Sunday, September 1, 2013

One of the Proud 77%

Of the many things I began to write about over the last several months but never finished was something on a poll Rasmussen released around Easter Week reporting that 86 percent of respondents believe Jesus was an actual historical figure, with 77% believing he resurrected. One of the big claims that the new atheists try to push is the idea that Jesus never really lived; he was a myth created by the early Church, and possibly by St. Paul.  The numbers seem to indicate that they are not making great inroads, if we take into account that the non Christian population in the US is growing, a group that would be disinclined to believe in the Resurrection to begin with.

But what of this idea that Jesus never existed?  It is true that he never wrote anything that we know about, outside of those mysterious scribblings he made on the ground with his finger when he confronted those who accused the woman caught in adultery.  The very claim that he rose from the dead discounts skeletal remains.  There is no birth certificate or obituary we can look at, even if such things existed back in the first century.  We don't seem to have any contemporary accounts of Jesus' life, outside of the Jewish historian Flavious Josephus.  But the brief passages referring to Jesus are suspected of being a later incursion into to text, and are so unreliable (though there does seem to be scholars who take varying positions on the topic).

When it comes to the historical reality of Jesus we have are two things we can hang our hat on, as I see it.

One is that we do have the New Testament cannon that is unjustly discounted because of their standing as Sacred Scripture.  Yes, they tell stories of the miraculous, and so what?  Even if you don't believe Jesus was a worker of wonders, all it proves is that his followers liked to guild the rose a bit (a position I do not take, of course).  The Evangelists, especially Luke goes to great lengths to place Jesus' life in an historical context, unlike the ancient myths, and in John there is constant harping about how all that was described was being communicated by a witness to the events; a witness whose testimony is true.  The Evangelists name the names of people who were at the cross or on the road to Emmaus, as if to say, "if you don't believe me, go ask them. They're still alive (at the time of this writing), they can set you straight."

Beyond the four canonical Gospels, we have the letters of Paul, as well as the others.  They were written before the Gospel accounts and attest to Jesus' death and resurrection.  Along with "Jesus Birthers" there are those who question Jesus' divinity, or his self understanding of his divine nature.  They will go as far as to claim that the Evangelists made it up, or that the Gospels really don't say that he's God.  Well, if the Gospels don't convince you, then go to the letters, written twenty to thirty years before the Gospels.  Here we see a firm profession of the divinity of Jesus and the bodily resurrection.  These were what the early Christians believed going back to the first generation, attested to by witnesses (Peter) and by those who consulted with those who knew the Lord during his earthy ministry (Paul).

The second point is that so many, including ten of the surviving 12 Apostles died as martyrs.  Judas committed suicide and John died as an old man, but endured exiles and torture for the faith.  Unlike our own time and place, in the Mediterranean of the first century everybody was religious, and it was a very public thing.  Most people were polytheistic.  One of the popular God's was Sol Invictus - the Unconquered  Sun, and while he was very popular, as Pope Francis writes in his first Encyclical, quoting Justin Martyr, no one was know to be willing to die for his belief in the sun god.  Yet thousands gave their lives for their belief in the Son of God, Jesus Christ.  It's possible for a few fanatics to give their lives for a myth maybe, but only if they were also insane; but thousands over centuries starting right from the beginning?  I doubt it.  Someone would have cracked.  Sure, some ran away to save their hides, but none said it was a scam.


And so yes, I believe in Jesus the historical person and Resurrected Savior.  I believe because it's reasonable to me, as well as being a matter of faith.  In the end, I wouldn't put my faith in something that didn't make sense. 

Thursday, August 29, 2013

The Passion of Saint John the Baptist

File:Michelangelo-Caravaggio 021 Beheading-of-St-John-the-Baptist cropped.jpg



Back in June we celebrated the nativity of St. John the Baptist, the only birth we observe on the liturgical calendar, other than those of Jesus and Mary.  John is the last of the Old Testament prophets, and his life is intimately intertwined with our Lord's from the time of their respective conceptions.  John's, in Old Testament style, was miraculous in so far as God guided nature, taking one who was thought to be baron (St. Elizabeth) and allowing her to be her fertile, causing surprise and wonder in the people.  With Jesus, he shows that he is the master of nature, intervening in human affairs in such a way as to totally surpass people's expectations.   

In his death we see that John was a true prophet, suffering and dying for the Word he professed.  It is no accident that the first reading from today's Mass is from the book of Jeremiah.  This past Sunday we heard that he was thrown down a well by the officials of Jerusalem because he was preaching against war and foreign alliances that would lead to doom.  Tradition tells us that he left the city as it was falling to the enemy, only to be murdered in Egypt.  He accepted the call to preach as we heard today, but professing the Word of God came at a great personal cost.

John also was fearless in his preaching of the Word.  He preached justice, equity and personal repentance.  His words were strong, calling those who came out to him a "brood of vipers" who needed to repent and so avoid the great wrath that was to come.  It was not for these things that he was beheaded though.  John told Herod, the puppet ruler of Galilee, that it was not lawful for him to have Herodias, his sister-in-law, as his wife while his brother was still alive.  John was defending the sanctity of marriage, and touching upon something so personal to Herod's way of life that it excited his ire.  He had John arrested, and Herodias manipulated a situation to effect his execution.

Today the Church is called to be prophetic.  She is vocal on issues of economic justice, racial equality, immigration reform and other social issues as seen through the lens of the Gospel.  When we do we are sometimes criticized, sometimes lauded and mainly, it seems to me, ignored.  But when we get up and say that marriage is a union of one man and one woman, for the good of the couple and the raising of a family we are accused of every vile epitaph imaginable.  We are called bigots and homophobes.  The former Archbishop of Buenos Aires was heavily criticized by that country's president for preaching that core doctrine of the faith (for those who don't know who I'm referring to, the archbishop in question is now the much lauded Pope Francis).   When we preach these truths we are touching to core of the human person.  Economics and politics can seem distant to us, especially in this age when the news has been dumbed down to such a large extent.  But our sexuality is tied to our inner self and identity, and so if we are told that maybe we are misusing it we react, sometimes violently, to the messenger.  But preach the truth we must in season and out, no matter the cost.

We do not preach this out of hate, but out of love.  I don't want to see people persecuted or abused because of their sexual orientation.  I believe that what goes on in the privacy of people's homes is none of my business, unless lives are in danger or they want to make it my business by way of the confessional.  I believe who people choose to live with is none of my business, for that matter.  But I can't believe in same sex marriages because it can never be a marriage in the way the Christian community has always understood it.  And just so gays don't think that I'm singling them out, straight couples who purposely exclude the possibility of children from their lives are in relationships that fall short of Christian marriage as well.

I'm not judging if the partners love each other.  I'm not questioning their mutual devotion.  But marriage, at a certain level, transcends these things. It's a commitment made for life that must endure many hardships, including the possibility of falling out of love, and the dimming of the sexual appetite.  It has it's feet planted in the here and now, with eyes fixed on the future, all the way into eternity. 

John the Baptist was put to death for defending the truth of marriage, in his case it's exclusive and indissoluble nature.  We are called to preach the manifold truths of the Gospel, whose implications touch every aspect of our personal, social, cultural and political lives.  We must profess it even when it is hard;  Always with clarity, always with charity.  Ready to accept any consequence that may come. 

Thursday, August 22, 2013

Fr. Jose Carlos Contreras, SDB, Delared Innocent, Freed From Prison!



Fr. Jose Carlos Contreras, SDB has spent four years in prison in Mexico for the rape and murder of 16 year old Itzachel Shantal González López, crimes he did not commit.  Yesterday the Supreme Court of Mexico, in a 4-1 decision, declared Fr. Jose Carlos innocent of all charges. 

The court's decision stated that the priest was convicted without proof that he was the rapist, and called the evidence and accompanying narrative of the overall events presented by prosecutors illogical and beyond the boundaries of common sense.

Today, the feast of the Queenship of Mary, Fr. Jose Carlos will be celebrating a Mass of thanksgiving with his family.

To echo the words of the statement put out by the Salesian Provence of Guadalajara, we have gratitude to God for Father's freedom.  It is hard to imagine the hardships that he endured over these years.  By all accounts he continued to be a priest for the other prisoners of the jail, giving guidance and consolation at a time he himself was suffering so much.  We pray for him as he makes his adjustment back into his regular Salesian life.  We pray for all those unjustly convicted, as well as the victims of the drug violence in Mexico, of which this episode appears to be a part.

Most of all we must remember that there is a young girl who will never grow up to be a woman.  We continue to pray for Itzachel Shantal González López, for her family, and that justice may be done in her case.

