrender it's sovereign right to a border for no reason. Also, the issue has been at the forefront of the national consciousness for at least 20 years, yet no concrete reforms are ever enacted, no matter who's in the congressional majority or in the White House. Why is this? Again, I don't believe that any of this is an accident. Which leads me to a fundamental question. If the situation was allowed to happen, even if there isn't any grand conspiracy (which I'm not suggesting there is), who benefits? 

I see interests, both political and economic that benefit. The politicians have an issue ready at hand to keep their base engaged and, presumably, their membership boosted by the immigrant population who do manage get citizenship, and their children born here, so are citizens already, who are counted on to join, or at least vote for them. The immigrant population feels they have an advocate who fights for them, even though very little changes over time. Since in today's political climate, no matter what community your talking about, perception is more important than reality, it's not an unwise strategy. 

The other are the business interests, who find ways to get around the law to hire undocumented aliens. They don't have to pay minimum wage, deal with unions, follow an 8 hour day, and can hire and fire at will, with no ramifications. I'm sure those who live in farming areas could go into details on how large industrial farm corporations benefit from the current situation. Neither party is really interested in solving the problem, but both are eager to exploit it for votes, and business interests for profits.

You may take issue with my analysis, and that's fine. Whatever the causes of the problem, I deal with the victims of it everyday. The vast majority of our parishioners here were born outside the US, mostly in Mexico. Many have legal status, many do not. I won't hazard to guess percentages. Part of this has to do with the variety of situations I've run into over the years (as I'll detail below). Some of those who are undocumented have managed to make a decent life here in spite of "being in the shadows," and I'm surprised sometimes when I'm approached for help with their immigration work. It's not uncommon for someone who is knocking on the door of being middle class, or has already crossed the threshold, to end up not having legal status and needing assistance. 

Many struggle though. They work construction, which is hit or miss - especially here in Chicago where the winters can be harsh. Others are dish washers and bus boys, which, again can be erratic. Many have factory work which can be six or seven days a week at upwards of 12 hour shifts. The pay is little and the job security is the same.

As for family life, both mother and father work, for the most part. Many families are strong, but cracks are forming. I see more and more single mothers, or "blended families" which seems so morally indifferent when it happens in the middle class or above, but is not so quaint where I live. Again, it works when the parents are married, supplying a stable home life with love and affection for all the children, regardless of the paternity or maternity.

But in other situations the families have been "blended" two or three times over. Partners change often, and it's usually the father figure who's changing in and out of the children's lives, and the situation can be disastrous. The children know that the man living here now isn't their father, and doesn't love them like a father. One day he will most likely leave, and they'll have to deal with another padrastro - or stepfather. The best case scenario, the man leaves and the children only suffer deeper abandonment issues, never develop respect for male authority. In the worse cases there is abuse, both physical and sexual before the man decides to leave or gets reported. 

These issues are not confined to the undocumented population, but they are exacerbated because there is a fear of going to authorities for help. There is no extended family, quite often, to reach out to. They feel alone and desperate. Theses homes can also be breeding grounds for gang members. The gang, perversely, becomes the family they never had as children. 

Again, I have to stress that for the most part our people work hard to live the right way. But this shouldn't blind us to the real problems that are, at the very least, made worse for adults and children by the parent's legal status in the country. 

From the stand point of the faith, a great obstacle for many in trying to live holy, Christian lives, is the long hours and 6 to 7 day weeks that too many parents have to maintain just to survive. They can't fulfill their Sunday obligation, or it is very difficult to. They have the responsibility to get to Mass on Sunday, but the employer has a responsibility to allow their workers this very fundamental right. So many of the children of these workers don't receive the Sacraments, don't receive even a basic catechesis. They are denied grace and knowledge which are so important in our human, as well as spiritual development. God freed His people from slavery in Egypt first and foremost so they could go into the desert and adore Him in the manner He saw fit. There were also economic and political reasons, but these came after. God wants to be united with his people. It is their right,as well as duty, and His due. That so many are undocumented, and so unable to really exercise their rights - religious, civil and economic is a great sin against God, and the First and Third Commandments.

What I haven't gotten into, and will in a deeper way at another time, is that for every family, there is a different story. Mom is documented, but dad isn't - or the other way around. The Parents are undocumented, but the children are citizens by birth. Some of the children are citizens some aren't. A child brought here by his or her parents at two or three years old, has no memories of Mexico, grew up here, was educated here, speaks English fluently, but Spanish not as well, could be deported. These people are more American than Mexican in many ways, yet they have no rights, and struggle to become documented. So those who want mass deportations need to think long and hard about what that really means in terms of breaking up families.  

I know that this examination is scatter shot, and not very well planned out. But it is a beginning. I do plan on writing more on this, because I'm in the position to. If I can sum up what I'm trying to say, it's that those who are here in this country illegally are victims of larger forces, both here in the US, and in their home countries (which I haven't written about) who benefit from the situation. The immigrant is here because there aren't any opportunities in their native lands, or at least don't see any. They crossed the border, sometimes after a harrowing journey through the desert, at the mercy of bandits, smugglers and the cartels. They were permitted to come in and stay, even if only passively. They are not saints - they're human beings. Which means that there are good and bad among them. I've seen mainly good, though I've also caught more than a glimpse of the bad. Their situations are diverse, and defy simple solutions like building walls or throwing them on buses. 

As a priest of Jesus Christ my first responsibility is to care for the spiritual and material needs of my flock. Before all else, be they documented or undocumented, they are baptized members of the Body of Christ, which transcends political or national identities. Even if they aren't Catholic, those who come to my door are human beings, and I'm not going to ask for a birth certificate before offering help. For me, this isn't primarily a political issue, but a moral one, and a very personal one. 