Friday, August 16, 2013

A Serious Man // DVD Review



Larry Gopnik is having a bad day.  This quiet, more than slightly nebbish physics professor's ordinary life is disrupted in an afternoon by a student who tries to bribe him in a failed attempt to raise his midterm grade (later the student tries extortion), he gets into a property line dispute with his goy neighbor, and his wife Judith (Sari Lennik) reveals that she's been seeing a close friend on the sly and wants a divorce.   Plus, his tenure request is endangered by a series of anonymous letters besmirching his character that keep on arriving to members of the tenure board, and the Columbia Record Club is hounding him for payment on a subscription that his son secretly took out in his name.  More bad things happen in the following days, including several sudden deaths, but you get the point. In the midst of this Larry, an observant Jew, wonders where Hashem (the Hebrew word used to refer to God in informal conversation) is in all this madness and confusion. Does life have meaning, or is everything that happens to us the product of random chance?  The rabbis he consults don't seem to know the answer, and one even tells him that Hashem owes him no answer, even though he plants the curiosity within us from the start.  As Larry frustratingly muses, if he gives us the question, why won't he give us the answer?

This is the set up for the Coen Brothers 2009 offering A Serious Man. The film is set in an Upper Midwest, mostly Jewish suburb in 1967.  It's based on Joel and Ethan Coen's own childhood neighborhood in Minnesota, and while the late 60's setting is somewhat superfluous, except to make certain gags possible, it does add to the atmosphere.  Though the film asks serious questions about God and fate, taking a critical view on the existance of a providential God and the ability of religion to answer the deeper questions of life's meaning, it's an affectionate, and often funny look at what it was like to grow up Jewish (albeit in the Coen Brother's dark style).

A Serious Man is billed as a modern retelling of the Book of Job, but the only thing the main character, Larry Gopnik (Michael Stuhlbarg), has in common with his Biblical counter part is that bad things start happening to him, seemingly out of nowhere, and he wonders where God is in all the suffering.  The difference is that Job was a serious man of property and wealth who lost it all, and got it all back, and then some, after his time of trial was over.  If we are honest in reading Job we are left with more questions than answers, even if the Divine author wraps everything up neatly at the end.  Here, Gopnik is an every-man who schleps his way through life, contently enough, to find himself suddenly confronted with calamities that thrown him for an existential loop, forcing him to questions the meaning of life and faith.  When things begin to turn around for the better real problems seem to be barreling down just as the film is ending.  We are left with the same questions as Job, only without the pretty bow and with a dose of palpable dread.

This isn't an easy movie to follow, especially since there really isn't a driving, clearly focused plot, and scenes are inserted that don't seem to be serving the story, such as there is.  This doesn't mean that these bits don't work, because they do; especially a bizarre Yiddish language prologue about a suspected ghost that takes place in another century and location.  Then there's the story of the dentist and goy's teeth; very funny but still leaves you scratching your head as to why we took the detour.  But the scenes themselves work, especially the one about the goy's teeth, in so far as they highlight the idea that life itself is a movie without a plot and the more you try to tease one out the more frustrated you will get. 

What I saw as a key to understanding the movie was an encounter at the end of the film between Larry's son Danny (Aaron Wolf) and the aged Rabbi Marshak (Alan Mandell).  It is the boy's Bar Mitzvah day and he goes into the old sages cluttered and slightly spooky office to be congratulated.  Featured prominently amid all sorts of strange scientific specimens in jars and random bric a brac is a copy of Caravaggio's Sacrifice of Issac, depicting another biblical story that makes one question what God's up to.  As he sits nervously, the grizzled and wizened wise man begins to slowly paraphrase the opening lines to a Jefferson Airplane song popular at the time:

     "When the truth is found to be lies,
     And all the hope within you dies,
     then what?"

This is the key question of the movie, even if Larry hasn't come to see the answers offered by faith to be lies yet.  The Rabbi Nachtner (perfectly played by George Wyner), who Larry consults after an unsatisfying sit down with the "junior" rabbi, can only tell him how God doesn't work as opposed to how he actually does (a later funeral scene shows that he doesn't have a grip on what the afterlife is about either).  He dismisses questions of ultimate meaning as annoying tooth aches that will go away with time.  For his part, Marshak, like the other rabbis, offers no answers, just the grandfatherly admonition to "be a good boy," as he returns the boy's transistor radio that had been confiscated by the Hebrew teacher at the beginning of the movie.  But where does one go when the basic assumptions that guide our life don't seem to be valid anymore?

In the end A Serious Man leaves us with questions, and no answers.  When what we were raised to believe doesn't seem to match up with the realities of life, what do we do?  Do we give in to hopelessness?  Obviously the Christian answer is no; life has a purpose and their is a plan even if we can't figure it out in our own time.  But I don't want to dismiss the questions, because, while God gives us more to work with than Rabbi Nachtner gives him credit for, he does leave plenty of room for mystery, wonder and questioning.  There isn't a person who hasn't had to grapple with these questions at one time or another, including great saints of strong faith.  The Coen Brothers make us grapple with them with humor, irony but also with a clear sense of appreciation for the religious and cultural tradition they were raised in, even if they are unsure how they view its deeper implications.

Sunday, August 11, 2013

Fr. Robert Barron: The Sacrament of the Eucharist as a Sacred Meal

This is a part of what I'm assuming will be a three part installment from Fr. Barron on the Eucharist.  He speaks of it here as a sacred meal, tracing the origins of this concept through the Old Testament and into the ministry of Jesus.  From how he set this video up, I'm guessing he will explore the ideas of the Eucharist as a sacrifice and as True Presence in the future.

One of the struggles of the Post-Vatican II period has been over how the celebration of the Eucharist should be viewed.  In the Pre-Conciliar period the stress was placed on the sacrificial aspect of the Mass.  Over the last fifty years more of an emphasis has been placed on the Mass as a communal meal.  But rather than trying to show the complementary nature of these two qualities of the Mass they have too often placed in opposition, as if these things were mutually exclusive.  Here Fr. Barron is trying to demonstrate that what we have is a case of both-and, not either-or.


Saturday, August 3, 2013

Chicago Bound

PLYMOUTH, MA - I've been and will continue to write a little less frequently over the next couple of weeks, not just because we're in what is the usual vacation-retreat time of year for most priests.  I have been given a new assignment that began on August 1, though I won't be actually moving in until the eighth (I'm squeezing in some time with my family between assignments).  I am no longer the pastor of St. Anthony's in Elizabeth, New Jersey and now hold the same position (in absentia) at St. John Bosco Parish on Chicago's North West Side.  It came as a surprise, especially since I had been green lighted for another term in Jersey, but things happen, as they say, and so I pack up and go in faith.

People are constantly asking how I feel about moving, and in truth I feel very much conflicted about it.  I spent five very happy years at St. John Bosco as parochial vicar before going on to be Coordinator of Youth Ministry (CYM) at Salesian High, New Rochelle.  I would be lying if I said I wasn't excited about going back.  But I was the  pastor at St. Anthony's, and the experience of leaving has not been the same as leaving other places that I've been.  A pastor is more than an administrator, he is called to be the spiritual father of the people in his care.  Don Bosco once said that he would never accept the position because of the grave responsibility that a shepherd of souls has for every person who lives within his parish boundaries. 

Some times we Salesians (and I'm guessing it's the same with most religious) view our assignments as jobs.  We do get attached, and many of us find moving difficult, especially as we get older and more settled in our ways.  But being a pastor is different from the other positions we hold because of its paternal nature.  A director, who is the superior of the religious community, also has this paternal quality.  But he is use to Salesians being transferred in and out, or students or club members graduating or aging out of the program.  A parish community is far more stable and we get to be a part of the lives of the families under our care and share in all the joys and sorrows of their lives.  If we are fulfilling our duties faithfully (or even not as well as we should, as I have observed) the people do become attached to us.  This filial or paternal relationship is real and parting becomes hard for "both sides," even, as in my case, the pastor has fond feelings for the place he's going. 

There is no easy answer.  The dwindling number of priests makes filling positions difficult and movement almost constant.  Staying too long in a place can bring complacency, stagnation and worse; a sense of entitlement and privilege on the part of the priest.  But constant change is unsettling for the people and makes establishing a consistent program, not to mention trusting relationships, almost impossible.

This last point, the importance of relationships, is what I believe the Holy Father is trying to stress to us.  Programs and strategic planning are important, but only if they facilitate a personal encounter with Christ.  Priests and religious, in a special way, are called to be the face, voice and hands of the Lord in the world now.  Do they have this role exclusively in the Church?  No, but they do have it in a unique way, and it's power can be undermined by the constant shifting of personnel.  The people will be respectful, but they will be slow to truly bond with their pastors and the pastor's associates if they have grown accustomed to them not being around for long. 

These are observations, not complaints.  I am looking forward to going back to St. John Bosco.  While leaving St. Anthony's is hard, I understand it and accept it in the spirit of obedience and bowing before the mystery that is God's will.  Pray for me as I begin this next phase as I pray for you all who read The Ax, and for all your loved ones.

Wednesday, July 17, 2013

Quick Reviews: "This is the End", "Man of Steel", "The Lone Ranger" and "Ken Burns: Prohibition"

I've seen a bunch of movies this summer, but have chosen not to review them up to now.  Consider this a catch up on some of the more recent films out right now.
 

This is the End

"R" rated comedies are not usually high on my list of must sees, but I took a chance on this one.  I rarely walk into the theater knowing nothing about the movie being screened, but there wasn't anything else out that week, so I figured I'd take the chance.

Bad move.

The premise and set up were actually intriguing.  The main actors, among Hollywood's Young Turk comedians and thespians, all play themselves, or at least play parodies of their public image.  They're self absorbed, stoner elitists living in their insulated pleasure domed ivory towers.  Seth Rogen and Jay Baruchel go to a party at John Franco's new house, along with a host of other young stars like Emma Watson, Michael Cera and Rhianna, all engaging in the excesses associated with show business types on their time off, when, you guessed it, the Rapture/Apocalypse happens.  Actually, so far so good.  But then, after a completely over the top sequence in which most of Hollywood's young stars are not simply "left behind," but gruesomely swallowed into the fires of Hell (again, I'm not into gore, but the movie still had me) the film settles into what seemed like an interminable middle section where six survivors try to figure out what happened and how they are going to survive.  It never goes anywhere interesting, and begins to feel claustrophobic and self referential, like, as some other critics have observed, this was some big inside joke that only they a few other peeps in the biz are in on (in fairness, this was not the majority opinion; This is the End was very well received by critics).

I would chalk this up as a missed opportunity, because the beginning, as I said, sets things up nicely, and the end, which goes inexplicably feel good in some ways (though still a bit bloody), wasn't that bad.  But the entire middle was a muddle of hit and mainly miss gags that left me bored. There was an opportunity to comment of religion, race relations, the objectification of women and the various anxieties effecting twenty and thirty-something men, but it never really does, or does so in the most superficial ways imaginable.

I've read and seen reviews (after I saw this mess) trying to explain the deeper meaning that Rogen and Seth Goldberg (writers and first time directors) were trying to say about male friendships and fame versus reality, but I didn't see it.  I admit that this is at least in part a generational issue (I'm just too old for this kind of stuff), but I think that it's more than that.  Yes, there is gore (this is meant as a "horror-comedy"), plenty of profanity and humor of the sexual and scatological variety, but who cares?  Just because you repeat a "dirty" word or phrase a bunch of times doesn't make it funny.  You may not have always agreed with Lenny Bruce, Richard Pryor or George Carlin (I certainly didn't), but the profanity that they used wasn't the point.  It was meant to get your attention so you would hear what they were really trying to say.  And no matter where you landed on the issues being explored, you couldn't deny that they were very funny men.  I know that this was meant as a bit of self parody and all, but maybe these guys really don't have as much to say as they think.  Maybe they are a bit more self absorbed than they want to admit.

Man of Steel

Now that Batman was been revamped for the screen it's time for the Superman legend to get it's day in the multiplexes.  The bottom line: this wasn't a terrible movie, but it simply wasn't all that compelling, either.  And all the Christ symbolism was laid on mighty thick.  I thought telling the story in a non linear style was good, and how they brought Clark Kent / Superman and Lois Lane together was inventive (though they sort of conflated the Lois and Jimmy Olson characters together, which seemed odd).  Superman is unbreakable, but not un-bendable, and he does have to exert great effort to accomplish some of his more spectacular feats, which was refreshing. Again, I didn't hate it, I just wasn't sure how necessary it was.

I'm having a hard time thinking of things to say about Man of Steel (I saw it about two weeks ago) not so much because of the time laps but because it was such a vanilla experience.  Fr. Barron gave an interesting commentary on it, so I'll leave him to say the rest.

The Lone Ranger

Back when I was a kid there was an attempt to bring the Lone Ranger legend to screen by way of a big budget spectacle, and it flopped epically.  From the reviews and box office receipts of this latest attempt, from the same people who brought us the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise, this concept must be cursed to failure.  

In spite of the title, this time out the "Faithful Indian Guide" Tonto is actually the main character of the story (actor Johnny Depp gets top billing to drive the point home).  Borrowing heavily from the 1970 Dustin Hoffman film Little Big Man, the story is told in flashback by Tonto as an old man in 1933 San Francisco.   There are other thefts from that earlier film, including one of its most famous lines, but in the end it's irrelevant.  They could have taken the best ideas from every western of the last seventy years and it wouldn't have saved this thing.

In the spirit of the aforementioned This is the End, they started with a good idea but this time, instead of going no where with it, director Gore Verbinski moves things along briskly, though the wrong direction.  The angle here is that The Lone Ranger (Armie Hammer) is an amiable dunce.  He's an earnest lawyer going west to bring law and order but is totally clueless.  He and Tonto form a reluctant partnership, which Tonto is constantly trying to wiggle out of after saving Kemosabe's skin time and time again.  The movie is full of humorous moments, which is great, but these are juxtaposed by truly gruesome scenarios. For me the two things just didn't mix.  I think if they had stuck with the Lone Ranger as well meaning dimwit motif, made this a smaller movie; more like a straight satire, it could have worked.  But, without a doubt, they want to make a series out of this, so that was never going to happen.  We get hearts getting torn out (and eaten), decapitations and terrorized children.  It's PG-13, so there is no gore to speak of, and the most extreme violence happens off screen, but it still makes for a very heavy experience that weighs down the whimsical movie trying to get out.    

Ken Burns: Prohibition

Ken Burns has reached a point in his career where I think that he is blissfully incapable of making a bad documentary.  2011's Prohibition, directed with Lynn Novick, is not ground breaking like The Civil War or Baseball, but it doesn't need to be.  His style is familiar, true, but he has a way penetrating a story and making distant history and the people who made it seem contemporary, giving us an empathy with the players, not just a knowledge of dates and events.  We come to understand better why things happened the way they did, not simply that they did.

In the case of Prohibition he uses the first of its three parts to trace the history of alcohol use and of the temperance movement in the United States, going back to colonial times.  While the clear conclusion of the series is that Prohibition was a great mistake, we understand that the problems of alcoholism and how drinking habits had evolved in the States over the course of the 18th and 19th centuries lead to real problems and legitimate concerns among the public.  Those in the temperance movement were not simply moralistic busy bodies, but were often victims of the ravages of alcoholism and saw the need to do something about it.

Where things go off the rails, for Burns, is when the temperance movement very early on changes from a movement seeking people's voluntary abstinence from strong drink to one pushing for the total ban on its manufacture and sale.  In the end the 18th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution that made the manufacture and sale of alcohol a crime, and the Volstead Act that detailed it's enforcement, were simply unenforceable.  Rather than alleviating the problems of alcoholism and crime both were exacerbated.

A theme that is repeated again and again throughout the series by the various interviewees as to why prohibition failed is that "you can't regulate morality."  There is something true to this, but something incredibly false as well.  All laws are somehow a reflection of the moral code of the people, if not of God.  It's not a question of if we regulate morality, but rather how we regulate it.  As was pointed out in the movie, it was harder to get a drink after the repeal of the 18th Amendment than it was during prohibition.  Milton Friedman (not featured in the film) once told the story that he went to a former speakeasy with a friend the day the law changed in 1933 for a drink and were informed that they couldn't serve alcohol because they hadn't been issued a liquor license yet.  With regulation, as opposed to an outright ban, governments can control and manipulate better the actions of the people.  And we should not kid ourselves, moral persuasion is a tool used by authorities to get their point across.

Smoking, for instance, has dramatically decreased in the last fifty years, yes because we know more about the heath risks involved, but also because of the heavy taxes levied on tobacco products.  There are also laws restricting where a person may smoke, with some municipalities mulling laws prohibiting smoking even in private residences.  The government has also used public service campaigns that present smoking as wrong.  Scientific and medical evidence may be used to make the case, but these are not cold appeals to logic, but very deliberate framing of the issue in moral terms.  A message is being sent; smokers are outside, literally and figuratively, the mainstream of social behavior and the practice must be stopped.

I have no love for cigarettes, and don't smoke, myself.  I'm all for ending smoking.  I'm just pointing out that by framing the issue in moral terms, conditioning the behavior and attitudes of the people and slowly regulating the industry out of existence, the government has been more successful in it's attempts to end smoking than it would have by an all out ban.  That is the real lesson of Prohibition.

Lumen Fidei: A Commentary by Fr. Robert Barron

I've got a couple of posts that I'm tinkering with right now, and could have an original piece put up before the end of business today.

Until then here's something from Fr. Robert Barron on the Pope's new Encyclical Lumen Fidei, on the theological virtue of faith. I've read it, am reading it again and I'll have my reflections on it, hopefully, next week.  Until then enjoy this.  Fr. Barron sees this letter on faith as an answer to the "new atheists'" claims the faith is a childish submission to irrational beliefs.

My own reflection on faith in general is that we only put our faith in things that we have a reason to.  If a boyfriend or girlfriend has always been honest and trust worthy then we can have faith in them when we take the next step and enter into marriage.  We would be a fool to entrust our hearts to someone who we knew was a liar and a cheat.  Faith comes in because, as they say in the investment game, past performance doesn't insure future results.  Humans are fallible and even the most noble is capable of infidelity under the right circumstances.  But we take the person's track record and have faith that together your virtues will only be strengthened by God's grace.