Tuesday, June 14, 2016

Thank You, Anonymous


I received a short, sweet, and much appreciated card in this morning's mail sent in an envelope sporting an Edison, New Jersey return address and a Seattle, Washington post mark. He or she wished me well over the summer and thanked me for the blog posts. The card was unsigned. To whoever you are out there - thank you for the encouragement. I needed it.

I almost gave up on the blog earlier in the year, but in May, after some prayer, decided to rededicate myself to it. The readership is small, and I wasn't sure if it was worth continuing. I'll take this random act of kindness as a sign that I made the right decision.

So, Anonymous, whoever you are, thank you again. I'll be pray for you and yours. I'll be praying for all of you out there, especially when I'm in Spain, France and then Poland for World Youth Day in July.

Christ: The True Organizing Principle

It's a scene becoming far too common. One time it's Paris, the next it's Jakarta, then San Bernadino or London or Madrid or, now, Orlando. Attacks by individuals or small bands of Islamist terrorists are too quickly becoming the "new normal" of the early 21st Century West. The secular media is full of talking heads bellowing at each other, saying the usual things about homophobia (in light of that the latest atrocity happened at a gay nightclub), gun control and Islamist terrorism, not always in that particular order.

I went around to different sites looking for the "Catholic" response - to get a feel for how people of faith have been approaching the issue. It wasn't a very exhaustive search, and I really didn't read any one post too closely. This cursory run through of what's out there gave me the sense that the focus tended to be placed either on, you guessed it, homophobia, gun control or Islamist terrorism, in that order, with a slightly larger emphasis on the first category over the second. People were either showing solidarity with the gay community, or else praying for the victims while pointing out that it was a gay club attacked (think, den of iniquity) so that those people really need our prayers. Then there was one criticizing those who pray for the victims while at the same time implying that a gay club is intrinsically more hazardous to one's moral health than other places would be.

What I found disappointing is that, for the most part, the Catholic blogosphere mirrored the secular press in many ways. The discussion still came down to political solutions and politically correct platitudes. By focusing on sexual politics, secular politics or terrorism (even though I believe that this angle gets closest to the heart of the immediate issue), we are missing the bigger reality. Things are falling apart — the center isn't holding. We are politically, socially and economically divided at home, and Europe, depending on how the Brexit vote goes next week, is on the verge of disintegration. Even if Britain votes to stay in the EU this time, the demise of the European Union will have only been delayed, not entirely prevented. Some thing new is happening, can't you perceive it? The old structures, both institutional and intellectual are no longer trusted. This comes decades after the religious underpinnings of society were undone. But the secular city was supposed to supply meaning and societal cohesion independent of faith? The purely secular society has failed, but even we in the Church seem slow to want to accept this reality. 

Sometimes I get the feeling that even believers have reduced God to something like the celestial clock maker, only a bit more involved after the mechanism has been set in motion. He made us with great care, and does continue to look after us, winding us, polishing us when necessary, but God is otherwise indifferent to our life choices, especially those concerning sexual morality. We can get trapped between two extremes, one is thinking that God is wrathful; constantly looking for an excuse to punish us. The other is to deny that God ever chastises His wayward children at all (the more common temptation right now). God does chastise, but woe to the one who assumes to know what should be punished or assigns themselves as the chosen instrument of divine retribution (therefore, count me out of the "Orlando Shooting was God's Punishment" camp, if one exists). 

No, God isn't a clock maker - He's a Father who tries to keep us in balance. He cares for us, tries to teach up, and gives us a swift kick when necessary. At the same time, if things are falling apart, it's not God's punishment necessarily. I remember good Sr. Rose Assumpta, my 8th grade CCD teacher. She had a background in biology. She explained that nature is set up in a particular way that if it's misused it will rebel. If we eat too much and of the wrong kinds of foods, we shouldn't be surprised that diabetes and heart disease may occur. If we dump waste where it doesn't belong, we shouldn't be shocked that poisoned water will lead to widespread illness. And yes, in as much as we don't want to hear it, if we misuse the gift of sexuality, physical ailments, as well as spiritual and emotional unhappiness, will follow. Is this God's wrath? No - it's natures way. As a good Father, God wants us to avoid these things - live in a balanced way, with Christ at the center, as our organizing principle. With Jesus and His Gospel at the center all the other aspects of our life will begin to fall in place, in proper proportion to the whole.

But what happens when, as a culture, we have made something else our organizing principle? What happens when we make the economic, the political or, increasingly, the sexual, the defining and organizing principle of our lives? 

We become centered on ourselves, either on our particular cadre, or worse yet on our personal selves. We care less and less about the common good and become obsessed with our rights, be they real or perceived. We are so obsessed with our personal identity that we fail to see the suffering of others, or the threats that surround us. We are no longer a part of a larger reality that transcends socio-polital categories, be they legitimate or contrived. To address the threats from without would mean having to move beyond ourselves and our perceptions, joining with others in common cause, and common sacrifice. Rather than joining together, we point fingers at the other identity groups we see as competing with us for preference. But when we face an enemy united such fractiousness can not stand. The society will collapse, not because of God's wrath, but because this is the nature of how societies fall. 

Obviously I believe that the only lasting solution to the present crisis is making Christ the organizing principle of our lives. Christ moves us beyond all the limited identities we are either born into or create for ourselves. Christ enriches those qualifiers that are worthy, dissolves those that are superfluous. Christ calls us to seek eternity while striving for peace and justice now. Only a society organized around the Gospel, who's political, social and cultural values are informed by discipleship in Jesus will be able to stand united in the face of a force bent on destroying us. 

I do not want to leave the topic of God's chastisement totally undeveloped. But before I get into that, I suggest you read Luke 13:1-5. (Yes, you have homework!)