When it comes to God, I put my faith in Him, at least in part, because He has a track record.  I can see that there is still a Jewish people and still a Church.  God made promises to Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Moses and David to make their descendants as numerous as the sand of the sea shore, a kingdom that would endure.  While I believe that the promises made by God to Israel see their ultimate fulfillment in the Church, he has not forgotten his "remnant."  Through wars, exiles, occupations, and even genocides, the Jewish people endure and thrive.  Jesus promised Peter that the gates of Hell would not prevail against the Church.  And through persecutions, schisms, reformations and scandals the Church endures, and even thrives.  God doesn't promise peace and tranquility, but he does promise His abiding presence and ultimate victory.  He's got a track record I can trust, and so I put my faith in Him.


Tuesday, July 9, 2013

Matrimonial Chastity?


I took the feast of St. Maria Goretti as an opportunity to reflect on the current debate over the proper definition of marriage.  That may seem strange since this saint is so connected with chastity.  In truth it makes perfect sense because, contrary to popular belief, chastity and celibacy are not the same thing.  Married people are called to live chastely just as much as single people and vowed religious are.  How so?

Well, the virtue of chastity consists in the moderation and self control of our sexual appetite, and is related in general to the virtue of  temperance.  For a single person this means total abstinence from sexual relations before marriage.  For a vowed religious and most Catholic priests it means a life long commitment to the celibate life.  For a married person it means fidelity to his or her spouse.  But it also means more than that.  Here are a few qualities of matrimonial chastity that come to mind.

1. Married chastity involves a mutual respect between partners.  Bl. John Paul II, whose writings on marriage and sexuality alone should garner him the title of Doctor of the Church, stressed that marriage was not a license to "do what ever you want."  The needs and dispositions of both partners needs to be taken into account when engaging in the conjugal act.  For instance one should never force himself upon the other (an obvious point, I would think).  JPII caused a stir when he suggested that there was such a thing a marital rape (some accused him of being puritanical).   He also scandalized some when, as a bishop, he wrote that spouses need to be attentive to the sexual satisfaction of their partners lest the "slighted" partner begin to view sex as a wearisome burden (what's a bishop doing writing of such things, how indecent, some said). A couple that approaches sex in a spirit of mutual respect and regard for the needs of the other are living the ideal of loving self control the virtue of chastity calls for.

2. Married chastity is open to the transmission of new life.  Ah yes, the contraception issue.  If Social Security is the third rail of American politics, this is surly 1,500 volts of shock no priest wants to play hopscotch around in the pulpit or in the confessional.  For most married Catholics this is something they see as a settled matter, and do not want to discuss it.  In my recent experiences with preparing couples for the sacrament I sense a tolerant politeness when I talk about it, and in some cases I do pick up a genuine curiosity about Natural Family Planning (NFP), but I'm under no illusions about the odds of them taking this practice up in their married life.  I've written on this topic in other places, but I will just say that those who practice NFP faithfully school themselves in the very self control that fosters mutual respect and regard for the needs of the other.  Sex is less likely to be engaged in for purely selfish motives, but (hopefully) in a spirit of gratitude and appreciation for the other since a time of abstinence is required each month for those who do not want to have children at a given moment, or else with the joyful purpose of being co-creators with God in the generation of a new life.  Either way the virtue of married chastity involves the perfecting the ideal that sex is an act of mutual self giving open to the transmission of new life. 

3. Married chastity involves modesty and custody of the eyes.  Modesty and custody of the eyes are somewhat "old timey" terms that we don't hear much about today.  Modesty usually involves how we dress and speak.  Dressing provocatively or telling "off color" jokes would go against the virtue of modesty.  Custody of the eyes involves having self control over how we see people.  To see a person we might find attractive and acknowledging it to ourselves is not sinful.  On the other hand leering and allowing lustful thoughts to develop into fantasies that linger in our minds would be going against what Jesus talked about when he said that it is possible to commit adultery in our hearts.

I am sometime countered by the line that immodesty is in the eye of the beholder, so if someone finds a woman's neckline too revealing it's his problem not hers  (And I don't mean to pick on women, men can certainly dress immodestly as well).  First off, this takes for granted the virtue of the owner of the neckline in question.  Secondly, while having custody of the eyes means that we have learned to look upon others as complete human beings and not sex objects, if our hypothetical neckline was as virtuous as we assume then she would have patience with the scruples of those weaker than herself, as St. Paul would put it, and not dress in a way that could be misconstrued or lead others into sin.  Obviously we need to be sensible about things; one doesn't go to the beach in a tuxedo or a floor length gown.  At the same time one shouldn't attend Mass in speedos or a mini skirt.  I would say that these principles apply to both single and married alike.

But on a deeper level I would say that these dual ideas of modesty and custody of the eyes needs to apply as well to the rampant spread of pornography and "gentleman's clubs" in our society.  There are wives content to allow their husbands to indulge in these "diversions" under the false assumption that these aren't sins against married life.  But in both cases these involve a debasement and objectifying of other people for the sexual gratification of the "customer," and in the case of the married person, it is seeking that gratification in isolation, apart from the fruitful and nurturing relationship of husband and wife.

Pornography has been especially harmful to marriages, with some studies suggesting that upwards of 50% of divorces are caused by porn addiction.  In these voyeuristic and vicarious experiences we can fool ourselves into thinking that the performers are somehow "not real."  But they are very real people caught in a web us sin, and we participate in that sin by watching a paying for it.

I don't claim these three points to be exhaustive, but they are what come to my mind right away when I think of the virtue of chastity within the context of marriage.

Saturday, July 6, 2013

Maria Goretti, Chastity and Christian Marriage

A photo believed to be of St. Maria Goretti


Brothers and sisters: "Food is meant for the stomach and the stomach for food" -- and God will destroy both one and the other. The body is not meant for immorality, but for the Lord, and the Lord for the body. And God raised the Lord and will also raise us up by his power. Do you not know that your bodies are members of Christ? Shall I therefore take the members of Christ and make them members of a prostitute? Never! But he who is united to the Lord becomes one spirit with him. Shun immorality. Every other sin which a man commits is outside the body; but the immoral man sins against his own body. Do you not know that your body is a temple of the Holy Spirit within you, which you have from God? You are not your own; you were bought with a price. So glorify God in your body.  1 Cor. 6:13c-15a, 17-20

I guess I don't so much want to reflect on the life of today's Saint, Maria Goretti, as the reading from St. Paul's First Letter to the Corinthians that is suggested for her Mass.  The virtue of Chastity, which Maria died for,  is central to the living of the Christian life.  Sadly the broader culture doesn't see it that way, and current attitudes toward marriage that are prevalent among many is proof of that.

Needless to say, the definition of marriage has been a hotly debated topic over the past several years, and is again at the forefront of people's attention with the recent Supreme Court decision striking down the Defense of Marriage Act.  Many do not understand why the Catholic Church is uncompromising in Her opposition to the redefinition of marriage to include same sex couples.  Is the Church bigoted against gays?  Are we holding to some Victorian notion of sexual morality that society has long ago abandoned?  The answer lies in our understanding of marriage, not born of a lack of charity or of social convention but of Divine Revelation, and our notion of Christian Chastity in general, born of the same.

We are stubborn on this issue, because from the beginning God created them male and female, as Scripture tells us.  The first couple were given to each other by God to be partners and companions, true, but also to "be fruitful and multiply."  We don't know from Genesis how long Adam and Eve enjoyed the Original Blessing before the Fall, but sex and family would have been a part of that blessing, whether they partook of them or not.  They were joined in a marriage, the primordial Sacrament, as Bl. John Paul put it, central to God's plan for humanity.  Because of the intrinsic link in our understanding between sex and child rearing, love and responsibility, Christian marriage is never simply about romantic love.  Romance may be the spark that lights the fire, but if the flames of love are to be enduring they need to be rooted in something deeper than sexual attraction or even the need for companionship.

As Paul reminds us above, sex is not to be seen as a good in and of itself.  Any attachment to bodily pleasure, be it eating, drinking or whatever pleasure a person finds comfort in, should be ordered toward a greater good or we will become self centered, closed off from the blessings God wants to give to us.  The body has value.  We are not bodies with souls, but neither are we a soul who lugs around an animated corps.  Christ redeemed the whole human person, and the body is meant as the visible expression of the invisible reality "underneath" it.  It is how we love, serve and live out our vocation as Christians.  In baptism we are joined to Christ, body and soul, and this union is renewed and made more explicit in the reception of the Eucharist.  When we sin we bring Christ with us to a place he doesn't want to go.  He doesn't want to accompany us in sexual sin because it is a misusing of the body and the gift of sexuality that is is ordered to a particular good; the good of the couple, yes, but also family life, which prevents sex from becoming self centered and egotistical.

When gays feel that the Church, and others who stand against same sex marriage are singling them out for scrutiny unjustly, they have a point.  The wider Western Culture has long a go separated sex from family life, and reduced marriage to a romantic relationship or maybe, on a deeper level, sees it as a profound companionship that involves certain legal benefits.  Children and family can be, and usually are part of this arrangement, but is far from essential.  All that matters is the couple themselves independent of any reference to family and society at large.  If marriage is thus defined, than why not include couples of the same gender among those who can join in wedlock?

Yes, I am stubborn.  Whatever you might want to call such a union, it is not a marriage as I understand it as a disciple of Christ, and it doesn't make a bit of difference if the couple is gay or straight.  This is so not because "I" believe it, but because I have thrown my lot in with Christ who teaches me through Scripture and Tradition, which includes in this case a teaching reiterated by Pope Francis in his latest encyclical.  These are my guides; not opinion polls or changing social attitudes.  I judge social mores by the Gospel, not the other way around.

I guess I feel compelled to conclude by saying that Christ holds His disciples to a high standard, not easy to follow.  Sometimes people fail, and then we trust in God's mercy and His grace that makes conversion possible.  Jesus made it clear that the Kingdom is not for the unchaste, but also showed great compassion for those who fell into sexual sin.  Jesus will always take us back.  But in this issue we are not simply talking about sin and weakness but in the institutionalizing of a way which is simply contrary to the Gospel message.  My only fear is that by going down this path, it is not Christ who will withdraw his love and compassion from us, but we who are closing ourselves off from it. 

Friday, July 5, 2013

Santo Subito! John Paul II and John XXIII to be Canonized



Along with the release of the first encyclical of Pope Francis' pontificate this morning, it was announced that Blesseds John XXIII and John Paul II will be canonized, probably sometime before the new year.  I have only gotten the my hands on the new letter, entitled  Lumen Fidei (The Light of Faith), but I'll get going on reading it and giving you my thoughts soon.    But for now, I just want to express joy at this announcement, and reflect on the early reports in the secular press.

As one might expect, John Paul Paul II is getting most of the headlines.  His was the more recent and longer pontificate.  As for "Good" Pope John, much is being made of the fact that Pope Francis dispensed with the usual requirement for a second miracle before the canonization can proceed.  First, the Church makes the rules, and the pope can dispense with these requirements as he sees fit, (like when Pope Benedict dispensed with the five year waiting period to begin the process almost immediately after JPII's death).  This time around it was done on the recommendation of the cardinals and bishops handling the case.  Before the 1600's there was no canonization process, the pope simply declared someone a saint based on his or her reputation, and sometimes the acclamation of the people from where the candidate was from.  And dispensing from this requirement is not unheard of.  St. Thomas More was canonized without any miracles attributed to his intercession; his martyrdom was seen as sufficient proof of heroic virtue. 

As for John Paul "the Great,"  most of the secular stories I read couldn't finish without mentioning the child sex abuse scandals that erupted in the final years of his pontificate, as if these should disqualify him from being raised to the altar.  A few observations:

1.  In the spirit of Pope Leo XIII, we should neither hide the truth nor lie about the past.  It is a historical fact that the scandals blew up during John Paul's pontificate.  Questions must be asked concerning how the Church, and the pope himself, handled the situation.  But we are declaring a person a saint, not divine.  All saints had faults, short comings, blind spots and failures.  All you need to do to figure this out is to read Gospels and observe the behavior of the Twelve.   The question is not if John Paul II was perfect, but was he faithful to his call to a heroic degree until he drew his last breath.

2.  The scandals themselves predate JPII's pontificate, with some cases reaching back to the 1940's and '50's.   This would mean that John XXIII should be receiving the same scrutiny, especially since the majority of cases are from roughly the '50's to the '70's (Pope John served from 1958 until 1963).

3.  Some see the dual canonization as a way of balancing out these concerns over John Paul's suitability, by placating both "progressives," who tend to idealize Pope John  and "conservatives," who are devoted to John Paul.  One article I read tried to paint it that Pope Francis is more in line with those progressives who see Vatican II as a clear break from the past as opposed to Pope Emeritus Benedict who had tried to stress the continuity of the Council with the development of the faith through the centuries; thus, again, pushing the placate scenario. In a word, rubbish.  You could make just as strong an argument that canonizing both men together is a way of reinforcing this notion of continuity (which I espouse):  the pope who called the council canonized with the pope who spent almost 30 years interpreting the reforms after their initial implementation by Pope Paul VI.

I have to get back to the work of the parish, at this point.  But I'll certainly have more to say of the great event, and Pope Francis' first encyclical.

Monday, July 1, 2013

"Evangelical Catholicism" - George Wiegel // Book Review

Evangelical Catholicism: Deep Reform in the 21st-Century Catholic Church
George Weigel, Basic Books, 2013

Every so often I read something, be it a book or an article, and I'll say to myself, "Self, this person is saying what I've been feeling but haven't been able put into words."  George Weigel's new book, Evangelical Catholicism, is one such book.  In it Weigel tries to cut through the politicized and polarized ways many Catholics, in the United States anyway, have tended to view things religious over the last fifty years in order to set in motion the "deep reform" of twenty-first century Catholicism along evangelical lines.

Before going on some definition of terms is needed.  Catholics and Main Line Protestants usually hear the word "evangelical" and think Christian fundamentalist, with all that that implies.  But what we mean by evangelical is that the central mission of the Church is the spreading of the Gospel message, and leading more people into a personal encounter, and ultimately friendship with the Lord Jesus Christ.  The Church's mission is not one of self maintenance where the criteria of success is measured purely on how the latest parish capital campaign is going, or if it reached it's quota on the bishop's annual appeal.  It's not that these things are unimportant, but rather they are good only in so far as they assist the overall mission of the Church which is the spreading of the Gospel.  When things that are ancillary become central, or when the Church gets caught up in theological debates over Her identity, as we will see, then She becomes self referential and irrelevant to the outside world: the very antithesis of what Evangelical Catholicism means. 

In recent decades we have seen the Church break into two camps.  On one hand you have progressive Catholics, who tend to be somewhat low church when it comes to liturgy, strong in promoting the social justice teachings of the Church while de-emphasizing the teachings on abortion and sexual morality.   They are often for a married clergy and women priests, and may be in favor of gay marriage.  On the other side you have traditionalist, who, in some cases want to go back to the pre-Vatican II liturgy, and place a greater stress on personal morality, especially on sexual matters, as opposed to the Church's social doctrine.  They're for a strict adherence to liturgical regulations and the excommunication of political office holders who publicly descent from Church teachings, especially on abortion.  While I have no doubt from reading this book, and some of Weigel's other writings, that his sympathies are more with the traditionalist side, he takes a pox on both your houses approach to this divide.  For him both sides exist within a Counter Reformation Catholic framework that sees the Church as She is and either wants to go back to a more stringent observance of "the rules," or else wants to loosen up the reins.  But neither model of Church, if you will, is sufficient to confront an ambient culture that is increasingly hostile to Catholic values.  

The proper response to this hostile culture is a Catholicism that understands that many, including those who are baptized members of the Church, do not share the traditional Catholic world view.   The answer is not to abandon traditional teachings, but to make an appeal from the Gospels as opposed to from ecclesiastical authority.  Contemporary Western culture has a mistrust of institutions and authority.  To appeal to the Code of Canon Law or a papal pronouncement to defend a position is useless in an argument with someone who doesn't recognize their validity to begin with.  But to appeal to the Gospel, Weigel argues, is to change the conversation from one of authority to one of challenge that will prompt a response.  It may be a thoughtful rejoinder or it may be hostile, but it will not be indifferent, and hopefully the conversation will continue.

Weigel does not see this process of evangelical reform as something that is just beginning now.  He traces its roots to the pontificate of Leo XIII (1878-1903) and sees it progressing through the popes of the twentieth century and leading to Vatican II, with Blessed John Paul II and Benedict XVI giving it its philosophical and theological character.  The book was published just as Pope Benedict was stepping down, but in recent interviews he has said that he sees Pope Francis as following right in line with this evangelical movement.

This really scratches the surface of what the book talks about, so I might revisit it at a later time. I guess what I identified with was this idea that we have come to the end of one historical phase of Catholicism and are now entering into another.  Counter Reformation Catholicism was vibrant and powerful; it held the Church together during a difficult period of Her history, and did oversee the evangelization of large parts of the non-European world.  But now we face new challenges that demands a new new expression of the faith.  Not that the content of the Catholic Faith changes, but how it is communicated and expressed needs to evolve and how it's lived deepened.  We must not be content to simply maintain institutions, but have the courage to alter them, or even abandon them for new models if they are no longer effective in serving the Church's central mission of evangelization. This is a frightening proposal, but one that must be taken seriously if the Church is going to be true to Herself, and the Divine Spouse that She serves. 

Thursday, June 27, 2013

Man of Steel: A Commentary by Fr. Robert Barron

I haven't seen the latest cinematic spin on the grandaddy of all the comic book superheros Superman, and I'm not sure that I am any time soon.  But here is a reflection on some of the deeper themes of the new movie, Man of Steel, by Fr. Barron.

I know that some people wonder if commentators like Fr. Barron read too much into popular entertainments like this, as he mentions, but I don't think that he does.  Film makers are artists, even if commerce is their primary motivation for doing what they do, forming their art in light of a particular world view.  Though they may not be consciously trying to put forth an agenda every time out, which I think they are more than we realize, their personal philosophy will come through one way or another.  Ideas matter, and while most people might find thinkers like Plato and Nietzsche to be esoteric and detached from everyday experience, their ideas are taught in universities and influence educators, artist, writers, lawyers and judges, to name a few.  The ideas do trickle down and shape how we view and form society and look at ourselves.

Birth of John the Baptist from the Apostleship of Prayer

I know that this is a few days late, but it's still a good reflection on St. John the Baptist. 

Tuesday, June 25, 2013

Mad Men Season Six: Put it in the Books

mad men redemption 650 amc tnc.jpg

I'm not sure that I have much to say about the just concluded season of Mad Men, since I wrote a pretty extensive post two weeks ago.  I guess pleasantly surprised would be the best way to describe my reaction to the last two episodes.  Last year ended with a bang, by way of Lane Pryce's suicide in the penultimate installment, with the final episode serving as a kind of epilogue meant to tie up loose ends from the season and give us hints as to the future.  I'm glad they didn't follow that same strategy this time out. Here the entire season seemed to be building to this big crescendo that didn't happen, though the conclusion was far from uneventful.  The whole Rosemary's Baby motif ended up being for atmospherics, not foreshadowing.  Megan wasn't murdered.  Bob Benson wasn't whatever it was people were imagining him to be; everything from a corporate spy to Don Draper's long lost son (some out on the Web even suspected he was a time traveling Don).  And Don didn't die.

Or, did he?

The one constant in a sea of shifting relationships, alliances and corporate configurations over the past six seasons of the show is that Don Draper doesn't change.  He might be tempted to run away, change local or even business, but he will always be the same secretive, controlling fraud hiding behind a made up persona.   He has only lifted the veil over his past in small ways to different people over the years, like when he told Peggy that he grew up on a farm, or Conrad Hilton that he was born in Illinois and grew up in rural Pennsylvania.  But in the final episode of Season Six Don Draper for the first time publicly acknowledges his true identity as Dick Whitman, if not by name then by story.

As I wrote previously, Don was very much a mess as this season came to a close.  Like two seasons ago he was drinking way too much and was beginning to show physical and behavioral signs of alcoholism.   In the past he was the top creative dog at the agency (know known as SC&P), so if he blew off a partners meeting or disappeared for a few days, or weeks, people put up with it because they knew that the work would get done and done well.  Now, in 1968, we see that Don is not the creative force he once was, and now that he has real competition from Ted Chaough, people are less inclined to put up with his erratic behavior.

They say an alcoholic doesn't begin to turn his or her life around until they hit rock bottom.  For Don that was spending the night in jail after hitting a preacher trying to evangelize in a bar.  But as usual, Mad Men doesn't take a simple view on things, including religion.  Yes, this particular preacher probably deserved the belt for implying that Martin Luther King and the Kennedy's met their tragic ends because they weren't true believers (another stereotypical caricature of a hypocritical religious person).  But when he flashes back to his teen years working in the brothel, and the preacher who was kicked out for trying to convert the prostitutes, the words that stuck with the adult Don Draper / Dick Whitman was when the minister said, "The only unpardonable sin is to believe that God can not forgive you."

So he goes home after his night in the drunk tank and dumps the booze down the sink.  He plans to move to a proposed branch office in California, convincing Megan that they can make a fresh start there.  Then he hits a conundrum.  Ted, who is also trying to save his marriage, pleads with Don to trade places.  He appeals to his conscience, which may seem like his least vulnerable spot, by telling him that he knows that there's a good man inside of him.

Something does click in Don's mind.  At a pitch to Hershey's Chocolate he begins with his usual smooth delivery, speaking of his own, mythical, childhood experience of getting a Hershey Bar as a reward from his father.  A total lie, of course, but it's working as always.  Then inexplicably, after it appears the deal is done, he starts up again, this time telling the truth about himself and his orphaned youth, serving as a pick pocket in a bordello, getting the candy as a reward if he stole more than a dollar from a given john.  The candy to him was his only link to normalcy and goodness, and he tells the representatives that  they don't need a man like him to explain to a child what a Hershey Bar means, they know already.  For the first time I felt true pity for the man, because for the first time he was really owning who he is and what he's made of his life.

I'm not sure if he was trying to make it up to Ted for being bad to him, especially when he embarrassed him at the St. Joseph's Baby Aspirin pitch, but this act of self sabotage showed the first act of total unselfishness Don has ever done.  It also sealed his fate.  Though he eventually yielded to Ted's request, California wasn't going to happen for him now anyway.  The other partners essentially dump him, under the guise of a leave of absence.  Megan, rightfully angry that she had quite her job to relocate to the Coast, now in career limbo, walks out, presumably for good.  Don had shifted careers before in his life, and even identities, but always stayed the same self serving con man.  Now he is stripped of everything, not to escape into some sort of alternate reality, but to confront himself as he truly is.  That little "meltdown" was the first step in that process, and was as much an act of redemption for himself as it was a favor to Ted.

The end was perfect.  Don brings his three children to the house in Pennsylvania where he spent those painful years.  The house is now completely rundown, surrounded by housing projects and factories.  The quintessential suburban kids, they're nervous at stopping in such a bad neighborhood.  After he explains that this was where he grew up, his daughter Sally, who he's been estranged from since she discovered his infidelities, gives him a knowing look, as if to say, it's still not right what you did and what kind of father you've been in general, but think I get it now.  

One way or another all the major characters end this season with clean slates.  Pete, whose marriage is over and whose mother joined his father in a watery grave, is also going to California to start over.  Peggy, knowing that Ted will not leave his marriage for her, is last seen giving Don's office chair a tryout.  Roger is starting over with Joan, but on different, platonic terms, so he can be close to the son that only he and Joan know that they have.   Mad Men seasons have always left off with a dose of uncertainty, but never like this.  What 1969-70 has in store is wide open.  Will Don be let back in to SC&P after his leave of indeterminate length is over, or will he branch out on his own?  Will Peggy get Don's chair for real, and a partnership (as I've predicted in the past)?  Will the show be switching focus to Los Angeles, or really be bi-coastal, as Don proposed for Megan and himself?  Is Bob Benson gay or just an opportunist (which is my opinion), and so his designs of Joan are more than just business related?

All these questions are interesting, but to me everything comes down to Don Draper, who is now dead as many predicted that he would be, just not literally.  The only question is whether or not he'll go back to using his birth name at some point.  The years of running from his past are over, and next season will be a time of self discovery for the man whose solution to every problem was denying the truth to others, but mostly to himself.    
 
It would probably be too much to ask for the writers to include God in Don's transformation.  They have shown a fairness to religion in the past, by way of Fr. Gill, and Ted's religiosity, which I have to believe effected his decision to stay with his wife.  Don's violent reaction to the preacher was not so much that he was a preacher, but that he was judgmental fool.  I get the feeling Don wants to believe, but has seen too much bad to cross that line.  But as the aforementioned Ted observed, there is a good man inside there, and I do believe someone open to believing again, or maybe for the first time.

I guess that I had more to say than I originally thought.  Until Spring 2014, that will do it for Mad Men.  Though you never know, I might have some other musings on the show before then.

Saturday, June 22, 2013

Rosemary's Baby Revisited

The current season of Mad Men has used Roman Polanski's classic 1968 horror film Rosemary's Baby as a reference point, both explicitly and implicitly, on numerous occasions.  But I'm not so much interested here in how Rosemary's Baby impacts this season's story arc, as with the movie itself.  I recently went back and saw it again after many years.  The first time I saw it was as a teenager, and I actually fell asleep during it.  Now as an adult I was riveted and repulsed all at once.  I finally got why my parents, and so many who were adults in the late 60's condemned the film as shockingly sacrilegious.  Today I'm not sure that many, especially those who have grown up on contemporary blood and guts horror, will get just how truly frightening, and subversive, this film is, because it's not here to gross you out, but rather works on a much more subtle level to rob you of your hope.

I will be making references often to the Ira Levin novel, so before going on, I must note that I never read it.  I feel comfortable though because every article I read in preparing this post, including one by Ira Levin himself, say that Roman Polanski made what could be the single most faithful filmed adaptation of a book in Hollywood history.  He was so slavish in following the source material that the author wondered if the Polish director, making his first U.S. movie, did this on purpose or simply didn't understand that he was at liberty to change things if he wanted to.  A friend of mine who has read it tells me that he likes it better than the movie, and that it has a humorous streak the film lacks that breaks up the doom and gloom.  Summer is here, so maybe I'll add it to my reading list, but I digress...

For the uninitiated, Rosemary's Baby follows the story of a young couple (Mia Farrow and John Cassevetes) who moves into an old apartment house in Manhattan with a creepy reputation.  They are soon befriended by the Castevet's, an elderly couple (Sidney Blackmer and Ruth Gordon, in her Oscar winning role) who insinuate themselves into their lives.   Once Rosemary gets pregnant, under very disturbing circumstances,  the Castevet's and the other senior citizen tenants begin to micromanage her care, from what home made medicines she takes to what doctor she will see.  Her health begins to decline, but her husband Guy insists that she stays the course.  Little by little she begins to suspect something evil is afoot, but finds little support from the people closest to her.  The one person who does lend a hand, her friend Hutch (Maurice Evens), meets mysterious end.

The film, as with the Ira Levin novel it's based on, takes place between the fall of 1965 and June '66 (get the three 6's reference?).  One similarity between Mad Men and this supernatural thriller is that Levin wrote his story in "real time," taking events that actually happened during those months, like a public transit strike and Pope Paul VI's visit to New York, and mixed them into his fictional timeline.  In truth he was writing just after these events, and knowingly or not was touching on some important themes of the era that have effects on us still.

Levin's exact motives in choosing to turn "the Mary and Joseph story on it's head," as he put it, are unclear.   On the one hand he knew that he was playing with literary fire, and was worried about a backlash from Christians, especially Catholics, prior to the book's release in 1967.  On the other he claimed no deep message or purpose other than to write a scary story that would make money to feed his family.  But if a story, even a misguided and blasphemous one like this, is accurate somehow in its depiction of human nature or the times it takes place in it will bring out certain truths, even if the author doesn't intend it.  In the mid '60's the relevance of organized religion in the public square was on the wane.  We were seeing a growing mistrust of public institutions in general that would have it's full flowering in the aftermath of the Watergate Scandal a few years later.   As for religion, God may not have been dead, but to many He was becoming background noise as opposed to the main reference point of their lives.  But what replaces God and religion, and what is our defense against the nefarious forces lined up against us when these things are not there or recognized?  Rosemary's Baby captures this dilemma perfectly.


Rosemary is a woman caught in the midst of the social and sexual revolutions of the sixties.  She is unsure about religion, having been raised a Catholic but now harboring doubts.  She is sexually assertive, yet does show a deference to her husband Guy that is hard to imagine today.  She clearly wants a child, and reacts angrily when she thinks friends are suggesting an abortion after it becomes clear that her health is declining.  In general she is obedient to the people around her, showing only passive resistance, but otherwise lets events happen to her.  Once she does begin to try to take control she is treated as insane.  This has been varyingly interpreted as promoting both feminist and anti-feminist agendas.  I'm not sure it does either, but reflects the author's nonjudgmental view of life at that time. 

There is also much debate as to whether the satanic elements of the story are real or just figments of Rosemary's increasingly deranged mind.  There is no doubt that as she unravels the mystery, and discovers that this ungodly plot she's suspecting extends beyond her neighbors to her own doctor, she does become more and more unhinged, which seems to be only natural.  I take what I see at face value, because no real hints are given to the contrary.  It's true that what she supposes the coven of witches wants with her baby is false, but that she is up against a satanic conspiracy is all too real, and confirmed by the movie's ending.

As she does discover the truth, Rosemary becomes more and more isolated.  By the end she trusts no one, especially her obstetrician Dr. Saperstein, played chillingly by Ralph Bellamy.  She runs to the one person she feels she can confide in, her old doctor, played by Charles Grodin, and even he betrays her, handing her back into the arms of Saperstein and her husband, who she will soon find out is in league with the coven.

What is chilling about the story is this sense of isolation, that Rosemary has no one to take her part against the forces of evil.  When she comes to the moment of realization that Dr. Saperstein is in on the conspiracy she is in his waiting room browsing the Time Magazine from April 1966 that asked the question on it's cover, in bold red print on a pitch black background, "Is God Dead?"  In the end, the baby is born.  Rosemary is lead to believe he was still born, but soon discovers the truth.  At first repulsed, she is convinced to stay and "be a mother to him."  As the revelers surrounding the bassinet proclaim that the "Year 1" has dawned, Rosemary takes her place by her son, gently rocking the cradle.  She is once again passive, accepting of the situation she has been forced into, and it does seem like God is, if not dead, absent and powerless.

In later years Levin regretted using the demonic motif, feeling that it helped spawn the supernatural thriller craze of the 1970's, and possibly helped spur a fundamentalist Christian backlash.  He even wrote a sequel thirty years later that made it all out to be a dream in order to make up for this perceived sin.  While I think that he's flattering himself to think that he helped turn people to Christian fundamentalism, there is no doubt that Rosemary's Baby inspired The Exorcist and The Omen., as well as other demonic themed horror movies in the following decades.   But there is a clear difference between Levin's work and The Exorcist author William Peter Blatty's.  In The Exorcist (which I did read) there was hope, however slim, that evil could be confronted.  While the cost was high, God was not dead or absent, so there was someone to take the little girl's part in combating and defeating the powers of darkness. In Rosemary's Baby our heroine is alone and outnumbered all the way.

Levin was a nonbeliever who used what little he was able to research on the topic of witchcraft and satanism to craft a convincing, adult, contemporary horror story. But as I wrote earlier, if an author touches on something true, even if he doesn't buy it himself, people will be drawn too it.  It was his mistake to dabble in forces beyond his control or understanding for cynical gain.  The result was exactly the result he didn't intend or want: that more people would become fascinated with the occult, something he claimed no belief in.  But what makes Rosemary's Baby most disturbing is not the sacrilege (which I didn't really write about) or the satanic subject matter itself, but it's lack of hope.  Even if the coven is a metaphor for government, big business, family, or some other oppressive public or social institution or custom, we are left with an image of resignation in the face of evil.

I do not want to leave you on a down note.  Obviously I do not believe that we are alone.  I do believe in the existence of an Enemy who wishes to undo the work of Christ and rob us of our hope.  But as long as we hold close to the Lord His will will be done.  The cost may be high, and the road difficult, but we never have to despair that He is not with us. 

Wednesday, June 12, 2013

Gentle and Lowly: More on the Sacred Heart from the Apostleship of Prayer

Swinging Round the Corkscrew: "Mad Men" Season Six Down the Stretch

mad, men, season, 6, episode, 7, recap:, dark, don, draper, is, back,

We are heading, sadly, into the last two episodes of Mad Men for this season.  Much of the discussion out on the web concerning the goings on at Sterling Cooper and Partners (the agency's new post-merger name) has been over the hidden motives and objectives of the strangely "straight" Bob Benson (James Wolk) and, more recently, if Megan Draper (Jessica Paré) will be going the way of Sharon Tate.  While these are interesting twists, what has kept my attention, not just this season but over all six, is the moral train wreck that is Dick Whitman's altar ego Don Draper (Jon Hamm).  In him we have the perfect example of the fact that sin makes us unhappy.  Like many of us though Don has become so attached to his vices, like Gollum to the ring, that he can't break way and make the changes necessary to truly be free and happy.  Year after year he just keeps on making the same mistakes, expecting different results, the very definition of insanity.  The way things have gone down hill for him this season it makes me wonder, as others have, if he'll be around for the seventh and final season in 2014.  While I really don't think that they will kill off the main Mad Man before the series finale next year, I can't argue that things don't look bleak for the ad exec we love to hate, or at least pity.

Matt Weiner (pronounced wine-er), the show's creator and chief writer, has said that he knows how he plans to end the story next season, down to the final shot.  This doesn't mean that he has every episode or plot twist worked out, but there is a trajectory, and what I've noticed this season is that he is already tying themes together from seasons past.  We are not dealing with repetition, but with very deliberate attempts to show how things in life come full circle, and can leave you just where you started even with all our good efforts.

Earlier in this season Joan Harris (Christina Hendricks) tries to fire a secretary for falsifying a time card and finds herself undercut by Harry Crane (Rich Sommer), much like she was in a similar situation by Roger Sterling (John Slattery) in season 2.  The difference is that then Roger was a partner and Joan was the office manager.  Now Joan is a partner being successfully bucked by an underling.  Part of this has to do with Harry's resentment that she's risen past him in the company, and what she did to get there.  All Joan knows is that she has a new rank earned through hard work, no matter what any one may think, but she is still treated like an over glorified secretary.  A few episodes later she tries to validate her position to the others by clandestinely wooing new business, even though Pete Campbell (Vincent Kartheiser) was given the assignment.  Pete was guilty of a similar breach of protocol in season one and was almost fired for it.  Rather than remembering his own actions he blows up at her in front of the other partners, essentially trying to get her ousted, for breaking a "fundamental rule" of advertising, the very reason he was almost gone years before.  In both cases history is repeating, and not for the better.  In Pete's case though, he seems to forget that he was once the one breaking the rules and being pardoned for it (Oh, hypocrisy: of all the vices on this show, the one it seems everyone shares). 

If there's been a season long throw back it's Don's downward spiral, reminiscent of a his near breakdown in season four.  Back then his decline was manifested by a slow physical deterioration.  He had a hacking cough that wouldn't go away and was beginning to black out, sometimes waking up with unexpected company.  The years of boozing, smoking and womanizing were taking their toll.  Newly divorced, there were now no stops on his already self destructive habits.  His personal problems were spilling over into his professional life, and things were generally getting out of control.  Then he met Megan, they married and most of season five was spent in relative stability, if not exactly marital bliss.  He was faithful to his wife, and as happy as this very unhappy man had ever been.

Season six began with Don backsliding.  Again we can see echoes of the past.  The series' very first episode presents Don as a devil may care ladies man about town, with a touch of existential nihilism thrown in, ending with a surprise reveal: the man we were led to believe was an eligible, if roguish, bachelor was actually a married father, complete with the big house in Westchester.  This season we go the first episode thinking Don has stayed on the straight and narrow (in spite of last year's season ending foreshadowing), to find in the final scene that he's having an affair with his best friend's wife, who happens to live one floor below the Draper's apartment.

Can you say "self destructive?"  I knew you could.

Most of the commentators out there focus on the therapeutic aspects of Don's problems; he's a sex addict, or he's a control freak, or all his self destructive behavior stems from his highly dysfunctional childhood (which we've gotten clued into over the years by periodic flash backs).  All this is true.  But in our postmodern world no one wants to talk sin.  That Don is caught in a web of sin doesn't negate the other therapeutic reasons for his predicament, or that the reasons he turned to these self destructive behaviors can't be seen as serious impediments to his freedom.  But because we have found ourselves in a cycle of addiction does not mean that we are condemned to stay there.  There is a way out, if we have the courage to surrender.

This season has high lighted a tension within Don: He needs to be in control but is constantly losing it.  He seems to be losing his creative touch at work and, since the merger with their main rival, control in the office as well.  The bloom is off his marriage since Megan gained greater independence by way of her acting career.  The implication is that she no longer needs him in the same way as before, thus another loss of control.  As all this is happening he tries to tighten his grip on the one aspect of his life he thinks he does have control over by his manipulative games with his married mistress Sylvia Rosen (Linda Cardellini).  Even she eventually breaks away from his grasp.  Don is all about control, and losing it makes him look to other options, like possibly abandoning his present identity and starting over, like he did when he deserted the army by assuming a dead man's identity.

The big speculation out there is that this season might see the ultimate in Don shedding his current persona.  There have been overtones of death since the first episode when Don presented an ad campaign for a Hawaiian hotel that made people think of James Mason drowning himself in the Pacific at the end of A Star is Born as opposed to taking a leisurely dip in the ocean (we won't even get into him reading Dante's Inferno on the beach).  Don has some serious issues that he needs to deal with, holes in his soul that need to be filled.  With all the loss of control and continuing dissatisfaction with his life, maybe checking out permanently is the answer?  But he's told in a hallucination (near death experience?) by a soldier he had met who was killed in Vietnam, still missing an arm in the afterlife, "Dying doesn't make you whole."

http://www.tvgasm.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/MM610Private.jpg

What makes you whole is coming to terms with the demons, both psychological and literal, that are haunting you, acknowledging personal responsibility for your sinful behavior and surrendering to God, with the understanding that control apart from God is an illusion.  Don is constantly running, seeking escape in drinking and sex, but remaining unsatisfied because when he wakes up the next morning hung over and alone he's back where started, the same person with the same problems, even if he's taken another man's name.  In life if we don't take the steps to break the cycle of sin then we just keep hurling down a corkscrew shaped slide, repeating the same turns but into deeper and deeper levels of depravity and self destruction until we hit the ground in a dead stop.

Addiction is real, but is not a life sentence.  I know people who have been in Alcoholics Anonymous, sober for decades, that will also say that sobriety doesn't come to everyone on the first try.  It's surrender to what they call a "Higher Power," but also depending on sponsors, friends, family, as well as coming to grips with why drinking has become problematic that will bring ultimate liberation.  There may be set backs along the way, but they can be overcome if these safeguards are in place. Again, being honest with ourselves and allowing ourselves to confront the underlying issues of our lives is also important.  As people who suffer from compulsive eating disorders will say, The problem isn't what you're eating, it's what's eating you.  In the case of Don, he has issues with intimacy, he's a father who had no solid role model himself.  He never knew his mother, and any mother figure in his life was either cruel or took advantage of him somehow.  Does he need a therapist?  You bet ya.  But he also needs God, and to surrender to His loving mercy if he is going to get past the hurts, the addictions and the self destruction.  If not he'll be just spinning around that corkscrew until he lands face down in the dirt.

This is incomplete, but I've written way too much already.  Another major theme running through the show is what is the nature of happiness.  In my season ending analysis of Mad Men season 6, I'll hit this topic, as well as tidy up this one. 

Monday, June 10, 2013

The Pope Francis: Real Conversion is the Work of the Spirit



The Vatican YouTube page has been posting the Holy Father's morning homily almost every day since shortly after his election.  Pope Francis gives a simple, extemporaneous reflection on the readings of the day, and as we can see from the video he enjoys a rather mixed group of people at Mass.  Enjoy.

Friday, June 7, 2013

A Reflection on the Sacred Heart

I posted two videos below about today's Solemnity of the Sacred Heart; one from the Apostleship of Prayer and the other from Canada's Salt and Light Channel.  Both say better than I can what this feast and the devotion it celebrates is all about.  But I do want to touch upon something Fr. Thomas Rosica said in his presentation; that devotion to the Sacred Heart has been on the decline, and actually denigrated by some, in the Church over the last fifty years, and what a tragedy that is.


The Second Vatican Council called for a renewal of popular devotions in the Church, with emphasis placed on the scriptural roots and significance of the various practices of piety prevailing among the faithful.  Devotions should also be revised so as to lead people naturally into the celebration of the Church's Liturgy, Her official public worship.  New Stations of the Cross services, for instance, were written up with lengthy scriptural passages included for each station.  An attempt was made to revise the Stations completely, replacing the non scripture based stations with ones culled directly from the Gospel accounts, but this never caught on.  The more direct linking of the Stations to the Scripture was a good thing, to put it mildly.

In the case of the Sacred Heart liturgists and theologians found little scriptural basis to support it at all.  Jesus simply doesn't talk much about the heart, outside saying that his was meek and humble (Mt. 11:29).  The Old Testament uses different imagery, unrelated to our understanding the heart as a symbol of love, to express the love of God for His people.  The fact that it was based on a private revelation made it even more suspect in the minds of would be Post Conciliar reformers.  This suspicion of private revelation is a reason behind the resistance of some pastors and liturgical experts to the newer devotion to the Divine Mercy (a discussion for another day).  There is a bigger issue here, about the divide between the simple faith of the people and the intellectualized faith of a professional religious caste in the Church, but, again, this is a fight for another day.  Suffice it to say, many in seminary and university theology programs have promoted the idea that popular devotions are anti Scriptural by nature and divert people from participating in the liturgy, to the detriment of the spiritual life of the faithful.

The tragedy of the decline of the Sacred Heart is that this and other devotions are not anti-Scriptural nor anti-Liturgy if they are authentic and well prepared.

First the fact that a particular devotion was born of a private revelation shouldn't scare people off.  Scripture and Tradition are the two fonts of the same Revelation of God.  In a way, we can say that the Tradition represents the continued handing on of what was received by the Spirit, a Spirit that continues to lead the people of God into all truth.  While we are never obliged to believe in a private revelation, if the Church in Her wisdom, under the guidance of the Holy Spirit of truth, has approved one as worthy of public devotion, and even establishes a solemnity in its honor, we can trust that it is in keeping with Divine Revelation.  In the case of the Sacred Heart it is speaking to people today, in a language we can understand, of the deep love Christ has for us, which is at the very core of Scripture.

Secondly, the devotion to the Sacred Heart has an intrinsic Eucharistic connection.  If it is properly understood and practiced it should lead us to Adoration of the Blessed Sacrament, then to participation in the Eucharistic Liturgy with sacramental reception of our Lord's Body and Blood (the Sacrament of Charity) and finally living the charity that we celebrate by service of our neighbor.  If this has not been the case in the past, I would argue the problem is not with the devotion but with how we have handled it.

The good news is that in the past twenty years we have seen an renewed interest in Eucharistic Adoration (another bogey man of many self professed religious progressives), as well as an explosion in devotion to the Divine Mercy (one that I haven't personally embraced as a part of my spiritual life, but still promote in the parish).  These and other devotions are ways of  continuing to raise our minds and hearts to God through out the day, and between celebrations of the Eucharist.  If they are done well, they serve as a link between our lives "on the street," our participation in the Liturgy, and then our return to the world to live the mysteries we celebrate.

My hope and prayer is that this great devotion to the Sacred Heart also makes a similar come back.  It touches so beautifully on our Lord's tender, passionate, human love for us (in the best sense of what these words mean), and His Divine power to save us.
.

Solemnity of the Sacred Heart of Jesus from Salt and Light